2 ms·
but he went about implementing them in a wildly irresponsible way. It's possible that the value of the release is greater than the harm from irresponsibility.
by rhizome 14y ago
but he went about implementing them in a wildly irresponsible way.
It's possible that the value of the release is greater than the harm from irresponsibility.
- tptacek 14y agoThat appears unlikely based on the contents of the release. For example, consider the most widely publicized story to emerge from the leaks: Collateral Murder. It turns out that Reuters was given access to this video shortly after the incident, and a detailed description of its contents ran in a newspaper (the Washington Post, IIRC), including time-annotated transcriptions of the radio chatter.
- mpyne 14y agoThere are those who ascribe the 'Arab Spring' to the data leaked by Manning... I'm just still not sure whether that's good for Manning or bad for Manning.
- tptacek 14y agoThis devolves rapidly into politics but for my part I'll say that a credible connection between Wikileaks and the Arab Spring would help affirm the value of the document dump --- though obviously this is a thread about Manning's culpability and I'm with you 100% on that.
- mcphilip 14y agoAs a counter point, there are many who ascribe the Arab Spring to a substantial spike in commodity price inflation leading to the self immolation of the peasant in Tunisia which is widely recognized as the key first event leading up to Arab Spring.
- anigbrowl 14y agoOf course, but with a few years' perspective it doesn't seem to have yielded much of value or significance. Mind you, I don't think the harm was so severe either; my hunch is he'll get 10-15 and Obama will commute his sentence or pardon him on leaving office.
- rhizome 14y agoWell, history's written by the victors, right? One thing I realized as this story was percolating today was that since it occurred, the value of the release was attacked based on the legality of doing so.
- anigbrowl 14y agoI'm not looking at it that way at all. Please see my grandparent comment for why I am ascribing a fairly low value to the release.