3 ms·
While I agree with the underlying point that most people grow their spending with their job, I strongly disagree that "it's not just about discipline or will".
by JoshTriplett 14y ago
While I agree with the underlying point that most people grow their spending with their job, I strongly disagree that "it's not just about discipline or will". It really does come down to wanting less and buying less. I don't know in what absurd world you "need" to spend $300k to keep a $400k job, or even $80k to keep a $100k job. Nothing stops you from having a six-figure salary and living like a college student.
That represents one of the most critical financial lessons of all time: your salary and your expenses do not need to correlate, so don't let them.
- HarryHirsch 14y ago> your salary and your expenses do not need to correlate, so don't let them. Wishing it doesn't make it so. In a previous life I applied to a business consultancy in Britain. (Ernst & Young? Andersen? Can't remember. It was long ago.) To get you into the mood, they had a little quiz on their website. One question went like this: "You have worked 12 hours on a report that is due the day after tomorrow and are tired. Your officemates want to go for beers. (This is Britain, and "beers" means many beers.) Will you join them?" Of course you join them says the website, you are supposed to work hard and party hard. These are the social pressures that michaelochurch talks about, they are very real, and what you do and where you live will affect your chances of promotion. For an insight I do recommend Karen Ho's "Liquidated", it's an anthropological study of Wall Street.
- rwallace 14y agoThere are two different mechanisms being pointed out, and it's important to understand the distinction. The first is the tendency for your burn rate to drift up to match your neighbors. Even when encouraged by your neighbors being assholes about it, that is a matter of discipline; if your discipline is in the top ninety-whatever percentile, it is possible to stop yourself doing this. The second is the fact that some companies attach to some jobs very high unpaid expenses that they dishonestly don't point out until after your working for the company, e.g. refusing to give you a high-paid job unless you drive to work in an expensive car. There's nothing to be done about that in the first sense; if they won't give you the job unless you spend much of your salary on these unpaid expenses, then they won't. What you need to do in this case is recognize such jobs, subtract the unpaid expenses from your after-tax salary, and make your decision whether to accept the job or walk away, based on your take-home pay after expenses, not before.
- jvoorhis 14y agoI don't follow your second point. In what situation would one be offered this position when they do not already own the expensive car, and after accepting it, how would they be coerced into buying such a car in order to keep their job?
- rwallace 14y agoWell if you look at what other people have been saying, one way this can happen is as a condition of the promotion that will get you the high salary you were aiming for.