5 ms·
It's interesting that the website stresses having a GitHub profile...yet no where is it stated that these tips are only for those looking for developer position
by minimaxir 14y ago
It's interesting that the website stresses having a GitHub profile...yet no where is it stated that these tips are only for those looking for developer positions.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoPerhaps non-developers need github profiles now? That would be scary.
- jacquesm 14y agoEven developers don't need github profiles. It's pretty weird to see this re-iterated so often, 100's of thousands of developers the world over don't have github profiles and they're doing just fine.
- j-kidd 14y agoYea, this madness about github profiles must stop. I cringe every time I see someone here pimping some github "projects" they whip up in minutes which obviously they have no passion in.
- daenz 14y agoWhy do you cringe when someone shares a useful project with the developer community? Are you cringing at submissions on /new?
- daenz 14y agoAlthough it is pretty cool to go into an interview and find out their engineering team actively uses one of your open source projects. You can't really get that any other way.
- nwh 14y agoIf it was a requirement, there'd be a lot of very empty profiles. I've only seen a couple of instances[0] where open source and design have come together to make a product with lasting visual impact. It's certainly uncommon. [0]: http://openemu.org/ http://openemu.org/
- davefp 14y agoYou're right. At the moment the site is very developer-centric. Ultimately I'd love to have multiple options for that section. One for design, support, finance, whatever. Time constraints mean that developers are the center of attention for now.
- doomlaser 14y agoIs having a public GitHub presence really necessary? I've been a GitHub user for years, but I haven't made contributions to any public repositories...
- pnathan 14y agoWhen I review candidates, a github[1] profile boosts them to the top of the stack. I'll usually go look at it, too. It shows 3 things: - Knowledge of version control. Which is good to demonstrate. - Knowledge of the de facto standard SCM hosts. - Knowledge of current trends in tech; i.e., social awareness. So tie those 3 things together and that presents a better candidate than someone who only has a resume. To be precise, it would vault you over the bog-standard candidates without a doubt. This is even more true for new graduates. [1] Any sort of profile/portfolio site is a bonus for me. It doesn't have to be github. But I give bonuses for github or other SCM hosting sites. Note that I can go look at your interactions with other people there, which is a big deal.
- krapp 14y agoHow much do you evaluate the code itself? In other words, if I were to interview and my Github profile was mostly personal projects of various levels of quality, would that necessarily work against me?
- pnathan 14y agoSpeaking for myself - and only myself - I would judge the code based on the project's apparent maturity. If it's something that's been obviously just stuffed up there because, hey, version control- yeah, I am not going to fine-tooth it. I've got stuff like that out there, so I can't bash others. :) But if its something that's been going for a while and seems to have some set of users, sure, I'm going to expect a certain level of professional attention to be given to the codebase. As a professional, I understand that lots of code is written to get the job done, and shouldn't be polished until it gleams, the ROI on that isn't really there. As much as I like seeing code that's been turned almost into a piece of engineering art, I don't think its worth it for most professional work and even for personal projects... those lovingly crafted comments go out of date, that tight & elegant functionality has to get chopped up for the new feature's logic flow. But I guarantee you that everyone is idiosyncratic about what they do for hiring. I think between the 3 guys who do most of the hiring on my team, we have between 3 and 6 opinions. :)
- richardlblair 14y agoGithub is a transparent and familiar way to show off your talents. Facilitating the need for people to know what you can do via github is a smart decision. Github can be used for more than just developers. I worked with a sales guy who made great github issues. I'm talking the type of "issues" that make reproducing the bug, and understanding context very easy. If he showed that to someone who understands the value in that, than he has demonstrated a great communication skill without every writing code.
- traeblain 14y agoAgreed, and this bugs me about many of these things. The site should be developers-throw-out-your-resume.com I'm a mechanical engineer, I know all my possible employers would love to see what I have on Github... yes that's absurd. Sometimes I fear these people live in a bubble all their own and have idea there are other professions our there that people might want to work in.