3 ms·
Dup: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=529552 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=529552 And the messages there indicate this device probably isn't practical
by ars 18y ago
Dup: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=529552 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=529552
And the messages there indicate this device probably isn't practical, it has too many caveats. And if you want to do this, you attach one to the main sewer stack of the whole house - it's been available for about 20 years.
- noonespecial 18y agoIf your house is older and has copper sewer piping, it does an excellent job of radiating that heat back into your house. What you save heating water might not be too far off the heat you don't have to use your furnace to make.
- lutorm 18y agoPipes generally don't go in your living spaces, they might heat your basement but that's not really where you want the heat.
- noonespecial 18y agoNearly all heat that starts in your basement ends up in your house. It has nowhere else to go. The copper pipes in our basement ran directly beneath the floor of the bedroom. A fine warm strip would develop whenever someone took a shower. By the time it got to the exit point in the house, the pipe was barely warm enough to notice. That is not negligible heat transfer considering its "free".
- pingswept 18y agoThe heat in your basement does actually have somewhere else to go. Typically, uninsulated basement walls and floor are near the temperature of the surrounding earth, which ranges between 45-55 F depending on how far down you are on the wall and your latitude. Heat conduction between basement air and those cold surfaces is not negligible on the scale of home heating.
- lutorm 18y agoThe trouble with that is that by mixing the hot drain water with cold water you spend the energy heating the cold water and lose efficiency. You want to avoid the cold toilet flush water and whatever and just get the "hot stuff".
- ars 18y agoDon't warm the entire cold water supply - just what goes to the water heater. But do it in the basement, where all the pipes already are, not under the shower, and not with a small device that is likely to get clogged.
- Vivtek 18y agoNo, he means that by putting this on the main sewer, you are running your cold drainwater through the same exchanger. If you put one under the shower only, you know you're starting with hot water. Really, if you were starting fresh, you'd probably want a hot drain and a cold drain down in the basement.
- adoyle 18y agoUnless you're refrigerating your water, the water going down the drain will always be warmer or at the same temperature as the incoming supply. Since these things don't hold water, they exchange the heat as the incoming and outgoing streams move past each other, thus the effect is essentially null when you're using cold water (brushing teeth) and positive when you're using hot water (shower). When you're using water "asynchronously" (bath, toilet), there's no effect since the incoming and outgoing water move at different times.
- pmjordan 18y agoAgain, this is about efficiency, allow me to explain in more detail: The rate of heat transfer is proportional to temperature difference. If you have a predetermined amount of time for the heat to be extracted, you will get more out of a small amount of hot water than a large amount of tepid water, even if the total energy from the temperature delta to cool incoming water is equal. The predetermined amount of time is given by the hot water capacity of this device and the flow rate - i.e. how much time does a litre of waste water spend in the exchanger when the shower is in operation. Plus, there are other practical advantages to using only water coming from the shower, washing machine, etc., as it will normally not contain large particles that could clog things up, particularly when the water is stagnant or slow-flowing in the exchanger. Finally, you'd ideally feed this still relatively clean water back into the cisterns of the toilets, which don't need to run on drinking water.