3 ms·
"The financial system in the U.S. is horribly inefficient. Retail transactions conducted with credit cards cost 2-3%, which is a ridiculously high cost given t
by codex 14y ago
"The financial system in the U.S. is horribly inefficient. Retail transactions conducted with credit cards cost 2-3%, which is a ridiculously high cost given today's technology."
No.
The reason banks charge high transaction fees on credit cards has to do with how credit cards are billed. The billing cycle for a card is 30 days, after which you have 30 days to pay. This is effectively a loan for which you are paying zero interest. Somebody must pay, though, because you are risky, unsecured debt and your interest rate is maybe 12 percent. Up to two months of free credit therefore costs the bank two percent, which they charge the merchant.
Credit card companies could shorten this billing cycle once the delays of snail mail are no longer commonplace, but that doesn't reduce the transaction cost--it only moves it from the merchant to the consumer, who now begins to accrue interest charges earlier. Consumers could theoretically pay off their debts faster and thus pay less interest, but only to a point, because most consumers live paycheck to paycheck and will carry a balance until their biweekly paycheck isn't eaten up by rent and auto payments--roughly a month.
And I would argue that most consumers and banks prefer the grace period and simple interest calculations; it makes the whole billing process easy to understand.
- graeme 14y agoWhat are the fees charged for a purchase made with a bank card instead of a credit card. (debit cards in Canada, not sure what you call them in the states)
- dangrossman 14y agoThe interchange fees for debit transactions start around 0.8% for Visa. The exact fee varies by card type and by merchant category code. That's about half what Visa charges on low-end credit cards.
- lisper 14y agoJust because my interest rate is 12% doesn't mean that this is the cost to the bank. The cost to the bank of floating this loan is the rate the bank pays for its money, which has been about 0.2% for the last four years. But you do raise a valid point: part of the problem is the conflation of payments and credit. I'll be writing about that in a future post.
- codex 14y agoThe bank's costs also include bad debt and fraud, which are high for credit cards; are you including those in your figures? At any rate, the opportunity cost to the bank of giving free credit to the consumer (by structuring the billing cycle this way) is the retail cost of the money (what you would have paid them) not the wholesale cost. Debit cards are a whole different story, of course, because no credit is extended.