11 ms·
Are You Living in a Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zone?
- downandout 14y agoAppalling, but sadly, not at all surprising. We have not-so-slowly been losing our rights for a very long time.
- JulianMorrison 14y agoIt's the other way around. The America the constitution talks about never existed. Most especially if you were black or female, but even if you were white and male if you were poor, or a union organizer, or a communist, or an anarchist, or a protester, or a striker, or a member of an unusual religion. In fact basically it was a pack of lies for anyone not already in the mainstream elite. And if you are in the mainstream elite in 2013, rest assured, this one does not apply to you either. In fact, the virtue of the constitution is that as a lie, it has inspired people to strive to demand it become true. And slowly by piecemeal, always hard fought for, always opposed, the golden age of the past that never existed is being constructed in the present.
- icebraining 14y agoOr a descendant of Japanese people: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_American_internment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_American_internment
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- phil 14y agoMichelle Malkin notwithstanding, it's pretty fucking cut and dried, and a national shame.
- vonmoltke 14y agoIn addition to what phil said, Michelle Malkin is Filipino (and born in Philly), not Japanese. In anything, that would make her biased in favor of the internment.
- venus 14y agoMichelle Malkin is not Japanese, and her book received near-universal condemnation from civil rights groups, historians and asian-americans alike. It's disturbing to me that you're referencing this piece of crap to make an apparently sincere argument that internment might actually not be a bad thing. That's all it takes, huh? edit: original comment by sp332, apparently deleted in shame > That's not as cut-and dried as it seems. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_Defense_of_Internment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_Defense_of_Internment This Japanese woman wrote a defense of the internment.
- sp332 14y agoI didn't know she wasn't Japanese. But really I was trying to find a link to the introduction since she's a lot more convincing than just me saying "someone thought it was a good idea."
- saraid216 14y agoMalkin really doesn't qualify as a credible source for, well... anything. You would have been better off pulling her bibliography.
- mikeash 14y agoWhat is the supposed rationale for Japanese internment being a good idea? Was it the supposed danger to the Japanese themselves from retribution? Why didn't that happen elsewhere, where they were not interned, if so? Was it the risk that Axis sympathizers would sabotage the war effort? If so, why did this never happen in Hawaii, which was so full of Japanese-descended Americans that internment simply could not be done?
- sp332 14y agoThe specific point that I recall was that it was impossible to ask Japanese living in America to deny one of their countries and adhere completely to the other. They were both Japanese and American and would therefore be hopelessly compromised if they had to pick a side.
- crusso 14y agoThe Japanese American Internment was the result of Roosevelt's extra-Constitutional power grab. The Founders had no intention for Congress to ever abdicate so much power to the Executive.
- andrewflnr 14y agoThat's the point. There have been extra-constitutional things going on from day one.
- AutoCorrect 14y agothat mar on our history should be a warning to everyone that wants the government to provide (whether it be retirement, medical, food, whatever) - the government giveth, and the government taketh away, as long as we are unresisting.
- mikeash 14y agoHold on, exactly what are you saying is the connection between e.g. socialized medicine and the Japanese internment? You seem to be saying there is one, but hell if I can figure out what it's supposed to be.
- JulianMorrison 14y agoYou really think it would have helped to resist? In a war? Also compare the fate of the native Americans who resisted.
- crusso 14y agoWhile I would agree that some segments of the population have increased in societal freedoms to a degree, the general spirit of the Constitution has been severely eroded and is being destroyed. The beauty of the Constitution was that it limited the powers of the Federal Government, allowing people to make more decisions for themselves at the individual, local, and state levels. One needs only to look at the legislative and judicial history to see that the Tenth Amendment has been largely nullified in favor of increasing Federal power. One needs only to look at the budget of the Federal government which is up around 24% of the GDP to realize that it is rather unconstrained by the narrow scope of the Constitution. The Founding Fathers were deeply paranoid of an overbearing government and an very powerful political class. That's why the Constitution was written the way it was. It was a good idea, but the best set of rules in the world can't constrain people who refuse to live by them.
- Retric 14y agoArguably the interpretation of the Constitution has changed little. It's society that's has changed. Consider, the impact of actually having cars vs people walking and the amount of constitutional protection when doing each. Cellphones and Credit cards can be traced. Email made it practical for large scale mail interception. Even just the amount of interstate commerce is so radically altered that virtually every transaction crosses state boarders. EX: Used a credit card to buy local grain, that now involves multiple states.
- rayiner 14y ago> While I would agree that some segments of the population have increased in societal freedoms to a degree If by "some segments" you 95% of the population who isn't a white, male, landowner. > The Founding Fathers were deeply paranoid of an overbearing government and an very powerful political class. This is middle school civics drivel. The dominant force in the Constitutional process were the federalists, who wanted a very strong central government. The federal government we have today is based on a reasonable reading of the Commerce Clause, which was always intended to be a very broad power and was a key piece of what the federalists wanted out of the new constitution. All that's happened since then is that we've gone from being largely self-sufficient farmers to people who even argue with each other over channels of interstate commerce.
- AutoCorrect 14y agobitter, party of one. Actually, the OP had it right the first time. We've made progress on some fronts even as the government has been growing and trying to circumvent others. Women and blacks can now vote, something which was not true in the start of this great experiment. You seem to forget (or never knew) that there is a constant tension between a government and it's citizens: the government wants more power, and the people usually want more freedom. Although if you look at the majority today, they'd rather have big brother take care of them. caveat emptor
- Torgo 14y agoYou are right, we are not losing our rights, we are losing the facade.
- jbellis 14y agoI see a bunch of stories about this recently, but they all seem to derive from this 2008 one: http://www.aclu.org/blog/technology-and-liberty/homeland-security-assuming-broad-powers-turning-vast-swaths-us http://www.aclu.org/blog/technology-and-liberty/homeland-sec... Has there been any actual new reporting since then?
- ibejoeb 14y agoCases are making their way through the courts. House v. Napolitano is the furthest along, I think. The court denied the government's motion to dismiss. http://www.uscourts.gov/Multimedia/Cameras/DistrictofMassachusetts/11-cv-10852.aspx http://www.uscourts.gov/Multimedia/Cameras/DistrictofMassach... I really think this just needs to move up the chain. I can't imagine higher level courts weakening the fourth amendment.
- largesse 14y agoIs this a case where the plaintiff actually crossed the border, or an exclusion zone case where he just happened to be within about 50 miles of the border?
- pfedor 14y agoIt was at the O'Hare airport: http://www.aclu.org/files/assets/2011.09.21_-_doc_17_-_pl._statement_of_material_facts_and_response_to_defs.__statement_of_material_f.pdf http://www.aclu.org/files/assets/2011.09.21_-_doc_17_-_pl._s...
- IheartApplesDix 14y agoWhat preschooler drew up this idea? Path of Rome, here we come!
- biot 14y agoThe solution to this is to find a whole bunch of DHS employees who feel that these seizures are unjust and who are authorized to perform seizures themselves. Then have them go around rampantly seizing as much as they can from as many high-profile people as they can. Seize the devices from judges, lawyers, congress members, TV reporters, actors, children, and so on. Only by flagrantly exercising the "rights" the DHS claims they have will sanity ultimately prevail. They may lose their jobs, but I'm sure there's people willing to make that small sacrifice for defending liberty.
- FireBeyond 14y ago"They may lose their jobs, but I'm sure there's people willing to make that small sacrifice for defending liberty." Are you? It's remarkably easy to say that getting fired from your job to make a point is but a "small sacrifice" when it's not your job, your livelihood, your family and/or home on the line. If it's such a small sacrifice, perhaps some people could game the system - apply for a job with DHS (they're hiring! https://dhs.usajobs.gov/JobSearch/Search/GetResults?Keyword=border&Location=&search.x=-1475&search.y=-403&search=Search%21&AutoCompleteSelected=False https://dhs.usajobs.gov/JobSearch/Search/GetResults?Keyword=...), and do this to make a point. In fact, I volunteer you for this noble, but small, sacrifice, that you're so willing to suggest others do.
- biot 14y agoI'm not American but if I were and working at the DHS already and hated where things have been going, then for sure I would. I spent some time in the reserves knowing full well that I could be called to defend my country with my life. How utterly trivial in comparison losing one's job is. I wouldn't recommend it for someone with a family, kids, and a mortgage but if you're young and single, why not? Who cares about keeping a job that consists of depriving your fellow citizens of their constitutional rights?
- freddealmeida 14y agoI'm not sure some one like that would actually work in the DHS. It would be anathema to them. Is it possible to sue them for this? Even if you yourself have not yet had your rights removed?
- TravisDirks 14y agoPopulation is concentrated on the coasts. Has anyone worked out what fraction of US Citizens have lost their 4th amendment rights?
- TravisDirks 14y ago"Using data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau, the ACLU has determined that nearly 2/3 of the entire US population (197.4 million people) live within 100 miles of the US land and coastal borders." From:http://www.aclu.org/national-security_technology-and-liberty/are-you-living-constitution-free-zone http://www.aclu.org/national-security_technology-and-liberty...
- eli 14y agoI think it's a story that deserves to be told, but this particular blog adds very little value over the source material the ACLU published in 2006-2008: http://www.aclu.org/national-security_technology-and-liberty/are-you-living-constitution-free-zone http://www.aclu.org/national-security_technology-and-liberty... Here's the HN discussion from two years ago: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1961071 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1961071
- OGinparadise 14y agoIn theory this makes sense: you cross the border...or live near the border...blah blah...keep US secure...blah blah... In reality, this is the latest attack and restrictions on our freedoms. Their tactic is brilliant, they pass xx laws that are unconstitutional and overwhelm the courts. Courts try to be reasonable and in many cases give half to one side and half to the other, every year. I wouldn't be surprised if you still have quite a few rights down the line but only inside your home and a few decades after that only in the bathroom.
- pfedor 14y agoLet me repeat what has been said in the other Hacker News threads about the same story: This is neither the law nor the actual practice in the US. It is just something crazy that DHS once said. If they ever actually searched someone 100 miles away from the border, that person could sue and there is no reason to believe that the verdict would be different from Almeida-Sanchez v. United States.
- ck2 14y agoWhat you are repeating is wrong. There are checkpoints a hundred miles from the border in many states and several videos of people suffering horrible results when they refuse searches at these checkpoints. The TSA also routinely performs searches far from the border with their VIPR team. (because someone might drive a train into a building? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visible_Intermodal_Prevention_and_Response_team http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visible_Intermodal_Prevention_a... )
- stock_toaster 14y agoInteresting section in that wikipedia about Amtrak temporarily banning TSA/VIPR from its property.
- ck2 14y agoThat ban is over and VIPR has been back at train stations since. Here's a story from January 2013 http://abclocal.go.com/kgo/story?section=news/local/east_bay&id=8957075 http://abclocal.go.com/kgo/story?section=news/local/east_bay... The most alarming part is how the "news" is now seemingly okay with all this.
- veidr 14y ago> This is neither the law nor the actual practice in the US. Not true; this is absolutely the actual practice in the US. Look what you have to do if you want to avoid being searched in one of these rights-exclusion zones: http://masonmark.com/mundane-american-hero/ http://masonmark.com/mundane-american-hero/
- 14y ago
- mpyne 14y agoWell on the one hand you have to draw the "customs/immigration enforcement" line somewhere. And "defense in depth" certainly makes as much sense in the real world as it does in computer security. But on the other hand I don't see a way for this to actually appreciably positively affect U.S. border security without stripping away most of what it means to be an American at all. Even random checks at a high enough interval to give a good chance at making it too risky to attempt a terrorist plot would be tremendously impacting on day-to-day life. The effect of the DHS would be much more severe than the effect of any supposed terrorists themselves! Better instead to use any such resources on things more beneficial to the common welfare, and to get rid of the extraneous legal authority.
- mutagen 14y agoA friend shared this video of assorted people exercising their fourth amendment rights at some of these internal checkpoints: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u4Ku17CqdZg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u4Ku17CqdZg Predictably it isn't long before Godwin's Law is invoked. While some were obviously successful through simple civil disobedience, I wonder how others turned out. The guy that apparently ignored an order to pull into secondary may have had a rougher go at it. The California agricultural inspections have stood up to challenge [1] and I sympathize with their purpose more so than a 'zone' including most of the population of the country. [1] http://law.justia.com/cases/california/calapp3d/104/505.html http://law.justia.com/cases/california/calapp3d/104/505.html
- RyanMcGreal 14y ago> Predictably it isn't long before Godwin's Law is invoked. The purpose of Godwin's Law is not to gainsay all comparisons to Hitler and the Nazis, but rather to gainsay inappropriate comparisons. I would argue that a US federal law enforcement checkpoint that clearly, unambiguously and persistently violates the US Bill of Rights is a reasonable place to start thinking about other governments that violate human rights. The comparison to Nazi Germany may by hyperbolic but it's not beyond the pale.
- hakaaaaak 14y agoI am in support of privacy and therefore I'm in support of the ACLU in theory on this one, but... That map is fucking ridiculous. There is no way they would search in the middle of a rural area without access from waterway, etc., and yet that is what much of this map highlights. Even if it is "factually correct", it isn't realistic, even for the most nutcase DHS employee. The everglades? Give me a fucking break. http://cdn.storyleak.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/fourth-amendment-free-zone-dhs.gif http://cdn.storyleak.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/fourth-a...
- burntsushi 14y agoHuh? That map highlights 2/3 of the country's population because of dense population centers near the coast. Just because it happens to overlap with the everglades is kind of irrelevant.
- hakaaaaak 14y agoIt isn't just the everglades. Most of the area covered is rural, swampland, farmland, etc. and would not be under suspicion, ever. It is a ridiculous map. It would be one thing if waterways and major cities were highlighted, but it is just over the top, completely. Highlighting all of it makes people in those areas worry unnecessarily when they need not. Finally, Homeland Security does not have the resources to implement searches in all of these places, nor will they knock on the door of every random apartment in Washington, D.C. This is a sideshow to real privacy problems and a waste of my time and yours. The ACLU should be focused on the fact that our communications are being monitored, because that is something that is much more worrisome.
- btilly 14y agoI have been aware of the 100 mile zone for about a decade, ever since a friend of mine encountered a border patrol traffic stop on a freeway in Maine. (The Bush era amendment to the policy was that they could seize your electronics. Not being currently reported is that they can jail you if they think you aren't here legally, and have been able to do so forever.)
- chris_wot 14y agoHow can it be legal to have Fourth Amendment Exclusion Zones in the United States?
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoAny organisation that creates a "Civil Liberties Impact" department, really needs to think about its basic job function ! Then again, as a UK citizen, I thought the fourth amendment was not letting soldiers billet in your house.