4 ms·
Experts can go wrong, too - and who defines who is an expert and who isn't? Some amateurs might have read more about the issue than the self-proclaimed experts.
by Tichy 18y ago
Experts can go wrong, too - and who defines who is an expert and who isn't? Some amateurs might have read more about the issue than the self-proclaimed experts.
And if non-experts are not qualified to speak, how do you justify letting them vote? Not saying democracy is perfect, but apparently there was a thought that even if people are not experts, they might be able to inform themselves sufficiently to be able to decide which experts to trust.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoGreat point Tichy. The entire democratic system is built on the ability for the common man to make decisions about matters in which he is not an expert. This is my problem with the global warming discussion, no matter what the outcome -- no matter who is right or wrong on it. At the heart of it, it's a threat to the core principles underlying the vote. That's why it's near the top of my list of political things to care about.
- Rod 18y agoScience is not programming. You can't learn Climate Modeling in your spare time, without checking experimental data and interacting with other people. Scientists should investigate and report their findings. Politicians should decide what to do. People elect politicians, not scientists. That's the way it should work. Democracy is not in danger. However, we now see politicians doing (pseudo-)science (Al Gore is a prime example) and reporting it to the ignorant masses. And we have scientists claiming that they should decide what to do. The world is upside down.
- Tichy 18y agoNot every climate expert has run a climate model in his head. Presumably sometimes they also just read papers about other people's results, and assign the a likelihood based on their own experiences. Maybe they are better at estimating likelihoods, but other than that, not so different from the common person in the street. Even without knowledge in climate modeling, some things can be easily seen. For example it seems obvious that there is a debate on man made warming - some experts seem to consider it likely, others not. Credentials of experts can be checked to some degree without expertise in climate modeling, too. And so on - at every level of knowledge, it is possible to make an estimate of the probabilities, I should think. Also, I think it is often politicians who decide which scientists get funding for their research, so in a way people do elect scientists (not sure how the system works in the US).
- Rod 18y ago"Also, I think it is often politicians who decide which scientists get funding for their research, so in a way people do elect scientists (not sure how the system works in the US)." You are totally right. And, in my humble opinion, it's dangerous when politicians alone decide what should be investigated and studied. It creates a situation where "intellectual prostitution" is the norm. Scientists know what the funding agencies want to hear, and write grant proposals accordingly. A monoculture is born. No one works outside the mainstream ideas. Focusing on some areas is good because it creates momentum and leads to faster progress. For instance, in the 1950s and 1960s, the investment in the space program led to an amazingly fast progress. This was good. Entire new fields were developed. On the other hand, when the government alone decides that a certain area is "evil" (e.g., stem cell research) then we have a "New Inquisition" in place. This is very bad. In an ideal world, scientists would report their findings, politicians would propose courses of action, and people would vote for one proposal over the others. The real world is a whole lot less perfect.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- robotrout 18y agoI assume it's the democracy bit that is your core premise. I'm not certain which country you live in. If you're in the U.S., you're not living in a democracy, you're living in a republic. There is a strong agenda by many people to turn it into a democracy, merely by saying it is one, and that is working, but by law, it's a republic. Democracies tend to disintegrate rapidly as the populace votes themselves beer and circuses. You see that beginning to happen now, don't you? The populace is not, and can not, be trusted to act in a fair, impartial, and informed manner. They're a mob. Look at the public lynching we almost had with the AIG folks? Even the attorneys general of New York and Connecticut got into the act. When the populace proves themselves too lazy to carefully consider the repercussions of their decisions, and too proud to admit they do not know the repercussions of their decisions, then it can't end well. This will not end well.
- jobeirne 18y agoVery frighteningly, accurately, and succinctly put.
- Tichy 18y agoWhat is the specialty of the Republic? I guess there are laws that the zombie masses have to adhere to, but these laws were once upon a time also created by people. I don't want to defend democracy, but it seems that it is not trivial to come up with a better system, and "don't give non-experts the permission to speak" won't cut it in my opinion. As soon as you start going down that road, a lot of other issues crop up.
- eru 18y agoA better model: Perhaps smaller democracies? Instead of everyone having 1/300,000,000-say in 300,000,000 lives, let them have bigger chunk in smaller systems. Stronger, faster and more direct feedback can enhance control loops without adding more sophistication otherwise. More data usually beats better algorithms. (http://anand.typepad.com/datawocky/2008/03/more-data-usual.html http://anand.typepad.com/datawocky/2008/03/more-data-usual.h...)