3 ms·
I only finally purchased a house in an attempt to get away from a series of noisy apartment neighbors. I'd had enough trouble with noise in apartments that I w
by pasbesoin 18y ago
I only finally purchased a house in an attempt to get away from a series of noisy apartment neighbors. I'd had enough trouble with noise in apartments that I was unwilling to make a purchase commitment in a similar environment (shared building).
If apartments and condos were quieter, I would probably have continued to rent. Being not "settled down" at this point in time, the flexibility and lack of hassle dealing with ownership issues (especially maintenance) are definite pluses. Or I might have purchased a condo or coop unit.
As people natter on about more efficient living, I continue to wonder whether there is a model that could incentivise the construction of apartment units that make a serious attempt at soundproofing. I guestimate 10% - 25% additional construction cost, depending on degree of soundproofing and on economies of scale. Hopefully toward the lower end, even with good soundproofing, particularly if there were a significant amount of such construction occurring.
(I don't know about retrofitting, although I am skeptical as to its being effective in many situations.)
- thorax 18y ago> I only finally purchased a house in an attempt to get away from a series of noisy apartment neighbors. Why not rent a house actually?
- 3pt14159 18y agoDude. Sound proofing is exceedingly cheap. I was trained as a structural engineer and met many building engineers and architects throughout my time. There are materials that cost less than a dollar per square foot that can reduce sound to nearly zero. Think 1% not %10 to %25. Thing is, sound proofing isn't even on the constructors radar half the time because it doesn't sell units. That is the problem.
- jraines 18y agoI would probably buy the How to Soundproof Your Apartment or House for Cheap, Guaranteed ebook. You could probably find some not too competitive keywords for this, or find people bitching about noisy neighbors on Twitter. How hard/expensive would it be to do as a retrofit?
- 3pt14159 18y agoRetrofit would be more pricey, but not because of the materials, mostly because of the electrical appliances you have to move. There is an online magazine called "Design Build Magazine" that had an article on soundproofing/fireproofing. You are right though. Maybe I should do some research into soundproofing and write a "How to Soundproof Your Apartment or House for Cheap, Guaranteed ebook" I'll even give you a free copy as your cut.
- throw_away 18y agoyou don't have to get it down to perfect. any noise reduction technique that doesn't look completely goofy would have me as a buyer. for example, the only noise that really gets me is low-frequency foot-sounds from people walking around in the unit above me, and even then, only in my bedroom. I never hear my adjacent neighbors. I imagine each renter's situation would be different. also, it seems that most documentation on sound-proofing is written by the same audiophiles that can tell if you're using gold or copper connectors. I'm not that picky, I just want to sleep a little better.
- neilk 18y agoThat's crazy. That has to be the number one complaint that neighbors in an apartment building are likely to have. I'd pay a premium on rent for soundproofing.
- jerf 18y agoI have seen apartments that advertised soundproofing, but we ended up renting a house instead. Question about this soundproofing: How is it with 20-40Hz sounds? Out of curiousity.
- 3pt14159 18y agoNot too good. In the 20 to 40 Hz range you are looking at a 15% reduction in sound intensity (NOT in decibels, a 10x logarithmic measurement of sound) per 1/4 inch piece. Say you have 100 dB of sound coming in at 30 hz the math works like this: log(10E6) = 10 or 100 in dB (because of the 10x) 10 000 000 * 0.85 => 8 500 000 log(8.5E6) => 9.929 or 99.29 in dB (no perceptive change) At the higher freq (4000+ Hz) you should see drops of 50 to 70% for a 1/4 inch piece. Using 100 dB again we have: 10 000 000 * 0.40 => 4 000 000 log(4.0E6) => 9.602 or 96.02 in dB for a 1/4 inch piece (much better! A clearly obvious change) Another thing to remember is that 1/4 + 1/4 != 1/2 Say we use the 30 Hz example it would be: 0.85 * 0.85 => 0.7225 or a 27.75% reduction, NOT an additive reduction of 15% For reference of how loud things are: Motorcycle right beside you: 100 dB Subway train about 200' away: 95 dB See: http://www.gcaudio.com/resources/howtos/loudness.html http://www.gcaudio.com/resources/howtos/loudness.html For a full chart. Hope this clears up some things :)
- jerf 18y agoThank you. I've lived in apartments, but it's never been the treble that bothered me, and I never figured that we'd ever see a bass-proofing that would meet my needs. So... I switched to renting houses. (And eventually buying one.)
- sofal 18y agoThe main reason why I eventually need to end up in an actual house is because when I'm finally able to afford my dream drum set, nothing is going to keep me away from it. The amount of soundproofing I would need otherwise is probably excessive.
- Tichy 18y agoSo you could afford to buy a house, but not to buy a drum set? Maybe I should reevaluate house ownership.
- randallsquared 18y agoHe lives in Detroit? (I know this has been here recently: http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/chi-detroit-housingjan29,0,5435392.story http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/chi-detroit-h... )