5 ms·
Nah, what should happen is that governments lower their extortionate tax rates so that these avoidance measures aren't neccessary. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki
by gadders 14y ago
Nah, what should happen is that governments lower their extortionate tax rates so that these avoidance measures aren't neccessary.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laffer_curve http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laffer_curve
- wavefunction 14y agoThe Laffer curve has never been shown to be true, and in fact has always been shown to be false in the real world.
- davidw 14y agoSo... if it's "not true", what sort of curve would you get if you plot government revenue as a function of tax rates? The Laffer curve makes a lot of sense. What is difficult about it, and where politicians are likely to try and push their own agenda, is finding where revenues are maximized, which is a far more difficult proposition than proposing that there is a revenue curve with a high point somewhere in the middle, which makes intuitive sense.
- lukasLansky 14y agoWell, you do not get a curve, and there is no maximum. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hysteresis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hysteresis Same taxes with different history of taxation yield wildly different results.
- sbmassey 14y agoIt would form a curve for a given state at a given time period. Obviously you wouldn't get the exact same curve for different states and times.
- gadders 14y agoIt's self-evidently true as a concept, even if the exact shape of the curve and the values aren't known.
- ubernostrum 14y ago"Taxes shouldn't be too high, and shouldn't be too low" is about the most precise statement anyone can make about the Laffer curve and still be able to have it hold up in the face of the real world. Pardon me if I'm not bowled over by that.
- gadders 14y agoWell, given that plenty of governments seem to think taxation can be increased indefitely in order to support their "client state" of government employees, I'd say that was a valuable result.
- vidarh 14y agoIf "plenty of governments" believed that, I'd expect to see far higher tax rates.
- jeltz 14y agoSince we have no clue about the shape of the curve apart from the two extremes it is a quite useless tool. EDIT: According to the Wikipedia page some studies indicate that the maximum for the laffer curve in Sweden was about 70% tax.
- twoodfin 14y agoThat's a believable number. But I also imagine that the curve flattens considerably before topping out: Sweden probably wouldn't get a lot of additional revenue out of that last 5-10% in tax rates. If you were picking the "right" level of taxation, you'd presumably want it to set it somewhere near the point where the economic cost of the taxes was equal to the benefits of the government's use of the revenue, and not at the point of maximum revenue. A 70% marginal rate is not outrageously far from where the top bracket in California will be if Washington decides the best Social Security reform includes lifting the payroll tax cap. Today's effective top marginal rate in CA is ~52% in Fed+State income taxes and another 3.8% for the high-earner Medicare tax. If SS goes uncapped, adding another 12.4%, your $1M earner is hitting 68.2%. I'm dispensing with the accounting fantasy that the "employer-paid" portion of the tax isn't actually a tax on the worker.
- sgift 14y agoEven if the Laffer curve is true (see the comment by wavefunction) no one knows where the maximum revenue point is. Look at "Empirical data" in the Wikipedia article: There are many possible values for "optimal tax rate" and companies have many options to play the system, e.g. always hold back enough money that there is justification for a lower tax rate.
- gadders 14y agoNo, nobody knows what the exact shape of the curve is, but governments should bear in mind when screwing more cash out of companies and people in order to fund pork barrell projects.
- vajrabum 14y agoGiven that company's minimize their tax liability any amount of tax over zero is going to be enough to induce them to such shenanigans.