4 ms·
A couple of questions if you don't mind 1. Private security firms are apparently taking over huge swathes of the not-actually-being-shot-at roles. Are those "
by lifeisstillgood 14y ago
A couple of questions if you don't mind
1. Private security firms are apparently taking over huge swathes of the not-actually-being-shot-at roles. Are those "soldiers" required to do the same policy busy work?
2. US Armed forces (incl reserve) is nearly 3m. Is that simply too big?
3. I thought the patten quote earlier solved this one - no policy or training DVD tells you what to do, it's telling you how.
- Tloewald 14y agoIt seems to me that the root of the US militaey's problems is that it's a giant peacetime military. Until WWII the US military was small in peacetime so that when there was a war promotions based on real performance eventually overwhelmed the peacetime leadership. It's impractical for the US to have a tiny military, but reducing it by 2/3 should be doable if anyone has the political means.
- chrissnell 14y agoThat's already happening. We're thinning down rapidly and we're doing it in a smart way. Attrition by the stupid. Do cocaine at a club on the weekend? You're gone. DWI? See ya. Fail body fat standards continually or fail to pass the physical fitness test? You're on your way out. Keep only the best.
- tanzam75 14y agoThat's a start, but it only gets rid of the stupid people. It leaves the people who are great at checking things off on a list. As long as they stay out of trouble, they might muddle along for decades, until finally retiring as an O-6.
- stan_rogers 14y agoSorry, but that's just not the case anymore. There's a lot more to weapons systems now than simply figuring out which end to point at the thing you want to hurt. Even getting a straight-leg infanteer up to speed takes more than a couple of weeks these days, and that doesn't begin to account for any of the more sophisticated tools that need trained operators and maintainers. There are some trades (MOCs) you can populate relatively quickly, but there are a whole big bunch of them that take years in peacetime (though you could break some of them down into smaller specialties and fast-track it to months at the expense of having people who know the whole system in wartime). It stopped being about getting a horde of young men to walk slowly and bravely into machine gun fire a long time ago.
- Tloewald 14y agoThis may be true, but we don't need to outspend the rest of the world on defense in "peace" time. I'd also argue that we're very good at building insanely difficult to use systems. Perhaps if getting users up to speed with weapon systems were a design priority this wouldn't be true. After all, everywhere else but the military tech gets more powerful and simpler to use.
- stan_rogers 14y ago> After all, everywhere else but the military tech gets more powerful and simpler to use. And more disposable. If your modern whiz-bang gizmo dies in the field on civvy street, that may mean a trip to the store. Even those things that can be repaired or worked around are beyond the knowledge and capabilities of most owners/users these days. If it happens on the battlefield, you're dead if you're relying on things you don't understand and can't at least jury-rig to work when they go bing. And no, you can't reschedule. And along with the training you need to make it work, you'd damned well better have the conditioning that allows you to use the training when your own personal ass is on the line. If you are to have a military at all these days, it pretty much has to be a standing military (regular plus reserves). Ad hoc forces are cannon fodder and little more.
- chrissnell 14y agoOK, I'll do my best here. Obviously, these are my opinions and not official answers. 1. It's not only private security firms; the military uses private contractors for all sorts of tasks and they are subject to just as much administrative overhead. That said, the ending of major operations in Iraq and Afghanistan has led to a significant downsizing of the military. During the height of the Iraq surge (2007), gates at bases back home were all manned by private security because the Military Police were all deployed downrange. Same thing with dining facilities and a million other support functions. Now that we're downsizing, we've pulled our troops back home and Soldiers are once again serving our food, guarding our gates and fixing our vehicles. This is a Good Thing, in my opinion. 2. I don't think so. From a civilian's perspective, that number may seem huge. Just how many people do you need firing guns, anyway, right? The truth is that a huge percentage of those forces work in support functions: repairing equipment, delivering food and fuel, maintaining communications systems, etc. For every door kicker, there's at least a few (if not dozens of???) Soldiers who support him. The nature of global threats continue to evolve but the importance of deterrence remains the same. For better or for worse, this country has amazing resources and if we didn't protect it, another bully on the block is going to make a grab for it. 3. If only that quote solved it for us. Sadly, we've moved far beyond the kinetic Army of Patton's day into a zero-defect organization where any problem is automatically deemed unacceptable and must be fixed.
- eru 14y ago> [...] and Soldiers are once again serving our food, guarding our gates and fixing our vehicles. This is a Good Thing, in my opinion. Why?
- chrissnell 14y agoSimple: these are functions that a field army must perform during a major combat operation. (examples: Battle of the Bulge, 2003 Invasion of Iraq, Desert Storm, etc.). You can't use civilian contractors to fix vehicles alongside of the road under enemy fire. This dangerous work has to be done by Soldiers. These Soldiers need to be trained in their jobs to perform well in combat and these peacetime functions are the best training we can provide here at home.