3 ms·
If you were studying gun use, and you wanted to know how often guns were used in self-defense, how would you categorize Charles Wellford’s experience? Preempti
by vanderZwan 14y ago
If you were studying gun use, and you wanted to know how often guns were used in self-defense, how would you categorize Charles Wellford’s experience?
Preemptive gun use. Bam, done. Any other categorisations required?
- brazzy 14y agoPreempting what, exactly? Seems to me like objectively, in the given situation the only effect of the gun being present vs. not being present was to increase the likelihood of a tragic accident.
- vanderZwan 14y agoYou are probably referring to the way the word is used in a computer programming context. I was talking about this: "A preemptive war is a war that is commenced in an attempt to repel or defeat a perceived offensive or invasion, or to gain a strategic advantage in an impending (allegedly unavoidable) war before that threat materializes."
- brazzy 14y agoAnd I was talking about the fact that in the example the gun was brought in preparation to an imagined but unspecific and actually not existing threat.
- arjie 14y agoThis illustrates the problem rather well. The case where I ready my weapon in preparation for violence vs. when I use my weapon to stop an anticipated threat are both preemptive uses of the weapon. The definition is unclear and one researcher may use one definition while another might use the other. Both cases are distinct, however. In one case, I am actually preemptively using the weapon and in the other, I am merely carrying it in anticipation of use. Part of the article is a discussion of the fact that such definitions are muddied and lost as statistics are looked at.
- jarrett 14y agoI would argue that you would need it to be finer-grained. As the story was told, Wellford's preemptive gun use was a response to a perceived threat that did not exist. You'd want to count those types of incidents separately from those in which the threat was real. And then you'd need a third category where the reality of the threat cannot be established after the fact. You would also want to tag incidents based on 1) harm done to victim, and 2) harm done to criminal. These are two separate dimensions, and in reality there are incidents to fit into every region on that 2d plane.