5 ms·
Google is getting better at what Apple does best faster than Apple
- magicalhobo 14y agoThe original was "Google is getting better at what Apple does best faster than Apple is getting better at what Google does best." Truncating the sentence for the title changed the meaning to something much bolder.
- largesse 14y agoPlaying up Google? Now Gruber is just screwing with us.
- parfe 14y agoTreat Gruber like Apple PR and it makes sense. He's seeding the conversation so an upcoming Apple announcement makes sense. Maybe another sub par app release which will be wildly outmatched by the competition, like maps.
- pinaceae 14y agothe big question is though, can Google also be awesome in Services going forward? i am loyal user of chrome, gmail, search, youtube, maps, picasa - in this order. none of which is younger than what, 5 years? innovation in those items? gmail got a new UI, but else? where are the BETA products? used to be the awesomeness of Google. ever since Page took over, they've been killing the small, useful things. ok, they want to be apple. google glass, cars, chromebooks - big ambitious things, big bang approach. nothing below 1500 usd. of course there is android, but that one is slipping away - samsung, amazon, chinese manufacturers - all are eating it up and taking ownership. how come amazon is the premier cloud provider, not google? how come dropbox is the premier storage provider, not google? they are moving from a (ad-supported) knowledge company to a product company. more money there i guess. still makes me sad.
- eurleif 14y ago>gmail got a new UI, but else? Priority inbox? It's pretty useful.
- pinaceae 14y agotrue, don't use it for priority myself though, only to group unread items out of the rest of the inbox. which is indeed awesome.
- ishansharma 14y agoAnd that is real advantage with Google. Priority Inbox(and every other feature) is a quite powerful tool and lets you use it the way you want it. Try that with iCloud mail or any other Apple service. They look good, work well but may feel restrictive after some time!
- patrickaljord 14y agoGoogle Chrome initial release is September 2, 2008. So it's less than 5 years old. Also Android, Google+/Hangouts, Google Voice are pretty nice and yes, ChromeOS is getting better all the time.
- taligent 14y agoDon't forget that they acquired YouTube, Maps, Picasa, Android and Chrome is a wrapper around WebKit.
- graetzer 14y agoChrome is not just a wrapper. WebKit requires you to implement networking, graphics rendering, font rendering etc. There are huge differences between the different WebKit based browsers
- taligent 14y agoSure but you can just defer to the OS for the bulk of those services e.g. CoreGraphics, DirectWrite etc.
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoFrom the original quote [1], what Apple does is "design" while what Google does is "web services". Design is more fragmented than web services and thus easier to break into. If Google + design -> Cupertino while Apple has only to master "web services" the war has already been won. Given how premature that seems, I'd say the core competences identified and thus the analogy as a whole appear to be stacked. [1] http://patrickbgibson.com/post/36041799210/apple-and-twitter http://patrickbgibson.com/post/36041799210/apple-and-twitter
- onemorepassword 14y agoIf design is so much easier, then why have all hardware manufacturers failed so miserably to match Apple over the past two decades? Anything from phones, mp3 players, monitors, tablets, laptops etcetera, they all look cheap, plastic and designed without love and attention to detail. And yes, that includes Google's Nexus range, which aren't ugly but won't win any awards either. It should be possible, look at B&O or Loewe in TV and audio for instance, albeit that they sell at a premium way higher then Apple's. And by the look of it, it's not others they haven't been trying to imitate Apple (hence the lawsuits). As far as I can tell, getting design right is very, very hard, and takes a broad commitment to excellence most companies are lacking. And if one company has very conspicuously ignored design and the basic notion of delighting their users with products that aren't just functionally great but make people fall in love with them, it has been Google. The design of the latest Chromebook is a huge leap, surpassing manufacturers that have attempted to match Apple for years, and comes completely out of left field from a company has so far shown little sign if even having any feeling for design.
- nirvana 14y agoIt's also a pretty blatant copy of the Macbook. Given the history you outline (which I agree with) I think the huge leap for the pixel came from Apple. Just like the huge leap from a blackberry clone to an iPhone clone that android took over the course of 2007-2008.
- nirvana 14y agoYour link to patrik gibson's twitter shows how silly the original hypothesis is. For instance, Apple's stores are still powered by WebObjects because WebObject is still one of the best web frameworks in the world. Do people say that Amazon is "bad at the web" because obidos and gurupa were designed in the 1990s? They're worse than WebObjects by a wide margin. How about all the companies whose web services are from the 1990s? Including google! The rest of his examples are cheap shots or simply based on ignorance. For instance, Game Center having trouble under heavy load is an exceptional event not a daily occurence, and lets not forget the weeks of cummulative time that google has had gmail down because of issues over the years, and all the mail people have lost and the fact that google will just blackhole people's accounts for no reasons and then when it happens you have no way to get your data back. The rest of it is misunderstanding or misrepresentation. In other words, this is just more propaganda in the endless google good, apple bad, ideological war that was started to try and cover the fact that android is a blatant ripoff of iOS.
- taligent 14y agoThe premise is pretty stupid. Firstly Apple does do services. They run the world's biggest media store, the world's biggest syncing platform and a semi popular email service. Sure they aren't perfect but they can be considered successes for the most part. And the point about hardware is completely misguided. Apple's true strength has never been their ability to build a well designed machine. It is the fact that they can do it consistently and ship it on a scale unmatched in the industry. All whilst maintaining a huge profit margin. Until Google can demonstrate that they can actually ship a product and do so profitably then nobody will or should take them seriously.
- patrickaljord 14y agoSo Google just released a laptop that is actually better than an MBA and you think Apple shouldn't take Google seriously? Good thing you're not running Apple.
- taligent 14y agoI think Apple should take every competitor seriously and I am sure they do. My point is that Google has a history of being unable to ship anything properly. And until we see them do so and with a sizable profit margin then they shouldn't be considered in the same league as Apple. And the important skill is not making the laptop it's in the supply chain management.
- patrickaljord 14y agoYou just said "nobody will or should take them seriously" and now you're saying Apple should take them seriously. Google shipped tons of products properly, if you're talking about nexus devices, they don't even advertise those much, they're more of a testbed for what's coming.
- taligent 14y agoNo. Apple should take every competitor seriously no matter how insignificant. The rest of us however shouldn't. And we are talking about hardware here. They have consistent failures in shipping hardware.
- wsc981 14y agoI still don't think Google has the culture to create a good consistent UI, something that has pretty much always been Apple's strongest asset - the reason I keep using Apple products. I don't think this will change, at least not anytime soon. Recently I developed an app for Android, but when using the toolkit and testing on a real device I realised how much stronger Apple is in the department of software design. That's not to say I don't like certain products of Google. I appreciate Gmail very much and I'm very likely to use AppEngine in the near future for a mobile game I plan to develop. I just think Apple is much better when it comes to UI design.
- tonfa 14y agohttp://www.theverge.com/2013/1/24/3904134/google-redesign-how-larry-page-engineered-beautiful-revolution http://www.theverge.com/2013/1/24/3904134/google-redesign-ho...
- bitL 14y agoI am not really happy that Google is cloning all successful approaches from various companies with slight modifications to suit their own purposes. First Facebook, now Apple. Where is that amazing, creative, innovative company I once admired? It's like Microsoft all over again.
- mailarchis 14y agoWell you are not taking into consideration google glass and self driving cars.
- taligent 14y agoYou do realise that Google didn't invent self driving cars and that they aren't even leading the industry. Mercedes Benz demoed the technology nearly 20 years ago and will be shipping cars along with Audi, Volvo etc en masse over the coming years. In fact every single notable car manufacturer has had their own program in place for decades.
- robryan 14y agoHow do we know who is leading the industry if the industry doesn't really exist right now?
- taligent 14y agoFirstly, the car companies have been shipping for the last few years many of the key systems of an autonomous car. Even some of the cheapest cars can self park and auto brake in the event of an impending collision. Adding more sensors and better control systems builds on this. Secondly, nobody knows who is leading the industry. But we know it's not Google since all of the car manufacturers have their own programs in fairly advanced stages. And due to the consolidated nature of the industry key technologies are shared within the groups. So if Google has no one interested in their technologies and they don't make cars then how will they ever lead anything ?
- nirvana 14y ago
- mkr-hn 14y agoThe more thoughtful Apple acolytes are becoming readable lately. This is a good trend.
- addlepate 14y agoGeez, what a fanboy!
- ishansharma 14y agoGoogle is definitely getting better. Their search infrastructure gives them a huge advantage over Apple. I have used Google Now on my friend's Android and it is much better than Siri. I remember someone linking to a video of Google Now (maybe it was Gruber)and commenting, "How fast should Siri be? - This fast!" Google can put a voice over their search interface and boom, they have a Siri alternative that works on any platform(though for web only, but it can integrate with Chrome and Android very easily). Just imagine asking your Chromebook to create a new appointment, that would be a nice feature. Or just asking Chrome to do it. The only problem with Google is that they do not have any customer care! When things go fine, everything is well and good. But one day when your GMail account suddenly stops working and gets blocked, you have no human to talk to!
- jacquesm 14y ago> Just imagine asking your Chromebook to create a new appointment, that would be a nice feature. Or just asking Chrome to do it. > The only problem with Google is that they do not have any customer care! > you have no human to talk to! I think you just solved google's main problem at some point in the future.
- myko 14y ago> Google can put a voice over their search interface and boom Isn't this already done? www.google.com, click the mic in the search box. Also the Google Search app on iOS has similar functionality.
- 7952 14y agoApple sell hardware and Google sell ads, everything else is just semantics. They may be competitive in certain areas but they are making money in completely divergent ways. Companies like Google and Amazon are able to use the Chinese electronics contractors to get products to market without the huge amounts on R&D that Apple had to invest. That is only a threat to Apple if they are unable to make innovative new hardware that can't be replicated quickly.
- jacquesm 14y ago> without the huge amounts on R&D that Apple had to invest. Which amounts are those?
- 7952 14y agoI could look for links that prove my point but whats the point? That information is naturally opaque. I believe that R&D costs are likely to be lower because I see such a huge number of new devices coming from companies without the clout of Google or Android. If Google are spending amounts equivalent to Apple on the pixel they are doing something wrong.
- nirvana 14y agoApple is vastly more efficient at R&D than google is, in part because Apple's products are so profitable, that it's R&D as a proportion of sales is "small". Meanwhile, Apple is investing $10B this year in CapEx, and while a couple billion of that are for server farms, the new HQ and store upgrades, many billions are going into the equipment and tooling necessary to make Apple products. People seem to think you just call fox con and say "I want 100 million mobile phones by monday!" Apple's "R&D" includes the investment in being able to scale a manufacturing business to the point where it can sell twice as many devices as the previous year, for several years running. This is under appreciated by people who look at no-sales devices like the google Nexus and claim that google is in the lead by some arbitrary criteria.
- 14y ago
- nirvana 14y agoI think people musnderstand what it is that Apple does best. And what it is is deliver great products that focus on what the consumer needs. Google has yet to deliver a compelling or wildly popular hardware product to the market. Google is getting really great at propaganda and hype though-- like that carefully set up PR event of brin on the subway with glass. Glass and this computer are both misfires because glass is just a bluetooth headset with a camera-- it needs a network to work. It needs an iPhone or android device to teather too (and I still think its really going to have bad battery life.) Same with this netbook-- it doesnt' have a real operating system, and it relies on being connected to the cloud all the time... which is impractical in a lot of ways. The iPad is the competitor to this device, not the macbook. The macbook is a real computer you can use for development, the iPad you can use for content creation but not really hardcore software development. The iPad is much cheaper, higher build quality, and doesn't need a network connection to really work. Google's delivered a lot of products like the nexus, the nexus q that have had a lot of hype but haven't really been big successes. Until they do make a big hardware success you can't really say they're learning to do what Apple does. It's not like you just call up foxxconn and say "I want 100 million phones made." Meanwhile, what google does best is selling customers to advertisers and search. I'd say Apple getting good at that reasonably fast. Apple's SIRI upended search and was a big jump forward. Apple's iAds has not been as successful, but this is probably due to mobile being a hostile environment for ads (google and facebook aren't having great success yet either.)
- raverbashing 14y agoI agree Having used most linux distros and Mac OS X (and Windows, but I can't stand it anymore now), unfortunately Linux is very behind in user experience (not just interface, but the whole experience) Granted, some of this are hardware/drivers issues (like getting suspend/sleep correctly, good wifi drivers, etc) Maybe Chromebook can make this better. - Google hand picked the hardware and can provide the best (sw) configuration for it - Google makes the browser the center of the experience, so as long as the browser works ok, there's very little beyond that (a basic window manager, network manager, basic linux system, etc) And yes, you're right, it's more close to an "iPad with a keyboard"
- jmduke 14y ago
- onemorepassword 14y agoBut is Google actually that good at services besides a few great products? I'm considering moving away from Google Apps, because besides GMail, most apps are a weak and seem to have become stagnant. Google Drive, which we had been waiting for for half a decade, is still buggy, clunky and unreliable. And don't get me started on the UI and the complete inconsistency between various apps. Yes, Apple has been consistently shite when it comes to online services, and Microsoft entered the game way too late. But I don't think Google has such a major advantage in anything else but search.
- jmduke 14y agoGoogle Apps is a blip: the vast majority of consumers have no idea what it is, what it does, or why it matters. Google Drive has its flaws, but it's infinitely better than iCloud. GMail and Search, Google's largest and oldest offerings, dominate their verticals. I'm pretty much an Apple hardware devotee (iPhone, iPad, MBA) but their services are terrible. iCloud is Kafkaesque; iTunes Match is essentially a scam. I agree that Google is by no means a paragon of great services (I'd actually argue that Amazon is poised to be the service king, except AWS is such a narrow vertical) but they're leaps and bounds past Apple and Microsoft.
- nirvana 14y agoHow is iTunes match a "scam"? It accepts my music downloaded from the pirate bay as proof of purchase then gives me access to it on all my devices. The hugest advantage is not having to manage all of that music on all the machines in our house. We just have one backup somewhere in case we need it, and then everyone syncs with iTunes Match just the music they want on their personal device.
- jmduke 14y ago'Scam' was a bad choice of words, but its ridiculously buggy (it accepts your music downloaded from TPB, but will only take half of an album which I legally bought and ripped to disk) and iOS playback is horrendous (both on and off WiFi.)
- alaskamiller 14y agoApple needs Yahoo and Yahoo needs Apple. Yahoo's culture conditioned by a strong personality cult is on par with Apple's own culture. They bring all the web expertise that can compliment Apple. That's an easy US$25B to spend.