4 ms·
I guess I'm just willing to accept the holocaust without questioning the evil involved -- a small kernel of evil, and then lots of self-reinforcing fear and sel
by rdl 14y ago
I guess I'm just willing to accept the holocaust without questioning the evil involved -- a small kernel of evil, and then lots of self-reinforcing fear and self interest, could lead a population of some evil and some just weak people to do horrible things. The banality of evil and all. It's less bad than otherwise because the Nazis were utterly destroyed; yes, they were horrible almost beyond consideration, but they're gone now, so there isn't as much of an ongoing concern there.
But what amazes me and makes me feel the most shame about humanity is how the US and other western nations acted w.r.t. immigration and refugees during the pre-war period, and then how the victors acted after the war (large numbers of German civilians and non-nazi German POWs died after the war, too, and in the USSR, there were POWs in "prison" for a decade after). And the US Japanese-American internment, etc. Very little was said about any of this until the 1980s.
- oijaf888 14y agoI thought after the war the victors (at least England and the US) treated the refugees and immigrants quite well. Admittedly not as well as their own troops in the area but humanely. I know France and the USSR treated the refugees very harshly though.
- rdl 14y agoI don't know how much of it was limited resources vs. punitive, but even the US and UK (who were the best of the victors) allowed hundreds of thousands (potentially millions) to die of starvation and disease. But life for UK civilians in the immediate post-war period was also not very good. The US is the country which probably retained the most industrial/agricultural capacity and could have done more.
- oijaf888 14y agoYeah from my understanding everyone was on rations in Europe and the civillians got the short end as far as quantity and quality goes. That is a good point though, I wonder if the lack of food was due to long supplie lines and a decrease in production in the US or if it just wasn't prioritized high enough.
- Alex3917 14y ago"The banality of evil and all." And thanks to modern technology, evil today is even more banal.
- ippisl 14y agoYou can add to that the repeated refusal of the allies to accept hitler's offers to take jews out of german territory, even while there was some knowledge or at least rumors about the holocaust.
- meaty 14y agoI think the worst bit and the bit which may have lead to a lot of deaths was the shitty handling of the camps by the US and European allies. A relative of mine, a German civilian but not a sympathizer was employed to deliver supplies to the camps. According to him, after the war supplies were cut by the allies and people were left to starve to death. People were so hungry they were eating their clothes. Those camps by then contained both nazi and civilian prisoners mixed together as well resulting in murders, violence and factions of prisoners. There's as much evil on both sides if you ask me. The whole thing was a complete mess from end to end. Only the victors get to put pen to page. The victors also pretty much legislated against debating anything other than the official stories. Note: I'm not denying anything, but some things have gone unsaid. When you're not allowed to talk, faith is required and faith is inadequate in this day and age.