3 ms·
> At the point that there is such a huge variation in practice, for most of these steps, I can't imagine that they are very significant/important. It seems a l
by munificent 14y ago
> At the point that there is such a huge variation in practice, for most of these steps, I can't imagine that they are very significant/important.
It seems a little premature to jump to that conclusion. The US and Great Britain are entirely different countries with different geography, climate, history, culture, laws, economies, etc.
Farming doesn't exist in a vaccum. It's affected by all of that, so it stands to reason that those things will influence policies and practices.
What I found interesting about the article was that while each system was different, each was internally cohesive. Trying to cherrypick one facet of one country's system and applying to the other would almost invariably make things worse. You have to understand the entire system.
That's an important lesson to keep in mind when we constantly read articles like "Country X does Y and it makes Z B% better so we should too!" We need to always remember that X is doing Y in some context that likely matters deeply.
- mturmon 14y agoSmart comment. It's like each country is an ecosystem, which has evolved procedures that work. Still, each could be informed by the other. Presumably at the annual "International Conference on Egg Hygiene and Fowl Maintenance".
- alphaoverlord 14y ago> It seems a little premature to jump to that conclusion. The US and Great Britain are entirely different countries with different geography, climate, history, culture, laws, economies, etc. I would say that there is also significant intra-country variation. I have a hard time imagining that there isn't some part of the US where conditions are not similar to the UK. At the point that these regulations work for these locales, I don't see compelling evidence that it wouldn't work elsewhere. My argument isn't that there isn't culture, climate, or a variety of other factors that influence how things are done - rather, at the point that there is variation, but they all generally work, I have a hard time imagining each of them are important. > What I found interesting about the article was that while each system was different, each was internally cohesive. Hence the idea that these narratives are contrived. If we look at any system (that works/is real), there is internal consistency. It is very easy to point to any particular aspect of the system, and say that it is crucial/unique/signifantly valid and valuable. I would say that this argument is very similar to creationism arguments that the universe's constants/parameters are uniquely functional because we are here. I'm not saying it can't be true, but it seems like a logical fallacy to presume that a particular aspect causes the system in place.
- pixl97 14y agoU.S. has the FDA so food regulations tend to get applied equally across the country, even if it doesn't make sense.
- tantalor 14y agoIn other words, each country is approaching a distinct local optimum.