4 ms·
So, I as a mere human can't possibly determine what's public domain and what isn't? I have to put in the effort to track down the original source, and see what
by bediger4000 14y ago
So, I as a mere human can't possibly determine what's public domain and what isn't? I have to put in the effort to track down the original source, and see what notes he/she/it/them put on the original, and if the creator wrote "released into public domain" you can go ahead and use it?
I confess that the very concept of "copyright" becomes more and more slippery the more you look into it. And the slipperiness is all to the benefit of the rich and powerful, and to copyright lawyers, of course.
- StavrosK 14y ago> So, I as a mere human can't possibly determine what's public domain and what isn't? You can, just look at the license. If one is missing, assume it's copyrighted. > I have to put in the effort to track down the original source, and see what notes he/she/it/them put on the original, and if the creator wrote "released into public domain" you can go ahead and use it? Yes? I don't see what's wrong with that, asking the author if you can use his work is just good etiquette, I'm sorry if that's too much work for you.
- hdevalence 14y ago> I don't see what's wrong with that, asking the author if you can use his work is just good etiquette, I'm sorry if that's too much work for you. Yes, it is too much work; it's often not even possible. This is the problem of orphaned works, where the authors are gone or missing and nobody knows who they are, etc, or the work was published anonymously, etc. Tracing down the authors of works produced seventy or eighty years ago is actually really difficult. You should try it sometime before casually dismissing the concern as being born of laziness.
- StavrosK 14y agoI believe that works should enter the public domain after a few years.
- gamblor956 14y agoI confess that the very concept of "copyright" becomes more and more slippery the more you look into it. And the slipperiness is all to the benefit of the rich and powerful, and to copyright lawyers, of course. In the history of mankind, the concept of copyright has never been more coherent than it is now. In the Middle Ages and before, copyright to the extent it existed was by fiat of the crown. Frequently, the crown (especially during the Elizabethan and post-Elizabethan eras) would use copyright and patent rights as political favors, transferring them at the whim of the current monarch. Prior to the 1900s, copyright law differed in every nation. Books copyrighted in Europe, for example, were not copyrighted in the US, and vice versa. The Berne Convention standardized copyright law worldwide. And note, Disney notwithstanding, the current craziness about indefinite copyrights and inalienable copyrights is a result of European artists' efforts to create an eternal copyright (see, e.g., "moral rights"). Corporations have very little to do with that effort and most are opposed to long-term copyrights since most copyrightable IP is generally not worth much and the costs of complying with old copyrights is extremely burdensome. (Corporations much prefer trademark law, which is indefinite but only as long as the trademark remains in active use. Trademarks are far more valuable because they are not limited to a single fixed expression.)