6 ms·
Can anyone point me toward Musk's reasoning about why solar will beat out wind power in the long term? I know he owns a solar company, but why did he choose th
by jessriedel 14y ago
Can anyone point me toward Musk's reasoning about why solar will beat out wind power in the long term? I know he owns a solar company, but why did he choose that over wind?
(I'm aware of the basic pros and cons of both. I'm really just looking for Musk's thinking.)
- MikeCapone 14y agoThere's a recent talk here where Musk discusses what he thinks of the future of energy, though I don't think he goes into wind vs. solar specifically (he does explain in the Q&A at the end why he doesn't think biofuels make sense). http://www.treehugger.com/green-investments/tesla-ceo-elon-musk-gives-hour-long-speech-university-oxford-video-and-audio-q-a.html http://www.treehugger.com/green-investments/tesla-ceo-elon-m...
- jessriedel 14y agoThanks much.
- Someone 14y agoI could not find him comapring solar and wind, either. On the risk that you already considered all of these, here are some reasons I can think of: http://www.withouthotair.com/c4/page_32.shtml http://www.withouthotair.com/c4/page_32.shtml gives 2W/m^2 for wind and http://www.withouthotair.com/c6/page_39.shtml http://www.withouthotair.com/c6/page_39.shtml gives 22W/m^2 for photovoltaic. Yes, there are places where you can get much more energy from wind per m^2, but you can get that photovoltaic output almost everywhere. It also is easier to start a solar business than one based on wind power. With solar, you can start small and scale up. With wind, you almost have to start with huge structures, as they have better ROI (higher = faster wind = way more energy). Building such larger structures means that you no longer operate in the B2C market. He may not like that. Also, he may not like having to spend effort and time getting building permission for those structures. He may also think photovoltaics will get cheaper faster than wind. Finally, it might be just a personal preference. To me, wind has more of a blue collar feel than photovoltaics (someone will get his hands greasy operating a wind farm). That does not make me dislike it, but might have swung the choice for him.
- sliverstorm 14y agoIs he actually rooting for photovoltaics? I personally have a number of issues specifically with photovoltaics that I do not have with many other types of solar. IMO any kind of solar "plant" shouldn't be using photovoltaics.
- ak217 14y agoCould you explain why?
- ams6110 14y agoI would speculate (but don't know) that concentration of the heat energy to power a more conventional steam generation plant would be more efficient, at least beyond a certain scale. The best photovoltaic panels are about 20% efficient under optimal conditions.
- ak217 14y agoThey are also closer to the consumer, negating a big chunk of the transmission losses. Also, while thermal electric plants may be more efficient at large scale, I'm not sure how that works at small scale, or if there is a difference in how much capacity they lose in cloudy weather compared to photovoltaics. Actually, I wonder what the ratio of installed photovoltaics to thermals is per region and generator scale.
- ihsw 14y agoThe alternatives seem simpler, specifically solar thermal collectors[1] where they can be used in conjunction with steam turbines and molten salt heat storage. The most obvious disadvantage is that energy collection ability drops sharply on clouded days and it relies entirely on clear skies. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_heating http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_heating
- ak217 14y agoI don't understand how a solar thermal collector is in any way simpler than a photovoltaic array. Actually, it seems more complex to me. Again, could you explain?
- JulianMorrison 14y ago360 by 360 degrees of solar energy spilling off into space, near enough. He also owns a rocket company. Coincidence?
- jaggederest 14y agoYou just blew my goddamn mind. He's thinking so long term, he's planning to corner the market on space-based solar after he's converted the world to run on electric power.
- JulianMorrison 14y agoKardashev 2 or bust.
- hcarvalhoalves 14y agoHe isn't in the electric car business. He's on the empire business.
- zoba 14y agoI believe I remember him pointing out, of all the things that need energy on earth, most of them use the sun as their source either directly or indirectly. Plants are obvious, and animals rely on plants. While products of evolution aren't perfect, they can often be a useful guide.
- w4y2 14y agoWind is really an indirect result of solar energy as well -- solar energy creating different pressures in the atmosphere, which produce wind. You are incorrect in stating that most things use the sun for energy. In fact, everything uses solar energy in one way or another.
- dangrossman 14y agoBacteria that live on nutrients emitted from deep sea hydrothermal vents do not use solar energy. Some theorize this is where life on Earth originated. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrothermal_vent#Biological_communities http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrothermal_vent#Biological_co...
- CamperBob2 14y agoDoesn't that energy ultimately come from tidal forces in the Earth's interior that wouldn't exist if there weren't a Sun to orbit?
- dangrossman 14y agoEarth's spin is due to asymmetry in the accretion of matter during planet formation. The dust and gas that would form the planet was orbiting the center of the nebula before either the sun or planets formed out of it; interstellar nebula begin rotating and flattening before they form a proto-star. If you could pop the sun out of existence, hydrothermal vents would continue feeding bacteria with absolutely no solar energy until the planet eventually shed too much its internal heat (from its initial formation, also not from the sun).
- 14y ago
- InclinedPlane 14y agoWind is far too variable. Even if you have a very well sited wind-farm it could potentially be weeks or months when the effective power output is zero. This is ruinously impractical as a base load power system, whereas solar is far, far more predictable (even with weather variation). The big problem that solar has is storage, which hasn't been worked out yet and probably raises the cost by anywhere from a factor of 2 up to an order of magnitude.
- jessriedel 14y agoSeems like you could easily diversify away most of the wind risk by building wind turbines in many locations and just moving the power (with loss). Also, whatever the cost of solving the storage issue for solar also solves the wind issue, unless storage is only possible over some intermediate time scale. My understanding is that most of the plausible storage mechanisms (pressure, gravitational potential) can store essentially indefinitely, although maybe total capacity is an issue. Without more info, I really don't think it's clear cut.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoYou'd think so but that's not the case. Sometimes there isn't enough wind power in an entire continent to provide power, and this could potentially last for days, even weeks. It's simply not practical to use wind power as base load power. If you look at the Netherlands, for example, you'll see that the way they've always used wind power is for pumping water (draining the polders). And there it doesn't much matter what the instantaneous amount of wind power available is, or even if the windmills are stagnant for a while. All that matters is that over a long period of time you end up with around the same amount of average power produced, and that's what wind power is good at. Potentially it would make sense to use wind turbines for powering specific sorts of activities that didn't rely on low latency of power production and could be automated (perhaps water desalination, for example). But using it as base power is a far more troublesome prospect than using solar.
- jessriedel 14y ago
- zanny 14y agoBesides Musk's viewpoint, I'd argue some simple math. There is vastly more potential power being emanated from the sun every second than there is in the prevailing winds on Earth's surface. The atmosphere being in differing states of high and low pressure is caused by multiple factors, but heating from the sun is one of them. In the long term, almost all of our power is derived from the sun (with exceptions like geothermal, even hydro is dependent on the water cycle being driven by solar heating) anyway - might as well go directly to the source. I just easily see the entire planet being powered by some terrestrial satellite grid of solar panels in a few centuries. Capture it in space, transport it to surface via a space elevator or something, maximum efficiency. Would probably also slow global warming since significantly less heat by that point would be reaching the surface (given the size of an artificial ring belt of solar panels we would need to run everything by then!)
- ams6110 14y agoIf you are capturing energy in space, and channeling it to the ground somehow, how have you reduced net energy reaching the surface of the earth?
- NathanKP 14y agoThe energy is in a different form which won't necessarily raise the temperature of the earth as much as the sunlight hitting the earth would have. Not to mention the hydrocarbon based energy sources replaced by the clean electricity wouldn't be contributing further damage to the environment.
- AlexeiSadeski 14y agoWhen that energy which has been beamed down from space is used, it WILL give off heat. Long term, climate management will be necessary regardless.
- jessriedel 14y agoAs I said elsewhere, I believe there is much more wind and solar energy each than humanity's power demands. It's not a question of total energy, it's a question of cost. And my intuition says that wind would be cheaper because it is of higher density. And in fact wind is significantly cheaper in the current situation where renewable sector is so small that variability and storage isn't an issue.
- AlexeiSadeski 14y agoThere is much, much more solar energy than wind energy for us to harvest.
- jessriedel 14y agoI believe there is much more wind and solar energy each than humanity's power demands. It's not a question of total energy, it's a question of cost.
- tokipin 14y agoThis. The energy output of the Sun is legit ridonculous. Something along the lines of 1 or 2 all the energy ever consumed by humans since forevers per second.
- Peaker 14y agoIs that the total output of the sun or just the energy from the Sun that reaches Earth?