7 ms·
Among Servers, Apple’s Mac Mini Quietly Gains Ground
- MattRogish 14y agoAt a previous job, we used http://www.macminicolo.net/ http://www.macminicolo.net/ for a couple of years. Awesome (awesome!) service, great pricing. Haven't been with them in about a year, but I haven't heard anything bad about them since I left...
- meric 14y agoWhat did they do with your mini when you left?
- MattRogish 14y agoI left the company, I assume they returned it.
- LinaLauneBaer 14y agoAt http://objective-cloud.com http://objective-cloud.com we are also using Mac Minis with SSDs and 16 GB of RAM. A single Mac Mini can do so much - computing wise. The only bad thing about Mac Minis is their GPU which may make some use cases less efficient to realize.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- bitcartel 14y agoThe posted link doesn't have any /. comments, try this instead: http://apple.slashdot.org/story/13/03/01/2252215/among-servers-apples-mac-mini-quietly-gains-ground http://apple.slashdot.org/story/13/03/01/2252215/among-serve...
- kunai 14y agoAs far as servers go, if you don't need the sophistication of OS X and its great development tools and process handling, why not just use an off-the-shelf and supported desktop (i.e., Lenovo ThinkCentre) with *BSD on it? Paying the premium for monolithic construction and an OS that is likely never going to see the height of its potential in a specified application seems a bit much.
- mitchty 14y agoThen you can legally virtualize osx.
- niggler 14y agoAny chance for the Xserve line returning? Now I use HP DL360s, but I used to love the Xserve !U servers
- ams6110 14y agoI would say almost certainly no. Apple has clearly become a consumer/retail oriented company; few organizations ever really bought into the idea of the Xserve line, and to the extent Apple are still interested in "enterprise" sales it's for MacBooks and iOS devices.
- GHFigs 14y agoI have a feeling that if Apple wants to get back into servers they'll do it with an ARM-based product sometime in the next two or three years. There's not much room for them in x86, and they've clearly abandoned existing customers. But with ARM they can start fresh and leverage a lot of what they've put behind iOS devices.
- lucian1900 14y agoThis seems very odd to me. Why restrict one's self to an unsupported, proprietary, unvirtualisable OS when Linux and the BSDs are neither of those things and very similar.
- jdboyd 14y agoOSX is virtualizable, but they only let you do it (license wise) on Mac hardware.
- lucian1900 14y agoWhich makes it unvirtualisable for practical purposes.
- jiggy2011 14y agoWhat advantages do you get in deploying something to OS X vs deploying to Linux?
- hollerith 14y agoSomeone who already knows os x gets the advantage of not having to learn linux.
- jiggy2011 14y agoBut surely at this point you are going to be doing everything via SSH at which point the differences are going to be small, although you might be better going with FreeBSD I guess.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- shrughes 14y agoYou get a lot of fun learning how its basic utilities crash on SIGSTOP.
- Nux 14y agoMac Minis are an absolute niche and will get buried by the "cloud" anyway.
- guylhem 14y agoWhy I do have one and you should consider getting one: - reliable : besides the 2nd HD giving SMART errors and that I had preventively changed, I never had one hardware problem in over 3 years. It's on 24/7 and on UPS. I have a second one without UPS, also working like a charm. - small : whenever you need a server, it will fit. - green : it won't suck too much power, so it won't overheat. I live in a tropical climate- this matters to me. - versatile : it can be reconverted into a small desktop when you no longer need it. - standardized : you don't have to worry about the video card or the revision of whatever internal piece changing between batches. If you compile your own linux kernels, that's a godsend. - easy to find : you need one in a hurry? There are applestores everywhere. now try and get me a dell server in the next hour. - osx already installed : sure Linux might be better in many cases, but my time is not free. OSX total configuration time tops 20 minutes, including plugging cables. - quick to configure : if you just need something for php+psql, download osx server package and you're ready to go (That's included in my 20 minutes estimate). It's sucking less than the previous versions (I hated snow leopard server). If you are not in a big hurry, I recommend instead to install your own utilities. In both cases you can keep .dmg, which is useful in some work environments where for security reasons there is no internet connection. Oh and here is a reason why I love rudix - prepackaged GNU utilities, with everything included. No I do not want to recompile stuff. No I do not want to even think about tracking dependancies! If I need say mc, I want a .dmg which contains the whole thing and the libs, and that I can install on another machine immediately without worrying about glib or stuff. TLDR; the mac mini is great. OSX Server "acceptable", but most of it can be replaced by rudix. Sure you may be better served by a custom built machine, or a cloud service, but when you want something working ASAP on an intranet, I haven't found anything better yet. I'm not even talking about the sweet no-questions apple warranty, or the rescue procedure standardization (alt key : will boot on CD or USB) common to all apple hardware. I don't want to remember if F1 or F10 or F12 will get me in the bios, or where I will have to click to let me boot from usb. I buy mac minis because it's the best hardware I've found for my needs (and I say that while trying some hackintoshes time to time!) If you haven't tried one yet, it is worth experimenting with. BTW on http://store.apple.com/us/configure/MD389LL http://store.apple.com/us/configure/MD389LL I see the 16Gb RAM upgrade is getting "more affordable", but I really would like to get a mini with 32 or 64 gigs. EDIT: I know that RedHat, Debian, etc installation can be automated. If you have thousands of identical machines using known-to-be-supported hardware, and highly specific needs requiring a gazillion of .debs it's great (+) But let's say it's 7pm and you need just one machine with apache to serve a php website on the intranet. Do you want to automate an installation and tweak it, or just take a box where a Unix is already installed, along with vi, apache, and the basic tools you need? Some minor configuration file edits will make that box production ready in a matter of minutes. (And BTW OSX software installation can be automated as well) + : automated installs do not fully remove hardware variation issues or make sure the drivers work. The best part of apple hardware is that it generally evolves very slowly - your kernel bins, modules, etc. will usually require more tweaking on 5 dells of the same model than on 20 different imacs (!) In the ends, it's all about costs, and return to scale. If you have thousands of linux boxes, it's a good idea to use cheaper hardware (and buy spares!) along with install automatization : high fixed cost, low marginal costs. For lower volumes, a different solution means I have to spend far less time on it, which lets me concentrate on the real work.
- alrs 14y agoI remember reading articles like this about technologies and companies that I was excited about. In the late 80s the stories were: "The Apple // is still relevant." It wasn't. I remember OS/2 fans pointing to "huge deployments in banking", "huge in Brazil", and "every ATM machine is running OS/2." Whatever truth was there was irrelevant, as IBM had given up on OS/2. Apple has given up on selling a server operating system. Apple has given up on selling server hardware. Apple failed. A cluster of minis makes sense if you are running a CI build farm for an OS X application. It probably makes sense if you're building a FCP render farm. In both of these cases, note that it only makes sense because of the licensing issues. In a saner world you would be running on commodity x86 hardware. If you are an Apple fan and find yourself arguing that your employer should be using piles of minis-running-Linux based on this article, don't.
- taligent 14y agoWhat is a "server" operating system exactly ? Because there is nothing inherently different between CentOS on the desktop and on the server for example.
- epochwolf 14y agoI think most open source people would say an server os is one without a GUI. People are forgetting Windows Server is still largely the same as Windows on the desktop.
- jiggy2011 14y agoWindows Server has a ton of features not present in the desktop versions. For example IIS running on a Windows 7 desktop is capped at 10 concurrent connections for licensing reasons. Whereas I could install a desktop distro + apache on my server and serve as many requests as the hardware can physically handle. The only difference would be that default settings would probably not be well optimised for that use case, but some reconfiguration would solve that.
- hazov 14y agoUnix people, AIX had CDE but no one used it, same for Solaris last time I checked it, but it was a couple of years ago.
- alrs 14y ago“We thought about applying it to other hardware, but if Dell makes a small little machine, you don’t know that they’ll be making that, in that form factor, six months down the road, or what they’re going to do, or how they’re going to refresh it,” This is completely upside-down. Apple's future plans are entirely opaque. When Dell releases an Optiplex desktop, Poweredge server, or Latitude laptop they commit to not making changes for some non-trivial amount of time so that corporate images don't need to be fiddled with.
- taligent 14y agoAs someone who uses Mac Minis for servers the biggest reason is value. I can fit 2 Mac Minis in a 1RU. And that is a Core i7, 16GB, 2xSSD which is about 20-30x faster than what Amazon, Rackspace offers for the same price. Now throw in the fact that you can (a) send it back to Apple if it breaks or (b) sell it on eBay for nearly the same price it all becomes very compelling. Given that I use a Java/Hazelcast/Cassandra stack I can simply add more Mac Minis to linearly scale with no single point of failure.
- chiph 14y agoI'm in the market for a couple for installing MySQL Cluster Edition on. I'll probably buy new (for a DOA warranty) and I'm going to skip AppleCare on them - I've had zero failures on the other Minis I've had. I've found that like you said, the used market prices are so strong that unless you're penny-pinching, there's no good reason to buy used. If there is a discount for buying 3 or more at a time like recuter said above, I may investigate doing that, if it's a steep enough discount. :) EDIT: Just chatted with Apple sales, and discounts are only for business customers, not individuals. :(
- alrs 14y ago"'I’d say the biggest worry is that it runs on 2.5in drives,' Stucki said. 'But, those have been come more reliable lately, and especially in stationary machines like a server.'" 2.5" drives are reputed to be more reliable than 3.5" drives, due to less rotational vibration. The advantage of 3.5" is density.
- trotsky 14y agoA big part of what's pushing the mini use in the datacenter is that pretty much everybody will give you a cheaper colo deal with less restrictions than a 1u. Because the mini lacks stuff like raid, multiple nics, ipmi etc. the typical customer can be relied on to have a pretty idle server. The mobile parts help, but if you filled one of those high density mini racks and used them as compute servers or cloud hosts or something your rack would melt just as fast as any cpu heavy stack of 1us. But with almost everyone just running a hobby website, directory server or mdm you can fit 10 or 15 of those things into to the power budget of a 1u or 2u cdn edge box. You can see the artifacts in a lot of their price lists. Dedicated colo? Sure, $35. Oh you want a managed firewall in front of it? that'll be $50 extra. Want some space on our fault tolerant SAN? No problem, $200. I bet it's a great way for a hosting company to get some use out of cages in the popular dc's that can't sell any more power.
- rdl 14y agoI have one in a 2-mini shelf in the colo to do OSX Server device management/etc. stuff. It's..interesting. Apple seems to keep changing their remote management tools, and unless you have Kerberos set up, there's no good way to do cut-and-paste long random passwords or anything else through the remote desktop tool (it doesn't work during the secure password input window). Probably wouldn't recommend this to anyone unless they have a very specific need; a comparable Atom-based Linux server is cheaper, easier to manage, etc. If you need performance, you can get a low-end i7 based server, and if you need ECC, etc., get a low-end Xeon. The hardware is fine; it's OSX that is lacking.
- cek 14y agoI call this concept "Ubiservers" for Ubiquitous Servers. The idea is the consumer demand for highly integrated computing devices, based on SoCs, combined with Moore's law being applied to solid-state storage will lead to very small devices that 'serve' content or computing to others becoming ubiquitous. Raspberry Pi is another example of this reality.