3 ms·
Making it deductible by everyone would help. As would taxing it no matter who pays. I can't see any good reason why health insurance should be tax deductible
by yummyfajitas 14y ago
Making it deductible by everyone would help.
As would taxing it no matter who pays.
I can't see any good reason why health insurance should be tax deductible - it's a private good with minimal external benefits.
- Spooky23 14y agoHuh? Say you're a parent. You have a house and three kids. Your spouse makes alot less than you do. Then you get afflicted with a chronic disease like MS. Without healthcare, you eventually cannot perform at work and get fired or laid off. You have some sort of episode, and end up in the ER. You can't pay your mortgage, and you cannot replace your income. So you stop paying the mortgage and go on food stamps. Then your house gets foreclosed. Next, your spouse leaves you and takes the kids. You're indigent, your kids are now on Medicaid (at taxpayer expense) and getting assistance for housing. You're behind on child support because your disability case was rejected and your appealing it. If you add up the costs, you'll find that the cost of providing deductiblity is lower than the costs of all of the other outcomes. Actually, a year of healthcare probably costs less than that 1 ER visit.
- jonknee 14y agoThere are a lot of things that are required in life and that are not deductible. Right now the deduction increases prices and makes changing jobs a lot more risky / a pain. Also, corporate write-offs for health insurance benefits has nothing to do with what happens to your healthcare when you get laid off. If anything not having it be deductible would help because then you're insurance has no reason to be tied to your employment so you could just pay for it yourself like you do anything else. What would fix your scenario is universal healthcare.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoSay you're a parent, and you work at a job which requires you to wear pants. Without pants, you cannot perform at work and get fired or laid off. [Insert rest of your sad story here.] Therefore, purchasing pants should be tax deductible.
- khuey 14y agoYou don't see an external benefit in encouraging people to buy healthcare so that society doesn't have to pay for it later (via Medicare or the emergency room)?