2 ms·
Yes, I am arguing that it was a good article and did a good job of describing what was going on. ESR certainly has his flaws, but that paper really was a well-
by davidw 18y ago
Yes, I am arguing that it was a good article and did a good job of describing what was going on. ESR certainly has his flaws, but that paper really was a well-done summary of how this stuff works and why, much better than anything else that was out there at the time (I remember reading it in 1998, I think it was).
I don't think he's done much since then that was worth writing home about, but that doesn't take anything away from that particular accomplishment.
- neilk 18y agoOk, I went back and reread some of that essay and I have to withdraw some of my criticisms. You are right and I was wrong. CatB, although anecdotal, is trying to make a coherent case from evidence, and the author's ego is kept relatively in check. His later writings became more like opinion pieces, and are constantly self-referential. My irritation with those must have carried over to the original.