3 ms·
> X mitigates Y. Y occurred. Thus X does nothing? No. X was intended to prevent Y. Y occurred -- to the tune of $100M. And it was not an isolated incident.
by lisper 14y ago
> X mitigates Y. Y occurred. Thus X does nothing?
No. X was intended to prevent Y. Y occurred -- to the tune of $100M. And it was not an isolated incident. Therefore X fails to prevent Y. In addition, X has lots of deleterious effects, not least of which is stifling competition.
> this article does a poor job of highlighting why the law is better dead than alive or modified
That's why this article is part of a (long, and not yet completed) series.
> Payment processors would be expected to fail from time to time
This is only true because the underlying infrastructure is antiquated and broken. With a modern payment processing system based on a secure protocol there is no reason a payment processor should ever fail (other than fraud, but that is already a crime under federal law).
- charonn0 14y agoPosting of a bond, whether by a criminal defendant, civil plaintiff, or as a condition of some license is never presumed to eradicate malfeasance. It is a deterrent only: if the bond is sufficiently large then the person or business so bonded will be strongly hesitant to risk losing it. Hesitant, but not otherwise restrained.
- thinkcomp 14y agoBut if you make the bond absurdly large and never enforce the law, then no one bothers getting it because A) they can't resonably and B) there isn't any point. Then add in twenty other ridiculous conditions and the whole thing becomes a total joke. Which is why HN companies don't bother complying at all, if they even know it exists.
- eqreqeq 14y ago>>No. X was intended to prevent Y. Y occurred -- to the tune of $100M. And it was not an isolated incident. Therefore X fails to prevent Y. In addition, X has lots of deleterious effects, not least of which is stifling competition. X= A ticket for illegal parking Y= People still park illegally Therefore X fails to prevent Y Now go ahead and replace X and Y for any type of law and crime. By your logic we might as well abolish or laws or regulations because there is still plenty of crime.
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoThe bond is meant to reduce, not eliminate, the frequency of fraud. It also makes winding up a failing institution smoother. Yes, this impacts efficiency, but it also decreases risk. One could argue about the size of the bond, but as a mechanism it's a technique with a good history across finance. Also, no firm is bust-proof. There are a number of human and technical errors that could take down a payment processor. Payment processors are also exposed to payment fraud. There there is good old competitive pressure.
- danbmil99 14y agoI would willingly take the risk of default on small purchases (< $100) in return for saving 3% on the cost of the transaction. This would pay off every 50 or so transactions -- and the failure rate is likely orders of magnitude lower than that.
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoConsumers don't bear the brunt of the risk of a payment processor folding. The merchant with millions of accounts payable, an unsecured claim, does. I agree with the core of the post: the system is too cautious. I disagree with the call to lower the bar for starting a payment processor to parity with a photo sharing app.
- lisper 14y agoRepealing the MTA would not lower the bar "to parity with a photo sharing app". There are still a whole host of federal regulations that you have to comply with.
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoPerhaps this would be a more concise argument than the multi-series approach? In essence, federal regulation is more than enough and the California finish is superfluous.
- sophacles 14y agoI think one of the problems people are having is that mitigate means "lessen the impact of" not "completely eliminate" a problem. So saying: X mitigates Y. Y occurred after X to the effect of $N. is largely unhelpful, unless you provide a supporting statement of: Prior to X, Y occurred to the affect of $M. Now if M <= N, X is a complete failure. If M > N it is some sort of success, (adjusting for the costs of X is assumed here). Now, there is valid discussion about the how much M needs to be greater than N to make X worth it, but, this sort of comparison is needed to properly discuss X.