3 ms·
I don't see why for any reason why new jobs will not be generated. Because economic productivity is no longer translating cleanly into increased buying power a
by eli_gottlieb 14y ago
I don't see why for any reason why new jobs will not be generated.
Because economic productivity is no longer translating cleanly into increased buying power and demand (expressed, usually, as a rise in real hourly wages). Without that link, productivity growth through, say, automation just becomes increased capital accumulation, because the people doing the automation, by self-selection of their choice to invest in automation rather than eating their profits, already have a lower marginal propensity to consume than normal.
The result is that new stuff gets invented, but little to no-one can buy it, because "you're not entitled" to wages sufficiently high to make discretionary purchases (like a private car) or personal infrastructure upgrades (like passivehaus insulation to save on heating costs).
- ams6110 14y agoWhat you're saying doesn't make sense. If nobody can afford to buy anything (no demand) then nothing will get made. If automation beyond a point actually decreases demand for the outputs, then its self-limiting.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoThe world isn't full of Dell Computers. This year's tomatoes are grown based on last year's demand or this year's demand for out-of-season import tomatoes. There's a time delay and someone gets stuck with the risk, belly-up if demand collapses. If automation beyond a point actually decreases demand for the outputs, then its self-limiting. Yes, but it will grow and then self-limit into an equilibrium state where humanity has a much lower real standard of living because it can't "earn" the output it's easily capable of producing.
- gizmo686 14y agoImagine that you have two companies producing pens, and society currently uses X pens/year. If company A can find a way to automate production, they can sell pens cheaper than B (and/or at a higher profit margin). Because A laid off people, society no longer consumes X pens, but the difference is distributed between both A and B (and other pen companies, and non-pen companies would also see a loss). Assume every company acts in their own best interest. If company A instead uses their extra money and gives it away to their now unemployed former employees, then society would be back to using X pens/year, and demand is maintained. But that is clearly not in A's best interest, so they do not. Now we have the ability to produce more stuff as a society (not just pens, because the unemployed can be used anywhere). However, all this gets us is people who can no longer afford what they once could.