4 ms·
In the USA, and legally speaking (I know, YANAL), can this blogger really, truly give up copyright by just having a link to a notice like that at the bottom of
by bediger4000 14y ago
In the USA, and legally speaking (I know, YANAL), can this blogger really, truly give up copyright by just having a link to a notice like that at the bottom of the page?
I mean, you don't have to mark stuff as "copyright", and you don't have to register it, it's automatically copyrighted as soon as it's fixed in tangible form. At least since 1976 the USA has worked that way. So why should some carefully, but not legally, worded notice allow you to give up those rights? Can anyone point to definitive information about this?
- networked 14y agoIANAL either, but there exist legal tools like CC0 [1] for releasing your work into the public domain or, barring that, waiving as many rights to it as possible. That said, even the FAQ for CC0 [2] carries the following notice: "Please don’t take the 0 (zero) in the name “CC0” literally – no legal instrument can ever eliminate all copyright interests in a work in every jurisdiction. CC0 doesn’t affect two very important categories of copyright and related rights. First, just like our licenses, CC0 does not affect other persons’s rights in the work or in how it is used, such as publicity or privacy rights. Second, the laws of some jurisdictions don’t allow authors and copyright owners to waive all of their own rights, such as moral rights. When the waiver doesn’t work for any reason CC0 acts as a free public license replicating much of intended effect of the waiver, although sometimes even licensing those rights isn’t effective. It varies jurisdiction by jurisdiction. While we can't be certain that all copyright and related rights will indeed be surrendered everywhere, we are confident that CC0 lets you sever the legal ties between you and your work to the greatest extent legally permissible." [1] See https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/ https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/. Incidentally, this license was developed by a US non-profit, so it's reasonable to expect them to have paid special attention to it working with the US copyright law. [2] http://wiki.creativecommons.org/CC0_FAQ/ http://wiki.creativecommons.org/CC0_FAQ/
- StavrosK 14y agoIANAL, but the license to what you create is yours to set, it just defaults to copyright. If you say "I release this into the public domain", lo and behold, it has been done.
- bediger4000 14y agoSo, I as a mere human can't possibly determine what's public domain and what isn't? I have to put in the effort to track down the original source, and see what notes he/she/it/them put on the original, and if the creator wrote "released into public domain" you can go ahead and use it? I confess that the very concept of "copyright" becomes more and more slippery the more you look into it. And the slipperiness is all to the benefit of the rich and powerful, and to copyright lawyers, of course.
- StavrosK 14y ago> So, I as a mere human can't possibly determine what's public domain and what isn't? You can, just look at the license. If one is missing, assume it's copyrighted. > I have to put in the effort to track down the original source, and see what notes he/she/it/them put on the original, and if the creator wrote "released into public domain" you can go ahead and use it? Yes? I don't see what's wrong with that, asking the author if you can use his work is just good etiquette, I'm sorry if that's too much work for you.
- hdevalence 14y ago> I don't see what's wrong with that, asking the author if you can use his work is just good etiquette, I'm sorry if that's too much work for you. Yes, it is too much work; it's often not even possible. This is the problem of orphaned works, where the authors are gone or missing and nobody knows who they are, etc, or the work was published anonymously, etc. Tracing down the authors of works produced seventy or eighty years ago is actually really difficult. You should try it sometime before casually dismissing the concern as being born of laziness.
- StavrosK 14y agoI believe that works should enter the public domain after a few years.
- gamblor956 14y ago
- acabal 14y agoIn a practical sense these concepts only exist to the extent that the "owner" is willing to enforce them. If this guy says he has uncopyrighted everything and doesn't bother chasing after people for copyright violations, then there you go. On the other hand I believe an officially registered copyright is required to merely go to court about a case, so if he says he's uncopyrighted everything, then turns evil, registers a copyright, and starts suing, I imagine that wouldn't really stand up so well to a judge in court. Really though I find the entire concept of copyright and intellectual "property" to be pretty ridiculous and baffling so maybe my interpretation is wrong.
- moron4hire 14y agoYes, he still holds the copyright to the media, he has just declared a free, non-exclusive, unlimited license for the entire world.
- bediger4000 14y agoI believe an officially registered copyright is required to merely go to court about a case No, you can go to court about unregistered copyrights. The distinction is with registration, you can sue for statutory damages, instead of actual damages, and that's where the real money is. But again, I Am Not A Lawyer, and we always let lawyers speak about these things at hundreds of dollars an hour, so you just have mis-information until you pay someone to bring your particular case to trial.
- jxdxbx 14y agoNo, you can't give up your copyright in the US, no matter how hard you try. All works are automatically copyrighted when they are set down so you can't somehow avoid it or opt out. There's just no mechanism. So view a "dedication to the public domain" as what it is, an "irrevocable" license (which means "permission" not "contract") to the entire universe to use the covered works in any way without permission. While this license exists, if the author tries to sue anyone the defendant merely needs to wave around the license. This is as good as the public domain, right? Nope. An author can always revoke a license that purports to be irrevocable after a set time. This is known as copyright "termination" or reversion. The law is very, very clear on this. There is nothing that an author can do, no agreement that he can make, that waives this right. You can pay an author a billion dollars to take ownership of a work and set it all down in an ironclad 50-page contract she can just go ahead and take it back anyway. The purpose of this is to protect authors against signing their lives away when they are young and lack leverage. One effect however is to make all transfers and licenses contingent which in turn makes it impossible to actually dedicate things to the public domain in as real a sense as one would like.
- coldtea 14y ago>* There is nothing that an author can do, no agreement that he can make, that waives this right. You can pay an author a billion dollars to take ownership of a work and set it all down in an ironclad 50-page contract she can just go ahead and take it back anyway. The purpose of this is to protect authors against signing their lives away when they are young and lack leverage* Does that only hold for authors? Because tons of musicians and music bands have "signed their lives away" when they were young and they haven't got anything back. Plus, how would this would work: "You can pay an author a billion dollars to take ownership of a work and set it all down in an ironclad 50-page contract she can just go ahead and take it back anyway." Is the author then supposed to return the money? And what about all the damages to your business by getting the ownership of his work back?
- jxdxbx 14y agoI used "author" in the technical sense, which means all creators of copyrighted works. The termination is far enough in the future that only now are some prominent musicians taking advantage of it, but there have been some stories recently. You have to actively take advantage of the law, also, it's not automatic. And there are often lawsuits. None of this applies to "works made for hire," for which the "author" is for example a company. If I hire you to write a song you never were the copyright owner to begin with. This is a complex area and there's a lot of litigation about the distinction between works for hire and works that are written and then transferred or licensed. I don't know the details of how it works with canceling my hypothetical "no termination only" billion dollar contract. I know copyright law but I haven't studied this area specifically. For the most part contracts pay the author a modest sum that covers a license or a transfer for a modest number of years. In fact a 20 year license should cost about as much as a perpetual license given that most works make all the money they're ever going to make long before that. So a termination under those circumstances doesn't involve any unjust enrichment to the author. And there can be no legally relevant "damages" that result from an author taking advantage of a law that has been in place for decades--it's your responsibility as a media company to know about these things, not the job of an author to decline to take advantage of his legal rights for your sake.