6 ms·
Marissa Mayer had nursery built near office before work-from-home ban
- merinid 14y agoMaternity leave is not remote working. Women should have the right to take lengthy maternity leaves without the fear of corporate ostracizing.
- goodwink 14y agoHaving a nursery built next to your office is not maternity leave, it's a work-life balance perk that she's affording herself which isn't available to other Yahoos.
- cafard 14y agoWell, no, but neither is her compensation. If the board thinks her compensation inappropriate, it can deal with it.
- hvs 14y agoUnlike all those other perks that executives receive that other employees don't?
- dfxm12 14y agoThe context of the situation is important, in the wake of her recent decision about working from home.
- Muzza 14y ago> Women should have the right to take lengthy maternity leaves And the cost should be borne by single men.
- DannoHung 14y agoYeah, dudes who intend to never reproduce should get some sort of tax credit as long as they submit to a sterilization procedure.
- cafard 14y agoAnd promise never to collect Social Security...
- Kototama 14y agoSingle men who never had a mother then.
- calinet6 14y agoSmall price to pay for the continuation of the species. Quit your whining. Maybe they should build a nursery for the single men, too.
- zorpner 14y agoScrew you, seriously. You want to remove childbearers from the workforce? You want to reduce everyone's employment experiences by diminishing the market of employees and ideas? You want your ten bucks a year so that you can say you don't support single mothers (note -- extensive public health research demonstrates that productivity and well-being of women of child-bearing age is the best indicator of the overall health of a society)? Why should society give you anything at all? Why should my tax dollars go towards protecting you from crime, or paying your emergency room bills? And I mean you, specifically, not people in general -- if you don't want to contibute to make everyone's lot better, why should anyone give a crap about you, or for that matter your opinions?
- Muzza 14y agoI see I hit a sore spot. I don't really want to remove childbearers from the workforce, but I do want a frank discussion about who bears the costs. Actually, just an admission of the inherent injustice of the system would be nice. Ten bucks a year? Screw you. I pay roughly 70% of my income in taxes every year. And holy thoughtcrime Batman! Despite paying tens of thousands of dollars every year in taxes, all government services should be denied to me just because of my opinions? http://mises.org/daily/2485 http://mises.org/daily/2485
- jrs235 14y agoThe tax credits and possible cost of guaranteed time off with pay for having children is nothing compared to the immense cost of raising children that will pay future taxes to allow for the continuance of government and government services.
- skore 14y agoComments like this make me think that the cost should indeed be borne by single men, exclusively.
- jerf 14y ago"Women should have the right to take lengthy maternity leaves without the fear of corporate ostracizing." They do in the US: http://fmlaonline.com/fmla-pregnancy/ http://fmlaonline.com/fmla-pregnancy/ Before you reply with potential handwaving theoretical issues with it, bear in mind I am answering your point as written: They do indeed have the right to take leave without fear. It may be infringed, but it does exist and redress is available if infringement can be proved to a judge's satisfaction.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- bitcartel 14y agoThe ban on remote working will hurt the moms and dads of Yahoo the most. - The US is the only industrialized nation not to mandate paid leave for mothers of newborns - The US is one of only three nations — the other two being Papua New Guinea and Swaziland - that doesn't guarantee job-protected time off with some amount of income after the birth of a child - New parents in the U.S. are guaranteed their jobs for 12 weeks after the arrival of a new baby, thanks to the Family Medical Leave Act of 1993, but they do not have to be paid during that time and exemptions apply for small companies. - Only two states in the country, California and New Jersey, offer six weeks of paid family leave to men and women who are caregivers. Unfortunately, the state leaves are not job-guaranteed - Afghanistan provide new mothers with 12 weeks off with pay. The Democratic Republic of Congo, one of the poorest nations in the world, offers mothers 15 weeks off with full pay. - UK provides 90% pay for 280 days, Russia 100% pay for 140 days, Spain & France & Netherlands 100% pay for 112 days, Germany 100% pay for 98 days, China 100% pay for 90 days [1] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/02/04/maternity-leave-paid-parental-leave-_n_2617284.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/02/04/maternity-leave-pai... [2] http://www.theatlantic.com/sexes/archive/2012/12/why-paid-leave-could-pass-in-obamas-second-term-americans-want-it/265831/ http://www.theatlantic.com/sexes/archive/2012/12/why-paid-le... [3] http://www.forbes.com/sites/work-in-progress/2012/05/23/3-reasons-why-card-carrying-capitalists-should-support-paid-family-leave/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/work-in-progress/2012/05/23/3-re...
- gte910h 14y agoI am not unconvinced the turning off the WFH was not a stealth layoff.
- vbl 14y agoIt's partially a stealth layoff.
- 46Bit 14y agoNice triple negative. I think there's an element of layoff about it, but comments from ex-Yahoos about lax work culture in remote employees might well mean it's the best thing to do. Especially when your management clearly can't work well with remoters and no longer has a clear direction. Remote work is great if there's good communication both ways. If not, it's throwing money into a bottomless pit.
- emperorcezar 14y agoSounds like they should have laid off management then. :)
- gte910h 14y agoIf they just need to decrease headcount, they can completely move the conversation to WFH vs NOWFH instead of "why are they laying off people" by canceling it. I'm going to bet MM doesn't necessarily think WFH is bad at all, it was just an easy layoff.
- shin_lao 14y agoIt might look like a stupid decision, but I think the true reason isn't as obvious as "people working at home don't work".
- huhtenberg 14y agoWhy do these angered employees think it's reasonable to compare themselves to the CEO of the company, who is trying to pull said company from a deep shit that it is in.
- corresation 14y agoYou make that sound remarkably selfless of her, as she heroically arrives and tries to save the day, the ungrateful slobs unwilling to see what is good for them.
- analyst74 14y agoA more accurate description is probably: Why do these angered plebs think it's reasonable to compare themselves to the CEO of the company, who paid with her own money to have privileges they can't afford anyways.
- chollida1 14y agoI looked at his comment multiple times and it looks like you're trying your very hardest to put words in his mouth. All he said was that it's odd that rank and file employees expect the same perks as the CEO. I think that's a very reasonable statement. if the CEO get's a personal assistant would every other employee expect one?
- corresation 14y agoAccepting the real differences in benefits for a CEO versus everyone else, or the options available to someone with a lot of money, is completely rational and hard to dispute. It was specifically the "who is trying to pull said company from a deep shit that it is in" bit that turned it from reality to emotional. Meyer is at Yahoo because she saw that as being in her own personal best interests. She isn't there out of altruism.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoConsidering that she just took away a big perk from everyone (and one that is very common in the industry), it's not crazy to wonder whether she'll try to make it up in some other way.
- cpeterso 14y agoIs this article trying to make Mayer look like a hypocrite? She had a nursery built near her office because she planned to work at the office, not from home.
- peterevans 14y agoWould Yahoo be willing to give other employees the opportunity to build a nursery inside their office space? Likely not. The article is contrasting the resources that Mayer has and that her employees do not in light of their ban on telecommuting.
- smacktoward 14y agoUnlike Ms. Mayer, the average Yahoo! line employee cannot afford to have a nursery built near the office so they can come into the office while still having their baby right at hand. So the "everyone comes into the office" edict falls on them a little harder than it does on her. It doesn't make her look like a hypocrite, in other words, as much as it makes her look like an out-of-touch, clueless plutocrat.
- jrockway 14y agoWe're calling people nasty names for making their employees come to work now? Wow.
- smacktoward 14y agoNo, we're calling them nasty names for setting up "coming in to work" to mean one thing for them and another thing for their employees, and then saying "Why is everyone complaining? I have to come in to work too!"
- res0nat0r 14y agoNote: This isn't a personal-gold-plated-one-baby-only daycare. There is nowhere in the article stating this daycare can't be used by all employees.
- Jabbles 14y agoWell where are the details about the nursery? Is it just for her? If it's available for all employees you could rewrite the headline: Mayer builds Nursery for employees' children to compensate (in advance!) for loss of remote working.
- smacktoward 14y agoSince the nursery is literally "next to her office" (see http://allthingsd.com/20130225/survey-says-despite-yahoo-ban-most-tech-companies-support-work-from-home-for-employees/ http://allthingsd.com/20130225/survey-says-despite-yahoo-ban...), and she paid for it out of her own pocket, it seems highly unlikely that it's intended for community use.
- Jabbles 14y agoOh. That does seem likely to cause resentment.
- schoper 14y agoMayer is not there to clock hours or save Yahoo with her brilliant ideas. You don't hire a pregnant CEO to get things done. Yahoo has to take a number of unpopular actions in order to get back into the game. Remote workers tend to be mediocre workers and they need to go. So do others. Mayer is there to absorb and deflect criticism during Yahoo's readjustment period. For various reasons, people don't like to criticize her, and when they do, they aren't criticizing Yahoo. She'll continue to slash and burn for a couple of years, and then she'll be gone, leaving Yahoo with a sort-of-clean reputation.
- xentronium 14y agoThis is some extraordinary claim. Do you have any extraordinary evidence besides her pregnancy?
- wutbrodo 14y agoNot to mention the fact that she _IS_ getting a lot of criticism (and she's not even pregnant anymore...)
- schoper 14y agoShe was sidelined at Google for years and basically forced out. Despite that, and despite her pregnancy, Yahoo still hired her. Every indication is that she is at Yahoo as an Image CEO. Further, the only thing that makes my claim "extraordinary" is that Mayer is someone who garnered elect status on HN shortly after her tenure at Yahoo began. A similar (though opposite) phenomena was the story yesterday about Mark Pincus, which generated a lot of heat for saying something positive about one of HN's "damned" personalities.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y agoI'm not sure about your "Remote workers tend to be mediocre workers" bit. I think that mediocre workers tend to be mediocre workers, whether working from home or office. If a person has a good work-ethic, they will choose the correct environment for themselves. But the rest of it sounds at least plausible, if not likely.
- donohoe 14y agoI wish people would give this a rest already. This is getting old fast.
- nthnb 14y agoWhy is the disgusting media leaking into HackerNews?
- tutuca 14y agoThe same reason we have comments like this : http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5299756 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5299756
- qeorge 14y agoIs it a foregone conclusion that others can't bring a baby to work? My biz partner brought his newborn in for about 10 months - it was awesome. Given, we are a tiny company and they are Yahoo, but its not obvious to me that its impossible to work it out. So I'm glad M. Meyer is doing so, I think that's kind of awesome. The kid will probably have a great time. Maybe there's a way to let others do it too.
- jlarocco 14y agoI can see that working at a very small company where all of the employees are good friends and spend a lot of time together. But I'm hard pressed to think of anything that would make me leave a company faster than having all of my coworkers brats running around all day. A lot of people feel uncomfortable having stranger's children around them.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoA baby less than 10 months old does not "run around". Unless they're colicky or sick, very young babies are not hard to keep quiet: if they're crying they're either hungry, tired, under-stimulated, over-stimulated, hot or cold or otherwise uncomfortable. You identify the problem, fix it, and they stop crying. It may prevent you from working, but it shouldn't bother your coworkers. They should certainly be a lot less annoying than the guy next to you chatting on the telephone. Between 10-18 months they start walking, start getting "opinionated", get a lot louder, stop napping continuously, and so on and would totally disrupt an office.
- dromidas 14y agoIf people started bringing babies to work I wouldn't care too much about them making the worst sound known to man constantly when they are upset because I have spent hundreds of dollars on noise isolating earbuds to block out my already-annoying environment. However if there were babies here I would kind of hate it. A lot. I would probably complain daily until either I get fired or they quit or they are forced to put their baby in a dumpster or wherever they put babies they dont' want to have around these days.
- aviswanathan 14y agoTo her credit, she probably has the toughest and most scrutinized job in the technology industry right now. Every action she takes will have hoards of supporters and nay-sayers. Kudos to her for actually being bold and ignoring the noise.
- jff 14y agoThe big stacks of money she's being paid, and the enormous golden handshake she'll receive even if she runs Yahoo! into the ground, probably help with that.
- codex_irl 14y agofact is people have kids & that's just life. If M wants to make Yahoo a more attractive place to work & get the most from her employees then build a dam child-care facility on site / at the office so that every employee can use it - take care of your employees common life requirements so that they are free to focus on building the best products & not about what time they need to leave to beat the traffic & pick up the kids.
- dreamdu5t 14y agoWhy do I feel like I've never read about Yahoo's CEO before it was Marissa Mayer? Is it because she's a woman?
- wutbrodo 14y agoWay to jump to conclusions of sexism against all evidence... Carol Bartz (former CEO of Yahoo) was also a woman. The reason you hear about Marissa Mayer a lot is because she had a sudden, high-profile transfer from Google to Yahoo, and had high expectations by some of making big changes at Yahoo in an attempt to turn them around (as well as expressing the intent to do so).
- calinet6 14y agoThis is a horrible criticism: Marissa Mayer is the CEO of Yahoo. She can do whatever the hell she wants.
- endianswap 14y agoShe paid for it right out of her own pocket... would there have been equal outrage if she had instead hired a nanny? What about if she had just put her kid in a regular daycare?
- dfxm12 14y agoNo, she can't. Yahoo is a publicly traded company. If her policies lead to excellent talent leaving to work at a place with better perks, either giving Y!'s competitors an advantage, or leaving Y! themselves at a disadvantage, it is the board's and stockholders' duty to show her the door.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y agoWhat is your argument? That those who are adversely affected should go and get CEO jobs themselves? Yeah! Let's all be CEO. In this country we have a long established right established in the principle that everyone can speak their mind. If Marissa Mayer's feelings are hurt, she can wipe away her tears with freshly printed one-hundred Dollar bills. But, one thing she absolutely does not have is the right to live a life free of criticism.
- geebee 14y agoI've read a lot of outrage about this, particularly around the hypocrisy of having a nursery while forcing others to come into the office with no comparable perk. Problem for me is, I actually don't think there's any moral imperative for Yahoo to make life easier for working parents or people who have some need to telecommute. It may make good business sense - Richard Branson certainly seems to think it does, but that's not a moral issue, it's a strategic one. If good employees who have options no longer wish to work for yahoo, they will leave. I do think Yahoo managed this poorly from a PR perspective. I think it would have been wiser to announce Yahoo's plans to make the campus a perfect place to be, with everything a working parent could want. Play up the daycare, gym, dry cleaning. If they're not doing this, start a plan or two and make a big deal about it. I'm speaking cynically here, this is about managing the press. I'd rather it were sincere, of course, but this is PR we're talking about.
- rayiner 14y ago> Problem for me is, I actually don't think there's any moral imperative for Yahoo to make life easier for working parents or people who have some need to telecommute. It's not any more or less of a moral imperative than having bathrooms. It's a concession to the structure of human society, and is arguably moral in that sense.
- geebee 14y agoI'd like to start by saying that I do agree with you that some basic rules about the relationship between employer and employee reach the level of "moral imperative" and should be codified in law. "At will" employment is a big part of this (if you don't like it, you leave), but I certainly do agree that there should be some legally enforced rules around this. So the only real disagreement we have is where to draw the line. Do you really put the right to telecommute on the same moral level as having a place to pee or time off to go to the bathroom?
- rayiner 14y agoI don't disagree with anything you've said, just pointing out that it's an arguable point. I think child care is more important than corporate America perceives it to be. It is the thing perpetuating the pay disparity between men and women in white collar jobs.
- jroseattle 14y agoI look at this latest story and think about it in context when Yahoo switched their employees to iPhones and Androids, which was well received as I understand it. Other perks put in place also helped boost the morale of the rank-and-file a little bit. But it appears she thinks about morale and vibe as quantifiable, something that can be managed relative to the available morale quotient that she can tap. If this is part of an overall strategy, Mayer looks like someone who only knows how to manage things on paper using spreadsheets. I'm sure she's trying to replicate many of the successful approaches she took at Google, but Google and Yahoo are not the same. This nursery story just adds to my impression of her that she's tone-deaf to how her actions affect the organization.
- enraged_camel 14y agoOn the one hand, what Mayer does with her money is her business. It is actually kind of nice that she built a nursery for her kid - it shows that she is taking her parental duties seriously (unlike most CEOs who get tunnel-visioned into their work and ignore their families). On the other hand, it would have been nice if she petitioned the Yahoo! board to spend company resources to build a larger nursery, one that can be used by regular employees. That way, it would have come across as, "we are eliminating the work-from-home perk for everyone, but we understand that this is tough for employees with young children, so we built this nursery they can use free of charge." That would paint her as a no-bullshit CEO who is also attuned to the family-related needs of her employees.
- rayiner 14y agoMy wife's reaction: "it's great, but [she] should have built on-site daycare for everyone to use." (Profanity edited).
- bbvup 14y agoSome people are more equals than others.
- quux 14y agoI'm CEO bitch.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y agoThat's excellent, so Yahoo! employees have access to a nursery at the work-site? That sounds like a reasonable thing to do after revoking the work-from-home policy on short notice.