6 ms·
Why hello my old friend, the Lump of Labor Fallacy![1] I get why people think this in theory. But they never seem to notice that we have been living in an age o
by wpietri 14y ago
Why hello my old friend, the Lump of Labor Fallacy![1] I get why people think this in theory. But they never seem to notice that we have been living in an age of untold abundance for quite a while.
From the perspective of anybody who grew up in a subsistence agriculture economy (which is the perspective of most people in human history), we developed-nations types live better than kings. And all the agriculture jobs are gone! From that viewpoint, none of us should need to work.
But we still mostly have jobs. Why? My take is that, as the Buddha said, desires are numberless. People find new things to want, and other people find ways to satisfy those needs. This will always happen.
Sure, it's possible that this time machines will actually eliminate all the jobs, and we'll live like the lillies of the field. But that has been failing to happen for the two centuries since the Industrial Revolution began. And people have been fearing machine-induced joblessness since the beginning. [2]
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lump_of_labor_fallacy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lump_of_labor_fallacy
[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luddite http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luddite
- altcognito 14y agoIt isn't that ALL of a fixed number of jobs are going away: that is not what the article is saying. it is saying that the need for good paying manual labor is changing faster than societies' ability to cope with it. Not only that, we are pretty much doing the exact opposite of what we should be doing.
- sopooneo 14y ago"This will always happen." I am dubious. It seems a lot of econ people hold this notion with almost religious faith. And I may be mistaken in my doubting and you may be correct. But I wonder if a paradigm shift is on the horizon that will wash some old truths away for good.
- WalterBright 14y agoI see new kinds of jobs being created all the time. For example, look at the explosive growth of the entertainment industry. How about the car customization industry? People pay a lot of money for personalized cars. The fashion industry. Comic book conventions are a big industry. Sports, sports equipment, trainers, etc. How about that minor industry to escort hundreds of amateurs up Mt. Everest each year? The increasing wealth of society and the decreasing costs of food/shelter enable all these more frivolous demands.
- zanny 14y ago> The increasing wealth of society and the decreasing costs of food/shelter enable all these more frivolous demands. Where do you live? Real wages haven't changed, spending power has dropped significantly, and inflation has multipled quite a few fold the costs of basic goods over the last 30 years. At least in the US. The inflation adjusted wage hasn't gone up. Housing and food have gotten tremendously more expensive due to land scarcity and the dramatic inefficiencies of housing and food distribution. We have superfluous tech advantages because they are untapped resources, like silicon transistors and graphene, but until we have automated farms, or skyscraper farms with artificial lighting, or molecular fabrication to such a degree that printers could print proteins and aminos, it is a real problem.
- desas 14y agoLand scarcity? Where do you live? The EU population density is something like 4x the US, admittedly we don't have inhospitable desert wastelands but there's a lot of space still left.
- khuey 14y agoIn the Bay Area, presumably.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoAmerica has laws that restrict you from building dense European-style or Asian-style apartment buildings, effectively forcing everyone into quarter-acre land plots in the suburbs. This is actually considered a major driver of inefficiency and waste in the American economy. http://www.amazon.com/The-Rent-Damn-High-ebook/dp/B0078XGJXO/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8 http://www.amazon.com/The-Rent-Damn-High-ebook/dp/B0078XGJXO...
- s_baby 14y agoThe difference is there was a rational reason to put people to work as capital and rational incentives were established to get people to work. What happens in a hypothetical when the only "numberless desires" unmet are those that are literally astronomical in scope due to abundance?
- jiggy2011 14y agoPeople's desires are numberless, but the question is who will fulfil those desires? Machines are getting better at fulfilling our desires a lot quicker than we ourselves are.
- wpietri 14y agoDepends on what you're looking at. Look at the credits for modern films. These days they use more people, not fewer. Or look at food. We've already figured out what a future of minimum-cost food looks like. There's a lot of growth in more human-intensive agriculture, production, and cooking. The best restaurants aren't the ones with the most automation. Sure, if Strong AI Jesus ever descends from the clouds or comes up from the labs, some things may change. But maybe not. Humans are evolved to deal with other humans. They like doing it.
- jiggy2011 14y agoTrue, there are certainly jobs for skilled filmmakers , chefs etc. But on the other hand there aren't any jobs for tellers at video rental stores (they are probably replaced by a lower number of software developers at netflix).
- jamieb 14y ago"But that has been failing to happen for the two centuries since the Industrial Revolution began. And people have been fearing machine-induced joblessness since the beginning." What has actually happened is that as labor was replaced or reduced in one industry, jobs moved to others. The agricultural revolution reduced the cost of food, thereby reducing the amount of "money" that a human had to earn to survive. They could then be employed doing something else. During the industrial revolution more goods were produced cheaply, making them more affordable, and allowing more people to buy them. The industrial revolution increased production but still required people. Each innovation created a new opportunity that required people to do the work. At each stage, we dealt with hierarchy of needs. Food. Clothing. Shelter. The assumption made in the quote above is that there is an endless list of jobs, and that the fact that we've had 200 years without the end of society proves it. Analysis of the data, however, suggests that at each stage, the "revolution" has left less jobs available, and/or those jobs have paid lower salaries. The trend is that at some point in the future, human labor and, some time later, human thought will have such tiny value as to be worthless. A robot or an AI will be vastly more cost effective than paying a slow moving, slow thinking organic entity that requires money in order to purchase proteins, carbohydrates and increasingly rare elements like phosphorus. Just as for millennia, smart people have been attempting to fly, so too have smart people been attempting to eliminate humans from production. Why are we surprised, why do we deny, that they are succeeding? The evidence is right here. Nobody here on HN is forming a startup to automate some aspect of our lives with the express goal that the labor saved be used to create new jobs. Nobody is saying "My start-up automates X so that the people who were paid to do X can get a new job doing Y". That last part is just not on anybody's radar. Does PG ask this in YC interviews: "And what will the people who are made unemployed by your new startup do?" No. So why are we surprised that the world is turning out exactly according to all our plans? The article is correct and asks the right question: "The jobs are not coming back. What are we going to do about it?"
- YokoZar 14y agoIt is entirely possible to invent technology that both saves on labor costs and creates more jobs in aggregate. A historical example was the very thing the luddites protested: weaving machines that replaced expensive weavers with greater numbers of ultra-cheap immigrants. Usability can make it so normal untrained people can do something that used to require expensive experts. It's also a kind of technology we can all agree on, and many of us work on it every day.
- steveklabnik 14y ago> But they never seem to notice that we have been living in an age of untold abundance for quite a while. That's probably because they're too busy trying to find a job, pay off their debts, find health care, or all the other things needed to live. _Some_ people have been living in abundance, not most.
- whatusername 14y agoWhile they have running water, electricity, lights, internet, all kinds of fresh food on demand, Health Care that actually works, all kinds of abundance like that. Assuming we are talking about people living in a Developed nation.
- steveklabnik 14y ago> health care that actually works lol (sorry, I live in the US. This idea is laughable.) > internet, all kinds of fresh food on demand These are luxuries that many can't afford.
- maxerickson 14y agoGP probably meant effective medicine, not a 'health care system that is shiny and fair'. If you measure historically, being able to buy a bottle of aspirin is some sort of miracle. Never mind vaccines, treatments for disease or antibiotics (many vaccines and antibiotics are more or less free).
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoThe problem is that "shiny and fair" is linked to the "miracles". Vaccines mostly work to eliminate disease by means of herd immunity. If vaccines because an individualistic economic luxury-good, they will stop working and we will return to the dark days of mass plagues.
- maxerickson 14y ago