5 ms·
Repeal the California Money Transmission Act
- thinkcomp 14y agoIn addition to Ron's excellent summary, if you're not yet convinced but still interested as to why the MTA should be repealed--and it definitely should--it's a long and sad tale. (As I've said other places, I'm personally not against uniform, reasonable regulation at the federal level, but the MTA is the wrong way to do it for so many reasons.) Bits and pieces can be found here: Think White Paper (Broad Overview) Held Hostage - http://www.thinkcomputer.com/corporate/whitepapers/heldhostage.pdf http://www.thinkcomputer.com/corporate/whitepapers/heldhosta... Think Legislative Comments (Extremely Detailed) November 7, 2012 - https://s.facecash.com/legal/20121107.dficomment.pdf https://s.facecash.com/legal/20121107.dficomment.pdf February 25, 2013 - https://s.facecash.com/legal/20130225.packetnumbered.pdf https://s.facecash.com/legal/20130225.packetnumbered.pdf Personal Essays May 10, 2011 - In Fifty Days, Payments Innovation Will Stop In Silicon Valley - http://www.aarongreenspan.com/writing/essay.html?id=54 http://www.aarongreenspan.com/writing/essay.html?id=54 June 1, 2011 - In Thirty Days, Payments Innovation Will Stop In Silicon Valley - http://www.aarongreenspan.com/writing/essay.html?id=59 http://www.aarongreenspan.com/writing/essay.html?id=59 June 14, 2011 - Why I'm Furious with Silicon Valley - http://www.aarongreenspan.com/writing/essay.html?id=60 http://www.aarongreenspan.com/writing/essay.html?id=60 July 20, 2011 - The California Law That Should Send The President and Fellows of Harvard College (and Every Private University) To Prison - http://www.aarongreenspan.com/writing/essay.html?id=62 http://www.aarongreenspan.com/writing/essay.html?id=62 December 5, 2011 - Why I'm Suing the State of California - http://www.aarongreenspan.com/writing/essay.html?id=73 http://www.aarongreenspan.com/writing/essay.html?id=73 July 16, 2012 - Naked Regulation: Capital Requirements Don't Work - http://www.aarongreenspan.com/writing/essay.html?id=77 http://www.aarongreenspan.com/writing/essay.html?id=77 July 23, 2012 - Hypocrisy Comes Full Circle: Money Transmission Meets Campaign Finance - http://www.aarongreenspan.com/writing/essay.html?id=78 http://www.aarongreenspan.com/writing/essay.html?id=78 February 13, 2013 - In Nine Days, the California Money Transmission Act Could Get Even Worse - http://www.aarongreenspan.com/writing/essay.html?id=86 http://www.aarongreenspan.com/writing/essay.html?id=86 FaceCash Lawsuit (Think Computer Corporation v. Venchiarutti, et al) http://www.plainsite.org/flashlight/case.html?id=716056 http://www.plainsite.org/flashlight/case.html?id=716056 http://www.facecash.com/legal/brown.html http://www.facecash.com/legal/brown.html MoneyGram USDOJ Lawsuit (USA v. MoneyGram International, Inc.) http://www.plainsite.org/flashlight/case.html?id=2334104 http://www.plainsite.org/flashlight/case.html?id=2334104 Square, Inc. Cease & Desist Letter (Illinois)* http://www.idfpr.com/dfi/CCD/Discipline/SquarePersonifiedCDOrder13CC208.pdf http://www.idfpr.com/dfi/CCD/Discipline/SquarePersonifiedCDO... * Not directly related to the MTA, but illustrative of how even licensure under the MTA for a California company with a former Secretary of the Treasury on its Board, good lawyers, and a very wealthy founder is not enough to comply and avoid violating federal law. 18 U.S.C. § 1960 http://www.plainsite.org/laws/index.html?id=14426 http://www.plainsite.org/laws/index.html?id=14426
- khuey 14y ago1. Law is passed to reduce fraud. 2. An incident of fraud occurs under the new law. 3. Law is pointless and should be repealed. 1+2 do not imply 3. I don't know much about the California MTA. It may very well be a terrible piece of legislation that prevents desperately needed innovation. But the argument presented here is laughable.
- thinkcomp 14y agoIt's more like... 1. Paid lobbyist writes law to protect enormous clients, convinces consumer advocates and legislators that it's in the best interest of the public and that there is "industry consensus" (actual words used). 2. Many incidents of fraud occur under the new law, including one that is nationwide to the tune of $120 million (settled for $100 million in three weeks to avoid an admission of guilt) involving one of the paid lobbyist's clients, whose license for some reason is not revoked. 3. Law is protectionist and not in the public's interest and should be repealed. Issues like this are complex and deserve our attention. The argument isn't laughable, it's just the tip of a very complicated iceberg.
- khuey 14y agoIf the issue is complex the author shouldn't try to dumb it down as far as he did.
- itafroma 14y agoLinks to the Hacker News discussions from previous parts, compiled because I was curious and on occasion a mention to a Hacker News discussion is made without a link: Part 1: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5265563 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5265563 Part 2: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5276471 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5276471 Part 3: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5295236 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5295236 Part 4: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5302661 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5302661
- JumpCrisscross 14y ago“The theory is that by requiring businesses that move money around on behalf of third parties to get licenses and post large bonds, that this will cut down on fraud. This theory was almost immediately falsified by the discovery that Moneygram, a licensed money transfer agent, had engaged in a massive fraud. And this was not an isolated incident. So the MTA clearly does nothing to prevent fraud.” X mitigates Y. Y occurred. Thus X does nothing? Posting bonds isn't to prevent fraud as much as to limit losses from disorderly unwindings. Think of it as the transaction equivalent of capital reserves. Is the system broken? Yes. It's slow, fragmented, and overly cautious which serves to protect vested interests. But this article does a poor job of highlighting why the law is better dead than alive or modified. Let's take as an example asset management regulation. Processors above a certain size must file capital adequacy, amongst other, disclosures. Regulators have the power to conduct investigations and, ultimately, suspend a processor's connections to the U.S. banking system. The advantage of a reactionary regulatory approach is speed and flexibility. Payment processors would be expected to fail from time to time, but fail gracefully, in a way that doesn't threaten to shut down the economy's ability to process payments (cash and bank-to-bank transfers are the safety mechanism).
- lisper 14y ago> X mitigates Y. Y occurred. Thus X does nothing? No. X was intended to prevent Y. Y occurred -- to the tune of $100M. And it was not an isolated incident. Therefore X fails to prevent Y. In addition, X has lots of deleterious effects, not least of which is stifling competition. > this article does a poor job of highlighting why the law is better dead than alive or modified That's why this article is part of a (long, and not yet completed) series. > Payment processors would be expected to fail from time to time This is only true because the underlying infrastructure is antiquated and broken. With a modern payment processing system based on a secure protocol there is no reason a payment processor should ever fail (other than fraud, but that is already a crime under federal law).
- charonn0 14y agoPosting of a bond, whether by a criminal defendant, civil plaintiff, or as a condition of some license is never presumed to eradicate malfeasance. It is a deterrent only: if the bond is sufficiently large then the person or business so bonded will be strongly hesitant to risk losing it. Hesitant, but not otherwise restrained.
- pbreit 14y agoWhen you say things like "does nothing to prevent fraud" and "does nothing to protect me as a consumer" you have lost me for I know these statements to be untrue.
- pbreit 14y ago4 or 5 long essays about a "simple solution" and yet I have almost no idea of what the solution might look like. Is it really that difficult to describe the user experience in a paragraph or 2?
- lisper 14y agoI can describe it in one sentence: replace the existing protocol with one where payment authorization is done with secure digital signatures.
- pbreit 14y agoThat's really not helpful. What is the user experience at the checkout counter? Are there any new instruments or hardware involved? How are such things deployed to consumers and merchants?
- lisper 14y agoTroll. You already asked me that, and I already answered it.
- pbreit 14y agoThen please humor me and either point me to such an answer or repeat it here. When I walk into a store and pay with your service, what is the experience? Your answer need not mention digital signatures (unless you are referring to the actual signing on some sort of touch screen as you sometimes see these days; and in which case i know your solution is a non-starter for deployment reasons) or encryption. And enough with the "troll" stuff. I am not remotely such. 16 very successful years in the payments industry.
- lisper 14y agohttp://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5296345 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5296345
- 14y ago
- toomim 14y agoBitcoin.
- josephagoss 14y agoThis law is all about the company moving money around, not a restriction on the money itself. So using BTC would not make a difference.
- thinkcomp 14y agoCorrect. If you are a fan of Bitcoin then you should definitely favor repeal because right now all Bitcoin exchange services are unlicensed and therefore illegal under the state and federal statutes.
- josephagoss 14y agoIf an exchange is in a different country then how can it be illegal? The only law that affects me is both the law of the country the exchange is located and the law of my country. Being as the exchange I use is based in Hong Kong and my country is Australia, USA laws do not apply to me. I understand that the USA law will apply to the majority of BTC users however, because most of the exchanges and developers are all USA based, unfortunately. Also I believe that Bitcoin-Central is licensed to operate in the European union.
- thinkcomp 14y agoSorry, I was thinking of U.S. exchanges. You're correct that international ones are outside of the scope of U.S. law--though interestingly, California does take the view that the MTA can police other states.
- toomim 14y agoYou don't need a money transfer agent if you're using bitcoin. You just send it to the other party directly. It's possible, though, that the law could interpret the global web of bitcoin miners to be "money transfer agents" and then all hell would break loose. I guess all the miners would just move out of california. :)
- contingencies 14y agoThe California Money Transmission Act is only one small portion of a greater struggle that is going on across the planet; a struggle that cuts to the very core of our societies, our diplomacy, our fundamental rights and freedoms, and nothing less than the future our world. It is a logical outgrowth of globalization, of technology, and of the internet. For international finance is the last great systems, next to law and the rule of government itself, that has not yet been toppled or reorganized by internet based, distributed technologies. Media has fallen. Education has fallen. Retail has fallen. Transport has fallen. Manufacturing seems to be coming under threat. Finance is certainly under threat, but it consistently beckons for state protection under the ruse of protecting the public from the ethereal boogeyman. Why? To cut to the chase, finance is government: they are in essence one and the same. Throughout modern history, the state's monopoly on physical violence has been used to collect taxes; taxes that must be paid in the state's own currency. Often, the use of foreign tender is made illegal. The money, otherwise backed by little, thus acquires value: you need it to stay out of the state's jails or system of punishment, to eat, and to live. Almost without exception, the state then further demands interest or otherwise manipulates their currency's value. At the turn of the 16th century, Martin Luther's doctrine of the two kingdoms marked the beginning of the modern separation of church and state, which was enshrined in to law in many countries throughout the 20th century. I believe that today, citizens have had enough of financial abuses, and our societies stand on the threshold of one further separation: the separation of state and finance. For as we have seen over the past few years, at present we have a financial system that sees itself above the law. A financial system that, despite reaping vast profits and efficiently systematizing both usury and the total, constant, warrantless international surveillance of private citizens and corporations alike (for it is inseparable from the state), has for the past twenty or thirty years failed to provide meaningful innovation or reduction in price, to provide transparency, to provide protection against corruption, to provide any meaningful service to society. Instead, we largely see the finance industry doing its best to stifle and defeat the threat of change, all the while scratching the state's back and imposing economic blockades against organizations and nations alike without any form of due process. Thus, it is perhaps too optimistic to expect the state, intertwined as it is with the existing system, to punish our financial overlords. Luckily, this is not a requirement. Simply by refusing to artificially stifle innovation, the winds of change will come, they will whisk through the vacuous marble halls of old finance, they will carry fresh ideas, they will underpin great movements toward transparency of governance, they will empower the collective individual, and they will take no hostages. State-sanctioned or not, this change is coming. We as humanity will continue along our historic trajectory: the technologically-backed shift away from nations and nationalism - Einstein's "infantile disease, the measles of mankind" - towards a human society. We will find ways to remove the state/financial overlords of old, and to enable for the whole of humanity - not just multinational businesses and the dynastic capital of old - the capacity to replace oligopolies of usury and fear with cooperation and enterprise, without regard for borders. It is said that one cannot resist an idea whose time has come. Make no mistake: the shackles of old are opening, and only fools will attempt to hold them in place.
- yarou 14y agoIt's odd that there are restrictions on "transmitting" money. Doesn't the USA do this already with hot money? How hypocritical. :)
- 205guy 14y agoI am very happy to see this issue getting exposure. I have long been saying that CC are a big scam and essentially a protection racket taking 3% of every transaction. People get 1% cash back (when they're lucky) and they think that money came out of thin air. The fact that vendors cannot pass that cost on to CC users is part of the racket--and is finally being recognized as illegal. But the OP gets at the heart of the matter: "Retail transactions conducted with credit cards cost 2-3%, which is a ridiculously high cost given today's technology. Retail transactions (actually, any money transfer transaction) could be profitably brokered at 0.1% or less." Given the high fees on CC's I always wondered why there was no alternative card with lower fees, or why ATM cards still had 1% fees. Now I know it's because of legislation like this. I bet the CC companies paid lots of campaign donations to the legislators who passed this thing. If I was still in CA, I'd send the email he suggested.
- dangrossman 14y ago> If I was still in CA, I'd send the email he suggested. Are you still in the US? Money transmitters need to be licensed in 48 of the 50 states.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- codex 14y ago"The financial system in the U.S. is horribly inefficient. Retail transactions conducted with credit cards cost 2-3%, which is a ridiculously high cost given today's technology." No. The reason banks charge high transaction fees on credit cards has to do with how credit cards are billed. The billing cycle for a card is 30 days, after which you have 30 days to pay. This is effectively a loan for which you are paying zero interest. Somebody must pay, though, because you are risky, unsecured debt and your interest rate is maybe 12 percent. Up to two months of free credit therefore costs the bank two percent, which they charge the merchant. Credit card companies could shorten this billing cycle once the delays of snail mail are no longer commonplace, but that doesn't reduce the transaction cost--it only moves it from the merchant to the consumer, who now begins to accrue interest charges earlier. Consumers could theoretically pay off their debts faster and thus pay less interest, but only to a point, because most consumers live paycheck to paycheck and will carry a balance until their biweekly paycheck isn't eaten up by rent and auto payments--roughly a month. And I would argue that most consumers and banks prefer the grace period and simple interest calculations; it makes the whole billing process easy to understand.
- graeme 14y agoWhat are the fees charged for a purchase made with a bank card instead of a credit card. (debit cards in Canada, not sure what you call them in the states)
- dangrossman 14y agoThe interchange fees for debit transactions start around 0.8% for Visa. The exact fee varies by card type and by merchant category code. That's about half what Visa charges on low-end credit cards.
- lisper 14y agoJust because my interest rate is 12% doesn't mean that this is the cost to the bank. The cost to the bank of floating this loan is the rate the bank pays for its money, which has been about 0.2% for the last four years. But you do raise a valid point: part of the problem is the conflation of payments and credit. I'll be writing about that in a future post.
- smutticus 14y agoThis article is long on opinion and short on actual facts.
- lisper 14y agoIf you want the actual facts, follow the link in the second paragraph. You'll find over 200 pages worth of facts.
- rdl 14y agoRepealing the California MTA still leaves sufficient federal legislation and other state legislation in place to effectively regulate payment systems. The MTA is just a bad law.