8 ms·
I agree with the basic argument that economic growth has a weakening correlation with job growth. However, the idea often proffered that you solve this by makin
by jandrewrogers 14y ago
I agree with the basic argument that economic growth has a weakening correlation with job growth. However, the idea often proffered that you solve this by making people with jobs work less is silly. First, at the limit spreading the work around over more people still results in the same outcome. Second, it also assumes that the real problem is a shortage of jobs when the problem is actually a shortage of people capable of doing jobs where it makes economic sense to employ a person.
The problem is that we have a (figurative) glut of job openings for neurosurgeons and a severe shortage of neurosurgeons. The answer not to make the existing neurosurgeons work fewer hours; they are serving a valuable, irreplaceable (in an availability sense) function every hour they work. You can't give a lawyer, janitor, and accountant a crash course in neurosurgery, split the job between them, and expect a comparable result in the aggregate even though you created more jobs. At some point we will have to come to terms with the idea of decoupling a job from a decent life in the same way that jobs are being decoupled from economic growth.
The limit of this scenario is interesting as a hypothetical. When we get to the point where only 5% of the population is employable and they are all employed with very valuable skills that are in extremely short supply by definition, how are those people treated once the vast majority of the population depends on their continued work while 95% of the population no longer needs to work and is not usefully employable in any case? Can the 95% not working force the 5% to work long hours because there is a desperate need for their skills and talents which are not easily replaceable? It is a different political dynamic than when the majority of the population is contributing to the economy that supports society.
- Spooky23 14y agoYou're using examples that are fundamentally flawed, as the high end jobs you named tend to be folks more likely to be partners or principals in their own businesses. For a good part of the 20th century, white-collar, salaried jobs were 40 hour jobs. Blue collar or non-exempt jobs were 40 hour jobs with overtime. Today, we declare almost everyone to be an exempt employee, work them ragged, and run as lean as possible. We do this because unlike in the 1960's, companies bear no cost -- those burnt out 45 year olds don't get disability pensions or insurance anymore. Those costs are borne by the public at large via social safety net programs. If you mandated that most workers work only 40 hours per week, you would provide companies with a powerful incentive to deal with the high fixed costs associated with hiring an employee. It doesn't make "economic sense" to hire people because the law has been changed to make that the case. Now it makes sense to hire freelancers, contractors, etc who are easier to abuse.
- jandrewrogers 14y agoI was not intending to name any particular high-end jobs. In fact, I picked "neurosurgeon" randomly so as to pick a profession far outside most people on this forum. The point that you missed is that the people who will still have jobs in this scenario are likely to be people in professions where the demand exceeds the supply and is not easily replaceable (or the demand would not exceed supply). To bring it back to an HN audience, consider high-end software engineers. There is ferocious demand for them and they can demand wages that is an integer multiple of the average wage in the US and employers will pay that. Most of these companies hiring high-end software engineers are essentially in a price war with other companies. The pool of new software engineers capable of the job does not grow fast enough to fill the growth in demand. When a company poaches a software engineer from another company, all they have done is move the demand to a new company. Forcing people to work less does not create a vast pool of highly skilled workers with deep technical expertise, nor does it make it any easier to develop that expertise. The number of jobs increase on their own. The number of workers qualified to fill those jobs does not. As the average skill required of those jobs continues to rise, the number of qualified people will diminish.
- Joeri 14y agoSoftware engineers earn a multiple of the median wage, but not an order of magnitude more. The jobs our work displaces are order of magnitude material. If anything, compared to the value we create, we're grossly underpaid. I think this is due to the inability of employers to see us as fundamentally different from the workers our automation displaces. The perception remains (and i've seen this first hand) that developers are replaceable, and this means that there are limits to how much you're considered entitled to.
- jandrewrogers 14y agoI would agree that some software engineers are underpaid. However, it is not legally enforced in the US unlike many countries, it is more of a statistical phenomenon. Many software engineers grossly underestimate the other costs associated with their efforts, which I state as a software engineer by trade with P&L responsibility. Most software engineers find pay that is at the level of their value to a first approximation. The reality is that "developers" are replaceable, it is not just a perception. And by "developer" I mean developers that have a few years of experience under their belt but no real differentiating skills. This is an important distinction; I've met developers in their 40s with no differentiating skills despite decades of work history and developers fresh out of school that could materially differentiate themselves from ordinary developers. It is an important distinction. Developers with interesting skills are a lot less replaceable. To be honest, I don't need any "developers" in the generic sense. My company does not hire them. We hire people with material skills that (1) we need and (2) are not widely available in the pool of people that call themselves "developers". I literally can't use the rest no matter how the conversation is framed. We pay well above the median wage for the developers we do hire because we know we are hiring them for their unique and valuable skill set. We absolutely pay for talent but have no interest in average talent.
- old-gregg 14y ago> Can the 95% not working force the 5% to work long hours because there is a desperate need for their skills and talents which are not easily replaceable? Indirectly, perhaps via taxation. You can look around (at least here in US/CA) to see what may happen. The unemployable ones will be voting for increasingly larger government to "employ" themselves while simultaneously raising taxes on the working to pay for unemployables' retirement.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoAs Spooky23 pointed out below, their very "unemployability" is also a function of public policies (like employer-linked retirement accounts and health insurance) that continually increase the fixed-costs of each marginal worker, discouraging hiring.
- ippisl 14y agoYou're neurosurgeon scenario is interesting because healthcare is the one industry where there are proven models where we can deskill jobs and by this create many good jobs for people with less training. One example is that of minute clinics where nurses + computers are doing the job of a physician.It's cheaper , it's a good job and the nurses can afford more time per patient , so this creates more jobs. And the u.s. don't steal doctors from the this world this way , which is nice. There is/could be plenty of stuff like that in healthcare.
- notdrunkatall 14y agoGood point, but you should proofread before you post.
- stephencanon 14y agoWill you allow a nurse + computer to perform an emergency craniotomy (a very simple neurosurgical procedure) on your spouse? Large parts of the healthcare industry can be deskilled as you describe. Actual neurosurgery might not be so easy.
- flyinRyan 14y agoDid you think about this at all before responding? The majority of health care is routine stuff that a nurse + computer can easily do. The nurse+computer combo can also determine if the issue is beyond their skill level. Why are we wasting valuable doctor time with routine issues? That's not an efficient use of anything.
- jiggy2011 14y agoI think at the point where it is 5%/95% it will become apparent enough that there is a problem that a solution will have to be proposed. Though you could end up with an interesting sort of inverse slavery where the unemployed masses resort to coercion to force the highly educated/intelligent minority into doing the work for them. What I think is scarier though is thinking about what happens if the unemployment rate hits say 20% and starts moving towards 30%. The majority of people will still be in work, so those who are unemployed will still have a stigma attached and you will have the usual arguments about "why should I have to work to pay somebody to stay at home?". These arguments will become louder as the amount of money that will have to be collected through tax from those who are working to support those who are not will become a huge sum. At that point a far right wing party who campaigns on the basis of removing all government support from those who do not work could gain considerable traction and possibly be elected. At that point you have a huge section of the population without any means at all, this will naturally lead to massive crime and civil unrest. At which point the government will have no choice but to respond with strong force against a large section of the population.
- ido 14y agoWhat I think is scarier though is thinking about what happens if the unemployment rate hits say 20% and starts moving towards 30%. That is already the case in some countries (even some western ones, like Spain: 26.1% as of December 2012).
- znq 14y agoPeople still do have work, though. They just work "black" and eventually receive unemployment benefits at the same time. The official numbers just don't reflect reality. That said, the economic situation in Spain is not great at the moment, but still not as bad as reported by the media sometimes.
- digitalengineer 14y agoThere's another official rate rate you can check out. The "real" unemployment rate, which measures everybody considered unemployed plus a lot of others who are falling through the cracks. It's called the U-6 unemployment. The government publishes this data in the same monthly report as all the other official employment numbers, and anybody can find it on the Internet. In the US the U-6 unemployment is [b]16.2%[/b] and counting. You could also just count the "Americans-on-Food-Stamps"number. It's 46 Million.
- dspeyer 14y agoThe question isn't whether the 95% can do neurosurgery. It's whether there's anything they can do better than a robot that other people want. Given the overall flexibility of the human mind, and the complete failure of general-purpose AI, I bet there's something. I could be convinced otherwise, but it would require much stronger evidence than a half decade of unemployment that could easily come from economic or political causes.
- cargo8 14y agoDo you really believe the success (at this time in technology) of general-purpose AI has a strong correlation to the potential for human labor to be replaced by machine labor? It would seem with the plethora of startups being created every day at providing services and products in different markets by utilizing technology means that there will be plenty of different companies willing to focus on a particular market / product / service to develop their AI. Does the success of general-purpose AI really limit the possibility of developing specialized machine labor AI? I can see how it will be slower to reach the point of replacing all of these jobs than if general-purpose AI worked well, but I don't think it really limits the possibility.
- dspeyer 14y agoSo long as humans can do general purpose thinking and machines can't, any task that requires general purpose thinking will require humans. Many of these tasks may be things that go undone now, but will become affordable when machine-made stuff gets cheaper and removes expenses from people's budgets. Assuming the economics doesn't mess everything up. Which it easily could. But the fundamental problem is self-solving until we run out of applications of general purpose thinking.
- flyinRyan 14y agoThe failure of general-purpose AI is simply the failure of general purpose robots. We've already seen the future: specialized "appliance" robots that do one job to perfection. They don't need to duplicate human conciseness, they need only enough AI to accurately do one specific job and nothing more. I don't think that's hard at all, just currently expensive.
- seanp2k2 14y agoWe'll never get to 95% of the population not working so long as more profits can be extracted by having more people than 5% working. You don't work now because you /must/ for humanity to survive. You work now because someone wants to get richer and you're helping them.
- paduc 14y agoNot true because if the profits aren't high enough, you won't be able to pay these workers enough money for it to be interesting to them. If you can make 2 cents/hour by employing someone, that doesn't mean someone will accept the job. People will prefer not working (and maybe resorting to crime to survive) at all rather than not making enough to live properly. I believe we are already at the limit here. Many people work for less than enough to live properly. In France, we know what happens when people start starving to death while others are fat and rich. The social measures are meant to prevent the poor population from killing the rich. It's the price to pay for peace and security.
- seanp2k2 14y agoIt's not as silly when you have stuff like this already happening http://money.cnn.com/2012/12/03/news/economy/record-corporate-profits/index.html http://money.cnn.com/2012/12/03/news/economy/record-corporat... Companies, and in turn, powerful individuals are getting richer and richer while unemployment rises and wages grow less quickly than inflation.
- wasdman 14y agoThat only encourages people to work the minimum at X shitty job, and then leave. Then when you get unemployment, you also work contract jobs and other cash jobs. Like hell anyone would report it, considering how bad unemployment insurance is. "you were paid 102k a year, but were downsized. Now get paid 446/mo."
- enraged_camel 14y ago>>Second, it also assumes that the real problem is a shortage of jobs when the problem is actually a shortage of people capable of doing jobs where it makes economic sense to employ a person. As someone who holds a degree in economics, I can tell you with absolute certainty that the problem is not a lack of people who are capable of doing the jobs, but rather a lack of demand for the products and services that the said job would provide.
- philh 14y agoIn other words, that's not a job where it makes economic sense to employ a person. (I can't tell if you're being serious or not; "absolute certainty" makes me guess not, but it looks like I'm replying anyway.)
- enraged_camel 14y agoI have no idea what you're trying to say.
- philh 14y agoIf a job provides products and services for which there is no demand, it doesn't make economic sense to employ someone to do that job. So the fact that such jobs exist, and there are people capable of doing them, doesn't change the point of what you quoted.
- waps 14y agoOk, but you're thinking in circles here, aren't you ? If you only count jobs that make economic sense then 1) any kind of job that is merely self-sustaining doesn't count. That might not be much in the US, in many countries it's 80% or more of the population. You can interpret this in many ways, starting at including only subsistence farmers, or you could be fair and count any job that doesn't provide disposable income.* 2) any kind of job that is merely checking others, or some form of administration or social program doesn't contribute to the economy. This means most government jobs, and for example any healthcare job that is paid for mostly by medicare. 3) Things like police and military ... ditto. So what are the figures now ? I'm willing to bet that worldwide, >80% of people do not have an economically useful function. That number is rising, fast. That's what everybody is complaining about. Making all these people retrain, and actually become good at an economically useful function, assuming it is possible at all, is not going to happen. About that assumption : know any industry sector that could use >4.6 billion people ? I know we could use maybe 1-2 million extra developers, but that would cover everything pretty well. The employment provided by that, worldwide, is but a rounding error. You also assume that, when push comes to shove, those 80% of people are going to let you have your economically profitable position at all. When I look at my own lifetime, that seems so obviously true ... it seems insane to question it. When I read the history of the 20 years before my birth or talk to my father, that seems a risky proposition. When I read the history of the last century or talk to my grandfather, that idea quickly becomes entirely ridiculous. The amount of work the entire economy can usefully provide pales to what war can provide. Of course, those jobs come at a cost you might find you're not willing to pay, but this is a choice that will be made for you. * You could even be extremely cruel and take that any job inside a country that's not running a trade surplus obviously is not economically useful to the world. It's just spinning around at best. But that would take us so close to 100% uselessness it's hard to argue that. Also keep in mind that the net economic usefulness of the entire world, of course, has to be zero. Once you pass a certain scale the economy's only remaining function is to keep humans busy.
- Daniel_Newby 14y ago> ... while 95% of the population no longer needs to work and is not usefully employable in any case? I hold great hope that genetic engineering will have eliminated such people before then.
- flyinRyan 14y agoWow. If someone can't be suitably tasked with making some rich people richer they should be killed? One has to earn their right to exist in your eyes?
- Daniel_Newby 14y agoPlease stop the emotional diarrhea. You have an intellect, so use it. Reread my comment again and this time think about each word. You will find that "kill" or an equivalent word does not appear once. What does appear is "genetic engineers". What do genetic engineers do? They create new organisms with genetic sequences chosen to encourage particular traits. Traits like intelligence and creativity. Then we simply sit back and wait for the wild-type organisms to go extinct. No killing is needed, as even a few seconds of reflection would have let you find out for yourself.
- Nursie 14y ago"when the problem is actually a shortage of people capable of doing jobs where it makes economic sense to employ a person" I would argue that there's another way of looking at it, there are actually a lot less jobs that need doing that unskilled people can do. When food production and manufacturing become largely automated, and there are only so many people can go into the service industry, what happens? It's a very difficult problem. Thankfully not one that I (as a skilled worker/business owner) am going to be on the sharp end of.