4 ms·
It's relatively straightforward to implement a strong cryptographic system (relative to the general complexity of dealing with crypto in general). The hard par
by lisper 14y ago
It's relatively straightforward to implement a strong cryptographic system (relative to the general complexity of dealing with crypto in general). The hard part is getting it deployed. And the reason I can't just get to the point and tell you why it's not being deployed is that I don't know. It's a mystery to me. Part of the reason for telling my story and casting a wide net is the hope that someone who knows will see it and clue me in.
I'm sorry you don't like my narrative style. I'm trying very hard to stick to the facts and not over-dramatize. There's a reason I'm an engineer by trade and not a journalist.
- rthomas6 14y agoOh, I didn't realize that you didn't know the reason. I misunderstood your topic. My complaint was assuming you knew, and were just stringing the reader along installment after installment while diving into details before getting to the meat of the story. Now, knowing that you don't know why all your meetings with banks were cancelled, and knowing that you ultimately don't know why banks don't want to play ball, it makes a lot more sense the way you're telling the story. And I'm sure your narrative style is much better than if I tried to tell it.
- lisper 14y agoNope, I'm not trying to be cagey, I'm trying to find a way not to don the tinfoil hat. But thanks for pointing that out, I guess I should be more explicit about that.
- pbreit 14y agoYou are very much over-dramatizing. Just describe the user experience. There are plenty of people here who know plenty about cryptography, payments and getting service usage. Note: here's all you have to tell us related to cryptography: the service is as secure as a mag-stripe.
- lisper 14y ago> Just describe the user experience http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chip_and_PIN http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chip_and_PIN > There are plenty of people here who know plenty about cryptography, payments and getting service usage I've explained this to you before: not all of the people who read my blog are engineers. > Note: here's all you have to tell us related to cryptography: the service is as secure as a mag-stripe. Apparently I have to explain more than that because that makes no sense whatsoever. Hm, if it quacks like a troll...
- pbreit 14y agoChip and pin is extremely difficult and expensive to roll out. And doesn't really address any of the shortcomings of the US credit card market. Fraud is essentially a non-issue in card-present situations. Hardly a troll.
- lisper 14y ago> Chip and pin is extremely difficult and expensive to roll out You're moving the goal posts. You asked me to describe the user experience. It would be like chip-and-pin. > Fraud is essentially a non-issue in card-present situations. That is not true. If it were, they would not ask you to enter your billing zip at gas pumps. (Yes, I know they don't do this everywhere, but it is a very common practice precisely because card-present fraud is a significant problem in some areas.) > Hardly a troll. We'll see.
- pbreit 14y agoSo it's like chip and pin but doesn't require new pos hardware? Is your system easier to use than a card swipe + entering 5 digits?
- lisper 14y ago> it's like chip and pin The user experience would be similar, yes. > doesn't require new pos hardware There are lots of ways it could be deployed. Some would require new POS hardware, others don't. But unlike chip-and-pin it wouldn't have to be custom hardware. It could be a smart phone or a tablet.