5 ms·
Life Inside the Aaron Swartz Investigation
- rdl 14y agoWow. I had no idea she was so relatively destitute; it's a lot easier to criticize someone's actions and unfamiliarity with the legal process when you're used to dealing with startup founders, people who have had Jennifer Granick on speed-dial, etc. I guess being an independent journalist doesn't pay well, and if you're being entangled in something in your personal life, vs. through through something you've published, you're kind of on your own. Still, a personal "document retention policy" is essential if you do anything interesting at all. In addition, I have a pretty bad memory.
- neurotech1 14y agoI have a lot more respect for Quinn Norton, than some of the so called "journalists" who rehash press releases and call it a story.
- rdouble 14y agoWasn't Aaron a fellow at Harvard Law school and didn't he hang out with Larry Lessig? The part of the story I don't understand the most is why the high profile lawyer who was egging Aaron on to break the rules seems to have played a minor role after his arrest.
- neurotech1 14y agoAs far as I can tell, Larry (Lawrence) Lessig is a civil copyright/technology/IP rights attorney, and not known to be a criminal defense attorney. Even with his high profile status, he may not have much criminal defense experience.
- jacquesm 14y agoYes, but that does not explain that the EFF as a whole didn't see fit to help out.
- rdl 14y agoWhy is weev getting relatively no support? EFF circa 2013 is a large institution. It does good, but it isn't at all focused on defending people in "boring" cases, which was kind of its original mission (Steve Jackson Games). There isn't an organization in the tech community which defends people from computer related crimes on bogus but boring grounds the way the ACLU does for pure, conventional free speech. I think that would be a useful organization; even if a defendant is a racist troll, he deserves a competent defense, and computer crimes are still complex and novel enough that normal legal defense is probably not ideal. Unfortunately I'm not (yet) in a position to fund something like that.
- dannyobrien 14y agoEFF isn't that large (I work there). It takes on cases in exactly the same way as ACLU does, for impact on the law. It was involved in the Swartz case, but mostly as a resource to help people find other criminal defence lawyers. Lots of people got caught up in the investigation, and they couldn't all be represented by the same firm.
- VonGuard 14y agoLOL. Weev isn't getting support from the EFF because he is Weev. Who the hell would want to defend him? And specifically here, Weev burned certain bridges there through his normal every-day work as a troll.
- rdl 14y ago"When my obligations to Harvard created a conflict that made it impossible for me to continue as a lawyer, I continued as a friend." (from http://lessig.tumblr.com/post/40347463044/prosecutor-as-bully http://lessig.tumblr.com/post/40347463044/prosecutor-as-bull...) i.e. another big East Coast university (primarily MIT, now Harvard) fucking over people actually doing something useful, more in keeping with their purported mission than anything the institution currently does. I hope MOOCs, online collaboration, one on one communication, self-directed projects, etc. destroy these outdated medieval legacies.
- gknoy 14y agoThat was one of my main take-aways, too. Logging. I do it, automatically in my chat clients, because otherwise I will totally forget little details about everything. Mom's address? Friend's anniversary? Details of X problem and its requirements? Logged. A document retention (And deletion!) policy seems like it's important to have, even in personal use cases, as this article pointed out.
- emhart 14y agoFrom the Editor's notes on the article: "A couple of publication notes. First, Quinn Norton did not accept money for the publication of this story. We offered. She has chosen to donate the money we're paying her. Second, I edited this story. Third, we've published several snippets of writing that Norton penned during the time of the trial along with her present account because their content -- a letter to the prosecutor and a reflection on Norton's father -- are an important lens for her state of mind at the time of the investigation. " http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/13/03/editors-note-to-quinn-nortons-account-of-the-aaron-swartz-investigation/273666/ http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/13/03/editors-...
- sneak 14y ago> First, Quinn Norton did not accept money for the publication of this story. We offered. She has chosen to donate the money we're paying her. No wonder she's too broke to afford medical care. :(
- emhart 14y agoThis one article would not make the difference, though I wonder if your greater point may be that it can be hard to get by in this country when you grant money an ethical/emotional/moral or otherwise personal value beyond beyond the apparent financial value.
- marshray 14y agoAnd you don't see the difference between this story and the rest of her work as a journalist?
- jrochkind1 14y agoNever, ever, ever, talk to the prosecutors. Learn from this story, and just don't talk to them. The dangerous part of this story is that she reports her grand jury experience as a success, suggesting that you _can- talk to the state and 'win'. Maybe it was as successful as she thinks, maybe it wasn't. And we can't say that you can _never_ be succesful talking to the prosecutors; never say never. But what we can say is that they are _experts_ at 'winning' in those confrontations, they've trained for it and practice it every day, no matter how smart you are you're _probably_ going to end up hurting yourselves or your friends and loved ones by talking to the prosecutors. Stick with the conclusion from the first part, never, ever, talk to the prosecutors.
- warmwaffles 14y agoLong read only to have it summarized as that. I don't want to venture down that road ever.
- the_economist 14y agoDon't talk to police, either, according to this law school professor: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc
- sachingulaya 14y agoThis is an insightful video to watch. I've seen it before and have to say it didn't hit on any of the obvious reasons that its a bad idea to speak to the police. I felt sick reading her account and couldn't finish. She is not the person I would want by my side going through something like that. In spite of being a "reporter on hackers" she was extremely naive of the system. How can anyone in the right mind recommend that the prosecution reads a document called the "Guerilla Open Access Manifesto"?
- gknoy 14y agoIt's a good thing to read, even so. Melancholy and sad, but not something I regret reading. It's not as informative (in terms of actionable advice) as the article on HN about how to (politely) not talk to investigators, but it showed the depths of how adversarial they can make it -- it's a game for them.
- unreal37 14y agoI feel sorry for Quinn Norton an innocent bystander in all this. It seems everything she did including talking to the prosecutors she did what she honestly thought was the best thing to do. She did need to protect herself and her daughter. Her life was thrown upside-down during those months she was involved in this case, unfairly.
- ScottBurson 14y agoTo me this paints a striking, and damning, picture of these prosecutors as egos run amok. These are not the kind of people I want to see paid with my tax dollars.
- kamaal 14y ago>>These days, I not only don't log, I refuse to talk to anyone who does. I often refuse to communicate without encryption. This is the lesson to take away from all this. People on this forum have always talked about freedom to bear arms. It is not that difficult to realize this fact, Freedom to bear arms in our times is cryptogrphy/encryption not guns.
- guiambros 14y agoEncryption is not relevant when prosecutors can subpoena all your electronic equipment and find every single trace, log files, historical messages, etc. But agree, the real lesson to take away if you ever find yourself in a similar situation is: don't ask, don't talk, don't write. Sadly, Aaron was right in trying to avoid any conversation about the case, even with loved ones. The only way to "win" is not to play.
- mindslight 14y agoComputers are an extension of one's mind, and should be subject to the same fifth amendment protection. We wouldn't say that protection against self incrimination no longer applies once information can be scanned directly out of the brain (although the doublespeaking sovereign nine probably would, sigh). I have hope that ubiquitous stenographic file systems can maybe show people the way and encourage such push back. We'll see.
- ctchocula 14y ago> don't ask, don't talk, don't write. This reminds me of the dystopia in 1984.
- ck2 14y agoThe entire wealth and resources of the federal government when wielded by a prosecutor against an individual is truly terrifying, and not surprisingly abused constantly. Those powers are meant to go after "well armored" entities like organized crime and "well entrenched" corporations, bankers, wallstreet, etc. to protect the people of the state from what they could not individually protect themselves against. But going after individuals guarantees wins which helps the victory scoreboard and political careers. Going after entities that have armies of lawyers and boatloads of cash is far less profitable and far more risky.
- lawnchair_larry 14y agoAccording to this, he never planned to release the documents at all?
- vidarh 14y agoAccording to this there is no evidence he planned to release the documents at all.
- lawnchair_larry 14y agoRight, but not only that, there was a very plausible explanation as to why he downloaded them, which had nothing to do with releasing them.
- MWil 14y ago"I told them about the Guerrilla Open Access Manifesto. And in doing so, Aaron would explain to me later (and reporters would confirm), I made everything worse. This is what I must live with." Not just worse, she gave them a case they didn't have (although arguably a better prosecutor would have googled)
- MWil 14y ago"I was told that changing my behavior while being investigated could be held against me, because in an investigation it is suspicious to learn from your mistakes." Google "subsequent remedial measures" and know that this isn't always true. INAL yet but I'd love to represent tech-savy clients who need help navigating the horrible world of the law.