4 ms·
All the problems are the integration with "real money", i.e., the account where you get your salary, the accont where your company pays salaries from, the card/
by PeterisP 14y ago
All the problems are the integration with "real money", i.e., the account where you get your salary, the accont where your company pays salaries from, the card/whatever that you buy stuff with, and the card/whatever that you get cash from.
For that, you'd need to interchange payments with your system and bank accounts.
1) Gov't regulates financial institutions, and there are good reasons for it - otherwise Ponzi schemes and 'bankers' stealing deposits are a real pain and causes the public to ask for regulation. So they will want (force) you to submit to regulation if you want to do anything serious; or you may try to do "only information" and have another, licenced institution (a large bank) hold the actual money - this is what many finance startups do, but then they depend fully on the bank(s).
2) Gov't and banks don't like anonymous transactions, and there are good reasons for it - money laundering, tax evasion, organized crime and stolen money are very real issues. A basic principle is 'know your customer', i.e., don't do any [above $X] business with anyone you can't identify; and don't allow your customers to front payments on behalf of others, unless they identify all those others to you in each transaction. And it's often simpler/cheaper to disallow 'on behalf' deals at all than to integrate your customer/transaction data with the bank's systems. For example, see MtGox AML limits for money withdrawal - if you want to handle "real money", then that would apply for all transactions, not just withdrawals.
3) There are a bunch of consumer protection laws that may hurt you. For example, if a customer's account is hacked and money transferred, above a certain limit you (not the customer) will be liable for the loss. And there are other cases as well. So you (as the organizer) really, really want a money system where payments are (a) traceable, (b) revocable if legally required and (c) can't easily go to any other untraceable, irrevocable systems. Banks do so. The alternative is to charge huge fees to cover the risks to you.
4) Payment systems (ACH/etc) require huge collaterals or guarantees from participants - and there are good reasons for it, as you don't want to receive a gazillion payments, give the money to your customers, and then have the payer institution say that they're insolvent and won't cover the bill for the payment-messages that they sent. Technical and legal barriers to joining are also quite high.
- foxylad 14y agoGood summary. 1, 2 and 4 are really about trust - if we trusted some institution implicitly, they could run the perfect online bank for the world. The first real banks got started in the 19th century when Quakers started them, because people (even from other denominations) trusted Quakers not to rip them off. Maybe the Dali Lama needs to start an internet bank for the world. And point 2... as a society, we have a very important decision to make. Do we trust our governments to control our money - and that of the terrorists, child pornographers and media prirates? The right to control our own money is disappearing as cash is slowly supplanted by cards, and I expect swift action against bitcoin if it gains traction.