3 ms·
This article has more than a little shadenfruede, methinks. But there's an interesting thesis lurking in there, that Porter's theories have lead directly to the
by javajosh 14y ago
This article has more than a little shadenfruede, methinks. But there's an interesting thesis lurking in there, that Porter's theories have lead directly to the enshrinement of C-level executives as a kind of upper-class:
first, that strategy is a decision-making sport involving
the selection of markets and products; second, that the
decisions are responsible for all of the value creation
of a firm (or at least the “excess profits,” in Porter’s
model); and, third, that the decider is the CEO. Strategy,
says Porter, speaking for all the strategists, is thus
‘the ultimate act of choice.’
The article doesn't go on to talk about what a C-level exec actually is but makes an emphatic case that, since Porter is responsible for the crowning of these kings, and now Porter is proven wrong, then perhaps it's time to take the crowns away.
I'm terribly biased, but I like this line of argument very much.
- paulsutter 14y agoRight so Steve Jobs, Elon Musk, Mark Zuckerberg, Larry Page ... all empty figureheads, deserving little credit for the success of their companies?
- asimjalis 14y agoWhen people misspell schadenfreude I am secretly happy.