8 ms·
One could argue that ARM's "practice" is producing designs. They are heavily involved in the creation and implementation of their patents, making them differen
by nitrogen 14y ago
One could argue that ARM's "practice" is producing designs. They are heavily involved in the creation and implementation of their patents, making them different from any troll that licenses "patents" they bought rather than "designs" they created.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoSo patents are only valid if held by their originator? That would make the IP non-transferable. In ARM's case, it would mean a takeover would invalidate its value.
- nitrogen 14y agoI didn't say anything about patent validity, only that it's arguable ARM does not meet some possible definitions of NPE. I admit that the reference to trolls buying patents near the end of my second sentence slightly muddies that intended meaning.
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoA patent troll, then, could argue its "practise" is "developing" undervalued patents by buying them off investors, who receive the value up-front, and then licensing them. ARM is, for all intents and purposes, a non-practising entity. It's just not a patent troll. The folly is in assuming all NPEs are patent trolls. Carving the ARMs out of the NPEs will take more thought that lobbing exceptions at a general idea. Minimum viable products don't work in law because switching costs are high.
- scott_s 14y agoIn the end a judge will make a judgement, which means they can take actual intent of the rules of what makes a company a non-practicing entity into account. Your point about high switching-costs is valid, but the law is not a blind rules engine.
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoI really don't get the "ARM is an NOE" thinking. They spend a lot of time and money developing the product they license. If ARM is an NOE then so is every software company.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- cabalamat 14y ago> ARM is, for all intents and purposes, a non-practising entity. I'm fairly certain ARM employs more technologists than lawyers. They also make actual products, and even if the patent system disappeared tomorrow, designing processors would still be a viable business. In this way they differ from trolls, who make nothing of value but are merely parasitic on the productive economy.
- rayiner 14y agoYou're using trolls and NPE's interchangeably. When an NPE buys patents from the inventor, that is a contribution to the productive economy. The possibility of a buy-out drives productive activity (this is the same as startups who hope to get bought out by Google, etc). Also, how would you classify this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mojave_Aerospace_Ventures http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mojave_Aerospace_Ventures
- scott_s 14y agoThe article mentions that one of the conditions that excludes a company from being a non-practicing entity is "the plaintiff is an inventor or original assignee."
- AnthonyMouse 14y ago>So patents are only valid if held by their originator? That would make the IP non-transferable. They could sell to anyone who practices the invention, just not to a patent troll. >In ARM's case, it would mean a takeover would invalidate its value. This is a good point, but it's cleanly solved by exempting mergers. That would allow two ARM-like companies to merge without losing their ability to license original patents, but it still beats back the trolls because a merger only allows you to combine two complete entities, it doesn't allow you to transfer anything less than the entirety of each company's patent holdings to a third party.
- jessriedel 14y ago> cleanly solved by exempting mergers... Your description hardly sounds clean. In fact, given the complexity of business mergers, sales, taxes, etc., it sounds like it would result in an ever expanding nest of exemptions. There's nothing wrong with companies that buy IP and do nothing but licence it; that's how an efficient market in IP is likely to operate. The problem is with the frivolousness/obviousness of the original patents.
- AnthonyMouse 14y ago>Your description hardly sounds clean. In fact, given the complexity of business mergers, sales, taxes, etc., it sounds like it would result in an ever expanding nest of exemptions. What does it have anything to do with taxes or any of that other stuff? If you have two corporate entities that merge, the merged entity can be considered the original assignee of all of the patents that each of the merging entities was. It's not a complicated rule. But it keeps trolls from setting up "mergers" to falsify their status as an "inventor or original assignee," because it's all or nothing. You couldn't transfer any subset of the selling entity's original patents to anyone else and still call them original patents. Here, we can make it even more simple. Forget about mergers. You can transfer a patent for which you are the inventor or original assignee to another party and have that party be considered the original assignee if and only if you transfer every such patent you own to that party. >There's nothing wrong with companies that buy IP and do nothing but licence it; that's how an efficient market in IP is likely to operate. So say the patent trolls. It reminds me of what the high frequency traders say about liquidity: Even if it could theoretically be true under some set of artificial constraints, in practice the cost of allowing it pretty clearly exceeds the supposed efficiency benefits. >The problem is with the frivolousness/obviousness of the original patents. The problem is that software patents anyone is likely to infringe are inherently frivolous/obvious, because the lack of physical constraints causes there to be a million good ways to do any given thing in software, so (putting aside standards-essential patents that constitute their own special brand of unintended consequences), the only way you get a software patent that anyone else will ever infringe is to abstract the so-called invention out so far that it covers all plausible implementations rather than only the specific one that you're supposed to have invented. The patent system wasn't designed for software. They're not compatible with one another. The proper solution is to eliminate software patents. But if we can't do that today then putting as many sensible limits on the amount of economic damage they can cause in the meantime will have to suffice.
- bigiain 14y agoThis is a problem that needs to be addressed carefully in my opinion. Right now, it's a perfectly valid decision for an inventive/creative person(or team or company) to choose to spend their time inventing new things instead of commercialising "finished ideas", since the laws are (and have been for decades) written to allow an inventor to sell their patents. If you're the world's best battery chemist, I'd rather you spent this year looking for an even better battery, rather than needing to be involved in making and selling last years "best battery" to earn any money from it. I don't want the top cancer researchers "wasting time" being personally involved in making drugs at commercial scale and doing deals with Walgreens, I want them doing cancer research - and having a patent/legal system that allows them to earn a living doing so (with the understanding that they've got a choice to license or sell their patents, and whether they get to share in the spectacular riches that some big-pharma company will make if they've just saved millions of lives will depend on how they chose to structure that transaction). Somehow, we need to allow inventors to continue to be "NPEs", while stopping the obvious "patent troll" techniques of buying up uncommercialised patents with the only intent being to use them to litigate. (And note, by "inventors" I'm including "companies set up to do inventing, either as their sole business or perhaps with a few staff or division who 'invent' as part of their regular work". I know of companies like http://www.novogen.com http://www.novogen.com and http://www.mesoblast.com http://www.mesoblast.com who are pretty much teams of biotech researchers intending to work out how to cure cancer, then sell the knowledge to other companies to commercialise it. I also know people at http://www.ecoult.com http://www.ecoult.com who didn't invent the technology they're commercialising, but have licensed the patents from the government research organisation that did invent/patent them.)
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- wmf 14y agoThis isn't much of a problem if the inventor sells the patent outright to the company that is going to use it. Then the new owner is not a troll and could legitimately sue infringers. I agree that it's problematic if the inventor structures the deal as a license.
- lawnchair_larry 14y ago
- mbell 14y agoI'm not sure that is entirely true. I'm no expert in the area but I would guess that the primary thing they are licensing is a particular design or instruction set, legally protected by copyright, not patents. I'm sure some patent licensing has to occur as part of any licensing for the protection of the licensee but I don't think the patents are the primary 'thing' being licensed, its the copyrighted material.
- digikata 14y agoMaybe one could look at how many customers elect to licence the patents vs how many are litigated into being customers. Or look at the availability of the patents for license. If a company holds a lot of patents, has no technical staff to develop products, and doesn't have sales staff to try to license their IP in any markets, we might conclude the company is a non-practicing entity whose only purpose is the litigate their way to customers.