8 ms·
Texas Declares War on Drones
- janson0 14y agoI love my state...
- janson0 14y agoI didn't even realize you could get down-voted on here ha. Well, sorry for my comment, I guess?
- macspoofing 14y agoThe right call for the wrong reasons
- largesse 14y agoI'm fine with citizens having drones but not the government.
- warmwaffles 14y agoI agree completely, but it takes the government paying a private entity to do surveillance. Far fetched, but still plausible
- carbocation 14y agoWhy is that far fetched? It's how roads and prisons are managed.
- enraged_camel 14y agoNot sure if the latter is a good example, since the prison industry is one of the most corrupt in the country.
- carbocation 14y agoNeither are meant to be good examples. The outsourcing of prisons, in particular, should seem to be a far-fetched concept that nevertheless occurs regularly. I don't see the outsourcing of domestic surveillance to be any more far-fetched.
- bmelton 14y agoAlso, a very great deal of sensitive government IT operations are outsourced to contractors and vendors and the like.
- hadronzoo 14y ago> Law enforcement officers could only use drones while executing a search warrant or if they had probable cause to believe someone is committing a felony, and firefighters can only use drones for fighting fire or to rescue a person whose life is “in imminent danger.” Texas’ border-patrolling Predator drones are exempt within 25 miles of the Mexican border. There are additional penalties for possession, display or distribution of data captured by an illegally flown drone. Gooden said the goal is to protect Texans’ privacy. http://www.popsci.com/technology/article/2013-02/privacy-and-drones http://www.popsci.com/technology/article/2013-02/privacy-and...
- largesse 14y agoThe "probable cause" exemption is bullshit. If you have probable cause, get a warrant. No patrols, no police drone leaves the ground without a warrant targeting a specific person or group.
- jasonwocky 14y agoDepending on the details, the "probable cause that someone is committing a felony" exemption is common to law enforcement. Exigent circumstances. If a police officer hears signs of a struggle in your house, he doesn't have to get a judge to sign a warrant before he kicks the door down.
- mattstreet 14y agoBut the way that gets used seems to be the officer somehow smells pot on every damn person they want to violate.
- bmelton 14y agoIt's interesting you bring that up, as whether or not a drug-sniffing dog's alert is considered grounds for determining probable cause was recently tested by the Supreme Court. I won't bore you with the full explanation of who won or why, but what I found interesting is that the dog's past performance comes in to play, the results of their testing, time in the field, etc. Also, the k-9 (human) officers are supposed to keep a record of their results to be provided should this come into question (which raises all sorts of things about false positives, false negatives, etc., due to ignored reporting of incidents that didn't otherwise generate paperwork). I'm wondering now if there shouldn't be some similar standard of proof for police officers. I've never had the "smells like pot in there" pulled on me for any reason, but I almost hope that it happens at some point so that I can poll the officer's record to see how many times he's used that line as probable cause and what the feasibility of that is.
- LAMike 14y agoWhat if I took a photo of someone on the ground on their own private property? That's not a crime right? So whats the difference if I take a photo not from the ground? It suddenly becomes illegal?
- callmeed 14y agoIt's a crime if you photograph them where they have a reasonable expectation of privacy [1]. That's generally easy to interpret for normal (ground) photography. But if I'm in my fenced backyard sunbathing nude and your drone photographs me, that could be up for debate/discussion. It'll be interesting, that's for sure. 1. http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/tech/columnist/andrewkantor/2006-08-11-photography-rights_x.htm http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/tech/columnist/andrewkantor/2...
- ttttannebaum 14y agoWow, how disappointing. Just another lesson demonstrating that if you hear about a law being passed and it sounds good (or bad), it's really just motivated by the interests of those with the most power.
- OldSchool 14y agoTexas and its long tradition of "pride of independence" has, at best, only resulted in a parallel version of Federal Government policy. Undesirable Federal policy X will almost always still show up in Texas - it will just be presented and perceived as though it has been arrived-at independently as the will of Texans. If sovereignty is your thing, other than a strong stand on gun rights there are states in the US with policy that correlates far less with D.C. and they don't make it their claim to fame either.
- hadronzoo 14y agoI've participated in the political process in Texas and I'm not sure that this is true. Take for example HB 80: http://www.capitol.state.tx.us/tlodocs/83R/billtext/pdf/HB00080I.pdf http://www.capitol.state.tx.us/tlodocs/83R/billtext/pdf/HB00...
- OldSchool 14y agoI remember hearing about this and the subsequent threats to cut off travel to Texas. Yes, it is nice to hear when Texas lawmakers stand up for their state's sovereignty.
- buddylw 14y agoThis is a knee-jerk reaction to a situation that the Texas legislature really can't stop. Cameras are becoming more and more ubiquitous with or without drones. Even with the law there's nothing stopping someone from posting illegally captured photos anonymously. The hobbyists will be ones that feel the impact of the law and the more clandestine drone operators that they aim to prevent will continue unabated. I'm sure that in the not so distant future when any police officer can launch a drone all of these privacy worries will go right out the window. In the words of U.S. Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis, "Sunlight is said to be the best of disinfectants; electric light the most efficient policeman." The good news here is that thanks to technology, our future is definitely going to be a bright place for all of us whether we like it or not.
- bmelton 14y agoI pretty much agree with you, but having seen the demo of the drone, there's a pretty big difference between a camera on every street corner, and a camera flying 3 miles up in the sky that you can't possibly see, but that is able to watch, draw boxes around and track every moving object in a small city. Again, I don't exactly know where the line is or should be drawn, but the 1.8Gigapixel camera on those drones are just super creepy.
- Qantourisc 14y agoNext up camera on a balloon!
- josephkern 14y agoAlready there; they are called aerostats.
- temphn 14y agoFor anyone else who was curious about the drone photographing an environmental violation, here's the denouement and the company's side of the story. In short, the Ondruseks state that an unmaintained government-controlled sewer pipe was responsible for the leak. Your reaction to this story will depend on whether you believe businessmen are mustache-twirlers who pollute rivers...or whether you believe that the kind of government that leaves potholes unfilled for years might jump into action to shift blame and point fingers rather than accept responsibility. From my POV, there doesn't seem to be much motive to intentionally dumping blood into a river rather than down a sewer line, so I kind of think the Ondruseks might be telling the truth. http://www.suasnews.com/2012/12/20401/columbia-packing-co-indicted-for-pigs-blood-in-trinity-river/ http://www.suasnews.com/2012/12/20401/columbia-packing-co-in... A Dallas County grand jury returned several indictments on Wednesday against an Oak Cliff meat packing company accused of dumping animal blood in a creek that flows into the Trinity River. Columbia Packing Company and its owner, Joe Ondrusek, face twelve indictments for water pollution. If found guilty, the company could pay fines between $6,000 and $1.5 million. Ondrusek himself could get five years in prison and fined up to $100,000 for each count. The grand jury also found evidence that the company, Joe Ondrusek and family member Donny Ondrusek tampered with physical evidence and returned six counts against them. The company could face more fines, and the Ondruseks could face up to 10 years in prison and $10,000 for each charge. Neighbors near the plant on 11th Street had long complained about noxious fumes and other problems from the meat packers. But investigators didn’t get involved until a remote-controlled toy enthusiast happened to affix a video camera to an RC aircraft and videotape gallons of what appeared to be blood gushing down the river. Officials from the Dallas County Health Department, Texas Environmental Crimes Task Force, Texas Commission on Environmental Quality and Environmental Protection Agency took photos and tested emissions. Weeks of investigation found the plant discharged pigs’ blood into Cedar Creek, a tributary of the Trinity River. In January 2012, the company issued a statement saying it would never knowingly pollute the environment. The plant shut down operations a few months later. http://keranews.org/post/oak-cliff-columbia-packing-tells-pig-blood-story-youtube http://keranews.org/post/oak-cliff-columbia-packing-tells-pi... WHAT HAPPENED On Thursday, January 19, 2012, approximately 50 individuals from various governmental agencies executed a search warrant at our plant. The search warrant accused Columbia Packing of intentionally dumping waste into the creek located a couple of hundred yards behind our plant. Let me be very clear: Columbia Packing did not and has not intentionally or knowingly polluted or illegally dumped hazardous materials. Our sewer line ties into a City of Dallas sewer main. It does NOT dump into the creek as has been alleged. There was a clog in the sewer line near a cleanout valve. When water was used (i.e. washing down after production), the sewer line was backing up causing water to come out an overflow/vent pipe. The city of Dallas apparently knew there was a problem on December 9th, but allowed it to continue and did not notify us until 41 days later when government agencies served search warrants. Two days before the warrants were served, a Columbia lawn mowing crew discovered the sewer overflow. We immediately called a plumber and took swift action to begin stopping the overflow. The clog was cleared and the line was open and running cleanly into the city’s sewer main in less than 24 hours. If the city had contacted us on December 9th, the problem would have been fixed the same day. Instead, the city knowingly allowed this overflow to continue for 41 days. Government officials did something my family never would have done- they allowed products to contaminate the Trinity River for more than a month without taking corrective action. The City has full access to our property at all times to test the sewer line. At any time, officials could have entered our property to find the source of the overflow. There is no cross connection between our sewer line and storm water. The City has now dye-tested and camera inspected our sewer lines, and our sewer line is clear and goes to the city sewer main. The city maintains a box on our sewer line that has for years monitored the amount of waste water going through the line and the substances contained in the waste water. The city monitors this locked box on its own schedule. When the City searched our property they found 18 possible code violations. Within 30 days we addressed and repaired each issue the City brought to our attention. Keep in mind, our Oak Cliff facility has been in operation since the early 1930’s, and the City of Dallas has never cited us for any violations in the past.
- tomjen3 14y agoThis is a great and very necessary law. Do you want fotage of your 3 year old playing in an inflated pool in your back yard to end up on pedo.net because you didn't put a cammo net over your back yard? Parrot drones are super fun, but it isn't hard to play with them responsibly.
- jlgreco 14y ago> Do you want fotage of your 3 year old playing in an inflated pool in your back yard to end up on pedo.net because you didn't put a cammo net over your back yard? Where does one acquire such an extreme level of paranoia? I mean, seriously...
- tomjen3 14y agoFollow politics close enough, each step the police gets better technology and so what used to be ok, like the police beeing able to follow a suspect ends up meaning that they can slap a cheap GPS tracker on any car, all without a warrent. Of course it is admissible evidence when the police see you sell heroin on the street, it is a little different when that gets changed intro a drone that can watch entire neighborhoods from the air. And when the police gets those rights, so will other people.
- jmccree 14y agoOne word: paparazzi. They've rented helicopters to get pictures of weddings. Cheap and easy drones? They'll be hovering over every starlet's swimming pool attempting to get bikini pics. Private graveyard service? No worries, 10 drones hovering 10 feet above to capture the video of the grieving widow. What's to keep people from using drones to hover outside Donald Trump's windows 24/7 streaming views of his living room? Sure, your average joe nobody is not likely to be targeted, but as the cost to acquire aerial video goes from $x,xxx an hour for a helicopter, to $x/hr for a drone, it will be used far more widely. In the past, it was prohibitively expensive and time consuming to do surveillance work. Now a smart phone with 4G tied to a balloon can stream HD feeds. In the past, you had a reasonable expectation of privacy in the curtilage of your home. If drones can take high resolution photos (and video) from the air, this becomes null and void. I personally would prefer we have laws to protect privacy instead being forced to completely enclose all outdoor pools or risk showing up on poolperv.com's drone feeds. (Per my reading, the Video Voyeurism Prevention Act of 2004 would not ban bathing suit video)
- meaty 14y agoAnd I was hoping for a small surface to air missile system :) I'm considering spending some time on an anti drone technology startup. I have some ideas.
- femto 14y agoI'd guess the aim is to make drones illegal, rather than actually prevent them from flying (ie. make the law, but don't enforce it). At zero cost to the state, this will mean any evidence gathered by a civilian drone will be illegally obtained and so inadmissible in court.
- DanielBMarkham 14y agoAs both a libertarian and tech junkie, I have serious concerns about the use of drone surveillance and am excited to see the technology develop. The best I can figure, what's needed is parity in drone use. That is, whatever is good for the government should automatically be good for the citizens to do. If the government wants to use hi-res cameras to surveil a city all day long, then anybody else should be able to do so too. If the government wants to arm drones, then I should be able to arm my own drones. I don't think that's an answer, but I think it will work for a decade or two -- hopefully long enough for us to develop workable policies.
- ck2 14y agoSadly it's not a war on drone use by any level of government, only individuals. I suspect government drones will get federal protection if people try to use them as skeet targets when they fly over their property. Countdown to when the public starts to say "oh well, what can you do, we need to be safe" (ala TSA).
- bmelton 14y agoTheir comfortable viewing distance is something like 12,000 feet, which is almost 3 miles up. You're not likely to have anybody shooting at them because they'll never see them. That said, I agree that people will accept their new passengerless overlords, and it'll probably start in New York.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- _account 14y agoSeems as though the title is not specific enough. It should read "Texas Businesses Declare War on Drones". Yet another case of moneyed interests exerting direct control over the proletariat's freedoms. Yay Fascism.