3 ms·
For anyone else who was curious about the drone photographing an environmental violation, here's the denouement and the company's side of the story. In short, t
by temphn 14y ago
For anyone else who was curious about the drone photographing an environmental violation, here's the denouement and the company's side of the story. In short, the Ondruseks state that an unmaintained government-controlled sewer pipe was responsible for the leak.
Your reaction to this story will depend on whether you believe businessmen are mustache-twirlers who pollute rivers...or whether you believe that the kind of government that leaves potholes unfilled for years might jump into action to shift blame and point fingers rather than accept responsibility. From my POV, there doesn't seem to be much motive to intentionally dumping blood into a river rather than down a sewer line, so I kind of think the Ondruseks might be telling the truth.
http://www.suasnews.com/2012/12/20401/columbia-packing-co-indicted-for-pigs-blood-in-trinity-river/ http://www.suasnews.com/2012/12/20401/columbia-packing-co-in...
A Dallas County grand jury returned several indictments on
Wednesday against an Oak Cliff meat packing company
accused of dumping animal blood in a creek that flows into
the Trinity River.
Columbia Packing Company and its owner, Joe Ondrusek,
face twelve indictments for water pollution.
If found guilty, the company could pay fines between
$6,000 and $1.5 million. Ondrusek himself could get
five years in prison and fined up to $100,000 for each
count.
The grand jury also found evidence that the company,
Joe Ondrusek and family member Donny Ondrusek tampered
with physical evidence and returned six counts against
them. The company could face more fines, and the Ondruseks
could face up to 10 years in prison and $10,000
for each charge.
Neighbors near the plant on 11th Street had long
complained about noxious fumes and other problems from the
meat packers. But investigators didn’t get involved until
a remote-controlled toy enthusiast happened to affix a
video camera to an RC aircraft and videotape
gallons of what appeared to be blood gushing down the
river.
Officials from the Dallas County Health Department, Texas
Environmental Crimes Task Force, Texas Commission on
Environmental Quality and Environmental Protection Agency
took photos and tested emissions.
Weeks of investigation found the plant discharged pigs’
blood into Cedar Creek, a tributary of the Trinity River.
In January 2012, the company issued a statement saying it
would never knowingly pollute the environment.
The plant shut down operations a few months later.
http://keranews.org/post/oak-cliff-columbia-packing-tells-pig-blood-story-youtube http://keranews.org/post/oak-cliff-columbia-packing-tells-pi...
WHAT HAPPENED
On Thursday, January 19, 2012, approximately 50
individuals from various governmental agencies executed
a search warrant at our plant. The search warrant accused
Columbia Packing of intentionally dumping waste into the
creek located a couple of hundred yards behind our plant.
Let me be very clear: Columbia Packing did not and has not
intentionally or knowingly polluted or illegally dumped
hazardous materials. Our sewer line ties into a City of
Dallas sewer main. It does NOT dump into the creek as has
been alleged.
There was a clog in the sewer line near a cleanout valve.
When water was used (i.e. washing down after production),
the sewer line was backing up causing water to come out an
overflow/vent pipe. The city of Dallas apparently knew
there was a problem on December 9th, but allowed it to
continue and did not notify us until 41 days later when
government agencies served search warrants.
Two days before the warrants were served, a Columbia lawn
mowing crew discovered the sewer overflow. We immediately
called a plumber and took swift action to begin stopping
the overflow. The clog was cleared and the line was open
and running cleanly into the city’s sewer main in less
than 24 hours.
If the city had contacted us on December 9th, the problem
would have been fixed the same day. Instead, the city
knowingly allowed this overflow to continue for 41 days.
Government officials did something my family never would
have done- they allowed products to contaminate the
Trinity River for more than a month without taking
corrective action. The City has full access to our
property at all times to test the sewer line. At any time,
officials could have entered our property to find the
source of the overflow.
There is no cross connection between our sewer line and
storm water. The City has now dye-tested and camera
inspected our sewer lines, and our sewer line is clear and
goes to the city sewer main. The city maintains a box on
our sewer line that has for years monitored the amount of
waste water going through the line and the substances
contained in the waste water. The city monitors this
locked box on its own schedule.
When the City searched our property they found 18 possible
code violations. Within 30 days we addressed and repaired
each issue the City brought to our attention. Keep in
mind, our Oak Cliff facility has been in operation since
the early 1930’s, and the City of Dallas has never cited us
for any violations in the past.
- techsupporter 14y agoThere was a clog in the sewer line near a cleanout valve. This sounds like the cleanout is on the sewer customer's property. The City has full access to our property at all times to test the sewer line. At any time, officials could have entered our property to find the source of the overflow. Not in Texas, they don't. The city water/sewer department or sewage treatment company (or district) does not have right of entry into a property unless invited by the subscriber. The subscriber has the duty to ensure that the equipment on his or her property is functioning as designed. That is why laws requiring water sprinkler backflow valves are enforced at the junction between the city's water pipe and the customer's water pipe. The city or supply company shut off the valve on their side of the pipe. Property demarcation is a huge thing in Texas. The city of Dallas apparently knew there was a problem on December 9th, but allowed it to continue and did not notify us until 41 days later when government agencies served search warrants. This I can believe (I mean, lolcityofdallas amirite?) but it does not absolve the property owner of liability for failure to maintain the sanitary sewer connection on his property. The city maintains a box on our sewer line that has for years monitored the amount of waste water going through the line and the substances contained in the waste water. The city monitors this locked box on its own schedule. And when your sewer bill was half of what it should be, this didn't raise any eyebrows? If there's one thing Dallas Water Utilities does shockingly well, it's collect money from ratepayers. I think that sending in the mod squad and filing charges was overkill. The Trinity has been used and abused for decades and people are just now trying to clean it up, so it doesn't shock me that TCEQ and Dallas dropped the hammer on this fellow.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y ago>Your reaction to this story will depend on whether you believe businessmen are mustache-twirlers who pollute rivers...or whether you believe that the kind of government that leaves potholes unfilled for years might jump into action to shift blame and point fingers rather than accept responsibility. Experience has taught me to trust neither. The city's failure to fix a valve doesn't absolve a party's responsibility to not pollute. Was the valve clogged? Or was it spec'd too small to begin with? The town I live in has a plant (not a meat packer) that has the same problem, with the same result. I'm loving the typical Texas politician response too. Noticed a business breaking the law? Make noticing things like that a crime!