7 ms·
Google services should not require real names: Vint Cerf
- trhtrsh 14y agoG+ official tagline is "Google+ makes connecting on the web more like connecting in the real world." Google has not required Real (legal) Names for quite a while now. Google requires your "Common Name", which is the name you use with your friends, family, or coworkers. And there is an undocumented policy that the name has to look "middle-class", have 1-3 spaces in it, and not look too artsy. http://support.google.com/plus/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=1228271 http://support.google.com/plus/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answe... If your friends call you Mini Kites, Google+ won't shut you down. And if Google+ challenges you on a name violation, you can "clear your name" with purely online-evidence, if you like.
- tveita 14y ago> And if Google+ challenges you on a name violation, you can "clear your name" with purely online-evidence, if you like. Their help page states that you may appeal with "Proof of an established identity online with a significant following" That's more of a celebrity clause than an actual solution for real users. Yes, if you're Lady Gaga or 50 Cent, or if you're just an internet personality with enough followers to raise a stink about being blocked, then you'll get your pseudonymous account. The rest of us will be named what Google tells us to be named, or stay out.
- walshemj 14y agoSounds rather French you have to use a name approved by Google - France used to until recently only allow certain names to be used by law.
- huggah 14y agoWithout testing, I'm not sure, but I think Mini Kites is actually likely to be a flagged name. The last vestiges of the "real names" policy are really just to keep businesses from getting Google+ profiles (Google wants businesses to keep Google+ pages instead). So there's an ML algorithm that determines how name-y or business-y a given name is, and flags names that it thinks belong to companies rather than people. I suspect Mini Kites (and almost certainly MiniKites or Mini-Kites) would trigger the review process.
- jgw 14y agoI'm still not entirely clear on what Google's policy is on real names, even after reading it. Is it acceptable to have an account with a fictitious name in addition to one's own account? It's not clear to me from their policy whether this is allowed or not. I had assumed not, but I know of at least one G+ "Suggested User" who maintains an account under a different name.
- Terretta 14y ago> "Using real names is useful," Cerf said. "But I don't think it should be forced on people, and I don't think we do." I guess he hasn't seen YouTube's argumentative 'give us your real name and link our accounts' wizard, then. While you can find a way to answer the questions to keep your handle, you may have to lie to do so.
- RobAtticus 14y agoWhat? Just say no when prompted by the dialog. It then says they are considering other options and asks you which you'd prefer. There is no lying involved. Edit: To clarify, I'm not saying Youtube's dialog is a good thing. I'm just saying there is no lying involved and it's rather trivial (albeit annoying) to dismiss it without having to lie or use your real name.
- bluntly_said 14y agoIt's a dialog that shows up every time I log into youtube, and requires (as of the last time I went through it) clicking about 5 different buttons to keep my real name off the service. I didn't have to lie, but it DEMANDED that I select a reason for not wanting my name on the service, and you can tell they're trying to get users to cave and just click "yes" once. It's shitty, argumentative, and unpleasant to use.
- lawdawg 14y agoIf it asks you more than once after selecting a reason for picking no, then its a bug. I hear your complaint a lot, but I've never seen it happen in person to anyone I know personally.
- lucian1900 14y agoMy anecdote beats yours. I've never seen it do anything other than ask on every login.
- 14y ago
- netrus 14y agoDoes Google actually ask for validation of user names? I prefer real names for aesthetic reasons, but if someone chooses to make up a false name, i wouldn't bother.
- Trufa 14y agoThey worry because they want G+ etc to be your real identity much like facebook. I had a nickname in Facebook, they found out and they put my name and I can't change it back. I'm not saying it's right or wrong, there are some very valid arguments for allowing fictional names (privacy, security, etc). They mainly not want to go back to the day were everything was mydodoname123.
- minikites 14y agoWho is harmed by a "Real Names" policy? http://geekfeminism.wikia.com/wiki/Who_is_harmed_by_a_%22Real_Names%22_policy%3F http://geekfeminism.wikia.com/wiki/Who_is_harmed_by_a_%22Rea...
- smokinjoe 14y agoWouldn't the people who perform much of this harassment also fall under this "Real Names" policy? While I'm not saying that the issues would be completely eliminated, could this perhaps be progress towards reducing such cases?
- nollidge 14y agoThere's not much social cost to harassing someone within the limits of the law. Or even just outside the limits, since police rarely are willing/able to do much about online misdemeanors.
- smokinjoe 14y agoWell, you can ban the person - and I would believe that some people's vitriol would substantially decrease if they had their names tagged on a particularly hateful statement. And if these Real Names were consistently kept accurate, wouldn't it be easier to sift through and ban offenders?
- nollidge 14y agoYes, but this only affects people's online activities. It additionally forces otherwise innocent people to open themselves up to offline, real-life harassment.
- smokinjoe 14y agoI just don't find that reason enough to completely eradicate the progression towards holding people accountable for their actions online.
- AdrenalinMd 14y agoI was never able to use google+, I always have "Your profile has been suspended.". Screw google plus.. http://i.imgur.com/frHh5dt.png http://i.imgur.com/frHh5dt.png
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- webwanderings 14y ago> ... there are cases where in the transactions both parties really need to know who are we talking to. This coming from a search company? What else do they have. A free email. You need two parties verifying each other via free email? What else. Ads. There's only a single party in Ads. What am I missing here?
- spiralpolitik 14y agoYou are starting from the premise that Google is a search company. They are not. They are an advertising company. The advertising company needs to know your real name as it is more attractive to clients to know they are dealing with a real person viewing their advertisements rather than a legend. The advertising company can charge more money and target advertisements better. You are also working from the premise that you are one of the parties in the transaction. You are not. You are the product being sold.
- webwanderings 14y agoI think based on the content of the linked article, it appears that he's talking about non-advertising situation, i.e credit card transactions or otherwise. From that perspective, it does however makes sense that "both parties know each other". However, I agree with the rest of your comment.
- yuhong 14y agoI am not for real name policies, but I do want the problems with posting under real names to be fixed if possible.
- summerdown2 14y agoThe major unexamined assumption here for me is that identity is unitary. In fact I have different names for different groups and I don't want them linked together. And that doesn't mean by everyone except Google. I don't want Google to consider me a single identity across its different accounts, either.
- roc 14y ago> "I don't want Google to consider me a single identity across its different accounts, either." Good luck with that. I've had Google prompt me to associate separate accounts across different domains (each driven by google apps). And I've had Google prompt me to merge what it determined were 'duplicate' email addresses into one contact for several of my friends/family -- it connected work accounts, pseudonymous webmail accounts, personal domain accounts, etc. You may not want to make the connection official, and I understand and respect that. But Google already has the data to know with some confidence. And that's not just a hypothetical capability; they're demonstrably doing it.
- tveita 14y agoA good and well thought-out appeal on the Google+ naming issue: https://plus.google.com/103112149634414554669/posts/WAu688n8JgZ https://plus.google.com/103112149634414554669/posts/WAu688n8... Even after they allegedly changed it to allow "well-known" pseudonyms, the Google+ naming policy just seems arbitrary and pointless to me. Real names that look fake get blocked, while fake names that look real stay. People who want to follow the TOS will stay away, while people who do not care will sign up. I'd consider using a nickname a "web best practice". It takes minimal effort, is unlikely to confuse anyone you actually know, and lets you compartmentalize your interactions better than any "circle". I am disappointed that Google is trying to discourage it.
- mullingitover 14y agoThe whole 'we changed our policy, you can now add a pseudonym field to your profile' was total bullshit in my experience. I tried adding 'mullingitover' as a pseudonym and got shot down. WTF is the point of adding a pseudonym field and then being inscrutable and pedantic about what you'll allow there? That was the day I stopped going to G+, and the day Google lost a boatload of my goodwill.
- siculars 14y agoYou do not have to look far as to why one might want to remain anonymous. I submit The Federalist Papers[0] as exhibit A. If the Founding Fathers deemed it necessary to publish under a pseudonym then who are the likes of Facebook and Google to say otherwise? Yes, you may say that FB and Google are private entities and as such we must play by their rules. But I would retort that FB and Google are the default market places of the day for connecting with people and spreading ones ideas. I submit they have an obligation to maintain anonymity for those that choose to remain anonymous. The Federalist Papers were not self published. They were published by The Independent Journal[1], a journal of the day. That journal saw fit to publish those works anonymously under a pseudonym. Anonymous publication must remain a viable avenue in the digital future if we are to maintain our character as a free nation. There can be no two ways about it. [0]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federalist_Papers http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federalist_Papers [1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Independent_Journal http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Independent_Journal
- eurleif 14y ago>But I would retort that FB and Google are the default market places for connecting with people and spreading ones ideas. "Default marketplace" != only marketplace. Was The Independent Journal, which published the Federalist Papers, the largest publication around at the time? Did it matter, as long as the Federalist Papers got published somewhere?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- arindone 14y agoIt's often not said enough, but the goal of Facebook during its history has always been to connect <i>real</i> people -- places like Twitter offer the opportunity to create humorous pseudonyms and fake identities, but Facebook (and Google+ for that matter) are about connecting people and fleshing out those connections. A point that's overlooked: MySpace allowed pseudonyms to run free and wild, but that's what made the connections on the site all-the-more shallow.
- orangethirty 14y agoReal names for standard web usage does not benefit anyone except Google. With it they can track you more effectively, which is the only reason they demand it. There is no value for the user. No matter what they say. Note that Nuuton does feature a good naming policy: Nicknames are encouraged.
- Executor 14y agoIt's about time this opinion started spreading. Let's hope we can change google... though I doubt they'd be moved by a news article.