4 ms·
I was not intending to name any particular high-end jobs. In fact, I picked "neurosurgeon" randomly so as to pick a profession far outside most people on this f
by jandrewrogers 14y ago
I was not intending to name any particular high-end jobs. In fact, I picked "neurosurgeon" randomly so as to pick a profession far outside most people on this forum. The point that you missed is that the people who will still have jobs in this scenario are likely to be people in professions where the demand exceeds the supply and is not easily replaceable (or the demand would not exceed supply).
To bring it back to an HN audience, consider high-end software engineers. There is ferocious demand for them and they can demand wages that is an integer multiple of the average wage in the US and employers will pay that. Most of these companies hiring high-end software engineers are essentially in a price war with other companies. The pool of new software engineers capable of the job does not grow fast enough to fill the growth in demand. When a company poaches a software engineer from another company, all they have done is move the demand to a new company. Forcing people to work less does not create a vast pool of highly skilled workers with deep technical expertise, nor does it make it any easier to develop that expertise. The number of jobs increase on their own. The number of workers qualified to fill those jobs does not. As the average skill required of those jobs continues to rise, the number of qualified people will diminish.
- Joeri 14y agoSoftware engineers earn a multiple of the median wage, but not an order of magnitude more. The jobs our work displaces are order of magnitude material. If anything, compared to the value we create, we're grossly underpaid. I think this is due to the inability of employers to see us as fundamentally different from the workers our automation displaces. The perception remains (and i've seen this first hand) that developers are replaceable, and this means that there are limits to how much you're considered entitled to.
- jandrewrogers 14y agoI would agree that some software engineers are underpaid. However, it is not legally enforced in the US unlike many countries, it is more of a statistical phenomenon. Many software engineers grossly underestimate the other costs associated with their efforts, which I state as a software engineer by trade with P&L responsibility. Most software engineers find pay that is at the level of their value to a first approximation. The reality is that "developers" are replaceable, it is not just a perception. And by "developer" I mean developers that have a few years of experience under their belt but no real differentiating skills. This is an important distinction; I've met developers in their 40s with no differentiating skills despite decades of work history and developers fresh out of school that could materially differentiate themselves from ordinary developers. It is an important distinction. Developers with interesting skills are a lot less replaceable. To be honest, I don't need any "developers" in the generic sense. My company does not hire them. We hire people with material skills that (1) we need and (2) are not widely available in the pool of people that call themselves "developers". I literally can't use the rest no matter how the conversation is framed. We pay well above the median wage for the developers we do hire because we know we are hiring them for their unique and valuable skill set. We absolutely pay for talent but have no interest in average talent.
- pc86 14y agoSo what does it take for one to differentiate themselves?
- stephencanon 14y agoUS median household income in 2012 was $45,018 [Wikipedia]. There are certainly two-engineer households that make an order of magnitude more; actually there are individual engineers at large successful companies who make that much if you include stock and option grants (which you should, because the IRS certainly does). Most engineers aren't so well-compensated. Most doctors aren't neurosurgeons, either.
- guelo 14y agoIf you're talking about $450k then you're talking about a 99 percentile minority.
- yummyfajitas 14y ago$450k is easily achievable by a household consisting of two higher end engineers.
- stephencanon 14y ago99th percentile minority is still something like 2.5 million working adults. Some of them are engineers.
- bd_at_rivenhill 14y agoThere are numerous individual software developers in finance that are easily making $450,000+ cash without resorting to stock and option grants.
- Joeri 14y agoFinance is a bad example because the traders that software replaces make an order of magnitude more than median wage. So, the software deeloper in finance could be underpaid making an order of magnitude above median.
- nilkn 14y agoWhere are these developers at, and do they have decent working conditions and hours? $450k may not sound so glamorous if you work 80 hours a week in a hell hole. I looked at Jane Street in college but it seems they start their developers at $100k with no bonus, i.e., less than Google, Facebook, etc., even though Manhattan is even more expensive than the Valley.
- khuey 14y agoThe best example of this is revenue per employee. Google and Apple have close to $1,000,000 revenue per employee. How many of their engineers are bringing home more than 20% of that?