3 ms·
For people using old X programs it's probably still sending X core protocol messages, but you're right that there are misunderstandings. What I and most people
by rwmj 14y ago
For people using old X programs it's probably still sending X core protocol messages, but you're right that there are misunderstandings. What I and most people want is "ssh [-Y]" to continue to transparently forward the display so we can run programs. Luckily it seems that xpra[1] will do this for Wayland at some point, although the real test will be how simple it is to set up (like ssh -Y it should Just Work for the majority of users).
[1] http://xpra.org/ http://xpra.org/
- zanny 14y agoFrom my understanding, it seems like what we want is a VNC switch in ssh rather than necessarilly display server specific functionality. Go even further and maybe the ssh server could just use the RFB protocol vnc uses. Any Linux VNC server worth its salt already support tunneling RFB over ssh. To take it a step further, you would just need very little display server support for an ssh server to request the framebuffer of an application it opens and send it via RFB or the vnc server to the client. And I'd imagine Wayland already has some mechanism for other applications to read somethings frames. If it is generic enough, ssh should be able to use that. My only concern is that Wayland would need to be rendering programs but not displaying them locally, and I don't have any understanding of Wayland's internal implementation enough to know if it supports hidden windows like that.
- joeyo 14y agoThank you so much for pointing out xpra. I've been wanting this exact feature for years. I frequently use Matlab on remote servers (they're closer to the data and faster than my laptop). I've been mostly able to get by through a combination of tmux, matlab -nodisplay, and rendering plots to files, but it's a less than ideal solution. Xpra does exactly what I need and it's glorious. Many thanks again.