4 ms·
Cost is an unknown except to SpaceX. Price (i.e. cost to the consumer) is easier to figure out but a little more complicated for reasons I'll explain later. Th
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
Cost is an unknown except to SpaceX. Price (i.e. cost to the consumer) is easier to figure out but a little more complicated for reasons I'll explain later.
The easiest direct comparison would be to the ESA's ATV. Each ATV launch costs around $900 million in amortized development costs plus vehicle costs plus launch costs. But, it delivers 6,595 kg of cargo, which puts the delivered cost of cargo at about $132/gram.
In comparison, the Dragon is on a fixed price contract (about $133 million per vehicle) which includes launch and operations and whatnot. This particular Dragon is delivering 1050 kg of supplies (677 kg within the pressurized part of the spacecraft, the rest within the unpressurized "trunk"). This comes out to a cost to NASA of $127/gram.
Which, admittedly, is not Earth shattering. However, this flight will also be returning 1370 kg of equipment back to Earth, including highly valuable scientific experiments and such-like. And Dragon is currently the only vehicle capable of doing so. On the whole this makes Dragon more than worthwhile.
However, this is still only the 2nd operational Dragon resupply mission, and they will continue to increase the amount of cargo delivered as they become more confident in the vehicle and especially as the Falcon 9 v1.1 becomes operational (which will happen in the next flight) which will add about 4 tonnes of additional payload capacity. If fully utilized it could bring the cost of cargo deliveries to ISS down to around $30-$50/g. Also, there is definitely an element of subsidizing the development of new systems in the CRS contract terms, though even so they're reasonably cost effective.
Edit: to compare to the Shuttle, on an MPLM mission the Shuttle could deliver about 15 tonnes of supplies and equipment and cost around $1.5 to $2 billion per launch (the higher figure due to the extremely low flight rate near the end of the Shuttle program), which works out to a cargo delivery cost of around $100/g, though the Shuttle could also return significant amounts of cargo.
Edit2: I inadvertently omitted the cost of the MPLM modules themselves from the calculation above, although including them would be difficult since most of them were built by the Italian Space Agency as payment in kind for ISS access, overall they would only affect the cost figures by less than 20%. Also, fun fact: the MPLMs were named for famous Renaissance artists, or ninja turtles, here's NASA's logo: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Multi-Purpose_Logistics_Module_Logo.png http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Multi-Purpose_Logistics_Mo...
- eliben 14y agoVery interesting, thank you.
- ramidarigaz 14y agoWow. I had no idea the ATV was so expensive. As a side note, your comments in space-related threads are always awesome. Do you work in the industry?
- InclinedPlane 14y agoA lot of the cost of the ATV comes from the development cost and the low number of missions (for clairty I've amortized that cost through the missions planned up to 2014 in the above). Even so it costs about half a billion dollars just to build and launch each one. To be fair, the ATV is able to transfer propellant to the station which is something that only it and the Progress vehicles can do. For myself, I'm merely an enthusiastic amateur, I've been studying spaceflight closely since I was a child and I've come to pick up a few tidbits of trivia along the way.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoNicely laid out, of course the "coolness" thing here is that the marginal cost of getting additional cargo is $25 - $30 per gm. Less if you can go with a non-returnable module. But the thing that really gets me excited is that "you" being the person trying to get stuff into orbit, not having to go to NASA or Boeing to do so. If the only thing between something on the ground and something in orbit is a well defined amount of money, it is possible to compute the ROI for sending something to the L1 point for example.
- opminion 14y agoThe $132/g vs $127/g price would make sense, all other things being equal (which are not, ok), if SpaceX were pricing in a duopoly, right?
- InclinedPlane 14y agoIf I take your meaning correctly, yes. For SpaceX the actual costs they experience are quite low compared to their competition. For example, they don't use rad-hardened CPUs, nor do they use vxworks. This alone saves them millions of dollars. However, it makes sense for them to offer their services as close to the competition's prices as possible, because it maximizes their profits. You see the same thing on their launch services.