2 ms·
> Yes, that's definitely a big part of it - the fact that the same company can both provide a loan and then insure that same loan creates an ethical conflict of
by anamax 18y ago
> Yes, that's definitely a big part of it - the fact that the same company can both provide a loan and then insure that same loan creates an ethical conflict of interest that calls into question their ability to objectively quantify risk
> So what did the less ethical banks do with these troubled assets, since I'm sure somebody in the top ranks had to know what they were getting into? Bundle them up with a bunch of their other more reputable financial products and resell them to others.
The combination of those two sentences doesn't make any sense.
The inability of an insitution to objectively quantify risk wrt a given entity doesn't matter if said institution doesn't own or insure said entity.
In other words, it doesn't matter how bad Citigroup is at estimating the risk of assets that it sells.
- Retric 18y agoThe problem is they sold the "good slices of the pie" and nobody would buy the bad slices. So they had a lot high risk assets on the books. Which was fine until the market decline wiped their value out.
- anamax 18y agoThe claim was that Citi can't distinguish good from bad. If that's true, they can't have preferentially sold either group. Note that we now have two stories on what they sold. One story is that they "unethically" sold the bad. Now we're told that they sold the good.
- alabut 18y ago"The claim was that Citi can't distinguish good from bad." That's not the claim at all - it's that they had a sliding scale of how bad a loan they were willing to make because of incentive to have lax ethical standards, then they hid the "badness" of those loans by bundling them up with other financial vehicles that they resold to others.
- anamax 18y agoActually that is the claim - "fact that the same company can both provide a loan and then insure that same loan creates an ethical conflict of interest that calls into question their ability to objectively quantify risk" Of course, the insurance that we're talking about wasn't for individual mortgages but for loan portfolios and tranches of loan portfolios. (The "insurance" wrt the effect of individual loans comes from the portfolio - instead of "loan fails or not", you get "fraction of loans that fail".) > it's that they had a sliding scale of how bad a loan they were willing to make because of incentive to have lax ethical standards That's completely incorrect. The "how bad a loan" stuff came from loan orignators as pushed by CRA, govt officials, and fannie and freddie. Ethics had nothing to do with it. Or rather, the "ethic" of "folks should get a loan regardless of whether they can repay" overrode the financial reality of "loans made to people who are unlikely to be able to repay are likely fail". Citigroup wasn't big in loan origination. They did their "magic" on portfolios that they bought from other magicians and from folks who originated loans.