9 ms·
A simple solution to credit card fraud, part 3: the startup that never was
- wmf 14y agoAfter reading parts 1 and 3, I think posting this in parts is just going to maximize misunderstandings (whether accidental or deliberate). It's just one cliffhanger after another. Maybe you should just wait until the whole thing is written.
- lisper 14y agoI appreciate the constructive suggestion, but it's hard enough to write this in installments because I have a very diverse audience, and I don't really know who is tuning in. So getting feedback and mid-course corrections in the form of comments really helps me figure out what to focus on next. I don't think it would be possible for me to write this all at once.
- rthomas6 14y agoI think the author is very intelligent and very bad at compelling narratives. Yeah, the story's complicated, but it's not that complicated. I've seen much more complicated stories written much more clearly. I wish they would stop mentioning all these tangents and asides, and just get to the point of why a strong cryptographic system can't be implemented for money, who is stopping it, and exactly how.
- lisper 14y agoIt's relatively straightforward to implement a strong cryptographic system (relative to the general complexity of dealing with crypto in general). The hard part is getting it deployed. And the reason I can't just get to the point and tell you why it's not being deployed is that I don't know. It's a mystery to me. Part of the reason for telling my story and casting a wide net is the hope that someone who knows will see it and clue me in. I'm sorry you don't like my narrative style. I'm trying very hard to stick to the facts and not over-dramatize. There's a reason I'm an engineer by trade and not a journalist.
- rthomas6 14y agoOh, I didn't realize that you didn't know the reason. I misunderstood your topic. My complaint was assuming you knew, and were just stringing the reader along installment after installment while diving into details before getting to the meat of the story. Now, knowing that you don't know why all your meetings with banks were cancelled, and knowing that you ultimately don't know why banks don't want to play ball, it makes a lot more sense the way you're telling the story. And I'm sure your narrative style is much better than if I tried to tell it.
- lisper 14y agoNope, I'm not trying to be cagey, I'm trying to find a way not to don the tinfoil hat. But thanks for pointing that out, I guess I should be more explicit about that.
- pbreit 14y agoYou are very much over-dramatizing. Just describe the user experience. There are plenty of people here who know plenty about cryptography, payments and getting service usage. Note: here's all you have to tell us related to cryptography: the service is as secure as a mag-stripe.
- lisper 14y ago> Just describe the user experience http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chip_and_PIN http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chip_and_PIN > There are plenty of people here who know plenty about cryptography, payments and getting service usage I've explained this to you before: not all of the people who read my blog are engineers. > Note: here's all you have to tell us related to cryptography: the service is as secure as a mag-stripe. Apparently I have to explain more than that because that makes no sense whatsoever. Hm, if it quacks like a troll...
- pbreit 14y agoChip and pin is extremely difficult and expensive to roll out. And doesn't really address any of the shortcomings of the US credit card market. Fraud is essentially a non-issue in card-present situations. Hardly a troll.
- PeterisP 14y agoAll the problems are the integration with "real money", i.e., the account where you get your salary, the accont where your company pays salaries from, the card/whatever that you buy stuff with, and the card/whatever that you get cash from. For that, you'd need to interchange payments with your system and bank accounts. 1) Gov't regulates financial institutions, and there are good reasons for it - otherwise Ponzi schemes and 'bankers' stealing deposits are a real pain and causes the public to ask for regulation. So they will want (force) you to submit to regulation if you want to do anything serious; or you may try to do "only information" and have another, licenced institution (a large bank) hold the actual money - this is what many finance startups do, but then they depend fully on the bank(s). 2) Gov't and banks don't like anonymous transactions, and there are good reasons for it - money laundering, tax evasion, organized crime and stolen money are very real issues. A basic principle is 'know your customer', i.e., don't do any [above $X] business with anyone you can't identify; and don't allow your customers to front payments on behalf of others, unless they identify all those others to you in each transaction. And it's often simpler/cheaper to disallow 'on behalf' deals at all than to integrate your customer/transaction data with the bank's systems. For example, see MtGox AML limits for money withdrawal - if you want to handle "real money", then that would apply for all transactions, not just withdrawals. 3) There are a bunch of consumer protection laws that may hurt you. For example, if a customer's account is hacked and money transferred, above a certain limit you (not the customer) will be liable for the loss. And there are other cases as well. So you (as the organizer) really, really want a money system where payments are (a) traceable, (b) revocable if legally required and (c) can't easily go to any other untraceable, irrevocable systems. Banks do so. The alternative is to charge huge fees to cover the risks to you. 4) Payment systems (ACH/etc) require huge collaterals or guarantees from participants - and there are good reasons for it, as you don't want to receive a gazillion payments, give the money to your customers, and then have the payer institution say that they're insolvent and won't cover the bill for the payment-messages that they sent. Technical and legal barriers to joining are also quite high.
- foxylad 14y agoGood summary. 1, 2 and 4 are really about trust - if we trusted some institution implicitly, they could run the perfect online bank for the world. The first real banks got started in the 19th century when Quakers started them, because people (even from other denominations) trusted Quakers not to rip them off. Maybe the Dali Lama needs to start an internet bank for the world. And point 2... as a society, we have a very important decision to make. Do we trust our governments to control our money - and that of the terrorists, child pornographers and media prirates? The right to control our own money is disappearing as cash is slowly supplanted by cards, and I expect swift action against bitcoin if it gains traction.
- wonderyak 14y ago> (Some people think the trouble starts when you consider a piece of paper to be money in the first place instead of, say, gold, but they are wrong. This is another tangent that I may write about some day, but for now suffice it to say that very few people actually seem to understand what money is or how it works, including many people who work in the banking industry. But I'm getting way ahead of myself.) So sad and so true. I wish more people could bear down, learn and realize how the money system works; how the Government controls it and what the banks involvement is. The work that Stephanie Kelton and crew are doing over at http://neweconomicperspectives.org/ http://neweconomicperspectives.org/ is really great if you're interested.
- tantalor 14y agoFWIW Bitcoin solves the problem of moving money around.
- lisper 14y agoMaybe. I think the jury is still out on that. But remember that this effort started in 2008. Bitcoin didn't exist then. Also remember that my target launch audience was U.S. companies and their investors. To serve that market I had to be able to move U.S. dollars around, not just any old currency.
- tantalor 14y agoPart of your point seems to be that this problem won't be solved because the financial institutions don't care. My point is you can solve it right now with Bitcoin. I realize Bitcoin wasn't around, but it is now. FWIW, to move $100,000 USD through Bitcoin right now would cost you about 6%, 100000 USD * (1 BTC / 33.6 USD) = 2976 BTC 2976 BTC * (31.8 USD / 1 BTC) = 94636 USD Or simply, (33.6 - 31.8) / 33.6 = 5.3% But I'm sure you know this already! Those numbers from http://mtgoxlive.com/orders http://mtgoxlive.com/orders
- lisper 14y agoYes, I know this. It makes no financial sense to pay 6% just to move dollars (unless you're a drug dealer, but that was not my target market). That's double what credit cards cost. My target was 0.1%.
- wmf 14y agoAnd replaces it with the problem of converting between real money and Bitcoin.
- driverdan 14y agoI wonder if the author ever tried reconnecting with some of the early banks they talked to. Stripe works with Wells Fargo. When you open an account with Stripe they actually open bank and merchant accounts under your company's name with Wells Fargo. I found this out when WF called me one day about my merchant account and I had no idea what they were talking about. It seems that WF is now open to working with startups and opening accounts in other people's names (without notifying them).
- wmf 14y agoSimple and Dwolla are also backed by banks. But I guess the reason why every bank rejected them is coming in part N.
- lisper 14y agoI never went back, no. It seemed unlikely to be fruitful. But this is good to know. Maybe I was just ahead of my time. If anyone knows who at Wells handles this sort of thing I would really appreciate a pointer.
- felideon 14y agoBut were you using Lisp to build the system?
- lisper 14y agoOf course :-)
- mrjaeger 14y agoIs FundersClub (https://thefundersclub.com/ https://thefundersclub.com/) anything like what you were trying to build with Founders Forge? I'm not sure how they move their money around, but the idea of creating a platform for investors to be able to more easily and intelligently invest in startups seems to be very similar.
- lisper 14y agoYep, looks very similar. Damn, they stole my idea! ;-)
- pbreit 14y agoMoving money is one of the easiest parts. Money movement is not nearly as broken as the OP would have you believe.
- lisper 14y agoPlease enlighten me: what is this easy unbroken way of moving money to which you allude?
- pbreit 14y agoWires, ACH, credit cards, cash, checks, etc. If there are specific situations where you feel the options are poor and are actually holding back the situation, would love to hear them. The only one I can think of that is truly poorly served is micropayments but I'm not really sure that's much of an opportunity anyway.
- lisper 14y agoI'm planning a whole post about the myriad problems with all of these. But in the meantime you can read this: http://blog.rongarret.info/2010/11/personal-banking-nightmare.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2010/11/personal-banking-nightmar...
- pbreit 14y agoThat's really a very rare circumstance, is getting rarer and pretty much always gets resolved. Wires have gotten much easier to perform (which is actually kind of scary).
- pbreit 14y agoThis story is getting even more bizarre. You pitched a start up idea to a Wells Fargo branch manager?? That makes no sense at all. The insinuation that bank higher-ups were actually evaluating your idea and killing it is presumptuous. Unsupported ideas have very short lifespans. Do you realize that Dwolla is trying to do similar things but it takes dozens of employees, millions of dollars and an indirect route to get there (same with PayPal)? I guess I'll keep reading because the inanity of it all has me hooked but pray tell part 4 gives some sort of short description of the user experience for this supposedly simple solution (that sounds anything but simple so far).
- lisper 14y ago> You pitched a start up idea to a Wells Fargo branch manager? Sure, why not? Had to start somewhere. > The insinuation that bank higher-ups were actually evaluating your idea and killing it is presumptuous. I don't know what happened at Wells, but I do know for a fact that senior management (and in two cases the CEO) was not only evaluating the idea, but actually signed off on it later. Just because I started naive doesn't mean I stayed that way. > Do you realize that Dwolla is trying to do similar things Of course. So? Lots of companies are trying to do similar things. None of them (except Paypal) existed when I started. > but it takes dozens of employees, millions of dollars and an indirect route to get there Yes, of course I realize this. And your point would be...?
- foxylad 14y agoI salute you sir. Excellent article, amusingly written - and (pardon the pun) right on the money! Money transfer is essentially subtracting from a number on one bank's hard disk and adding it to another on a second bank's hard disk. OK, it has to be done transactionally, and you need those numbers to be secure, but really... how hard is that? I read today that share traders are excited that they can now do trades between Chicago and NY in 8ms instead of 12ms. So why does it take me days to make a simple payment? And why does it cost more than a few micro-cents to do it? Revolutionising value transfer has the potential to be biggest benefit the internet gives us - but seems destined to be the last one realised. I make six figures providing online services for schools, and spend roughly half of my effort on payments. Partly resolving problems where the payment processor refuses to accept credit cards (from schools - hardly a high fraud demographic, and we've never had a customer charge-back), partly handling paper checks, partly trying to match ACH payments with customers. Bitcoin can't happen soon enough.
- ceejayoz 14y ago> First, what you have just read is a very abbreviated version of the actual plan. In the interests of not turning this story into War And Peace I have left out a lot of detail. You've written five thousand words thus far...