4 ms·
Citizenship in a Republic
- tomrod 14y agoIt appears a lot of people talk about what it takes to make a successful startup and the like. Reading through this today just reminded me of the fight many startup entrepreneurs take every day.
- jkeesh 14y agoThanks for sharing this link. As it related to HN, I think you have to applaud all of the people who go out on a limb and share their work-in-progress side project, new startup, or anything else that they've created---knowing that half of the community will "point out how the strong man stumbles, or where the doer of deeds could have done them better." I still am a relative beginner to the space, and I do find it frustrating when people dismissively point out such "obvious" problems with our project, or things we should be doing, but I think it comes with the territory.
- tomrod 14y agoYeah! He even refers to the "critics" as such, those on the outside of the arena.
- untog 14y agoEDIT: the title of this post has now been changed, to the extent that it loses its entire relevance to HN. It was previously something along the lines of "After a year reading HN, this quote reminds me of the people here" --- I'm deeply skeptical of any attempts to romanticise "doing a startup". "The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood" Running a startup is hard work. No-one disputes that. But if you are in the position to run your own startup you are incredibly lucky. There are a lot of people out there that might be far better entrepreneurs than you, but because they weren't born into a situation that gave them a good education and the ability to take a risk, they never will. Running a startup is stressful, but don't try to pretend that there aren't enormous upsides. You can do whatever you want, you can work with whomever you want. The industry celebrates failure- think about that for a second. You can try your best, fail miserably, and people will still say that you did a good job. How many other people in the world can do that? The guy earning minimum wage in his factory job, spending all his salary just to keep out of poverty- if he fails, he is fired, and he and his family are screwed. He is the person whose face is much more likely to be covered in actual dust and sweat and blood. Being in this industry is a position of extreme privilege. Harping on about it as if it's a heavy burden to bear is utter nonsense and only helps the perception of "startup folk" as deeply out of tune with how the rest of the world works.
- Mz 14y agoI don't see it as romanticizing it. I met an old guy, last remaining (living) founder of a huge company. In our brief exchange, he remarked on how the company had seen "a lot of bad times" or something like that. After all his success, acclaim, money, etc, he still smarted from the challenges. It still hurt. It still weighed on him. I think stuff like this is more like a salve for their wounds. Most folks seem pretty scarred by their experiences. Though that isn't peculiar to startups. Still, I get the impression there is something more raw about the experience than a lot of other things. Just an impression.
- avenger123 14y agoCouldn't agree more with your sentiments. I find it sometimes very frustrating to read about all these people doing start-ups (who I am cheering to succeed - I have nothing against others succeeding, no matter how good their circumstances are) talk about the struggle and the hard work, etc. It's inevitable that either consciously or subconsciously you do a mental comparison between yourself and these people. Sometimes, I tend to have questions such as "ummm... why am I not/did not follow similar path". I don't dwell to much on it as I catch myself and look at their background. For example, I will use the founder of one particular company (which I won't name). Let's see, father is CEO/founder of a medical company (ie. already no risk of any real failure - dad is available for a start-up capital and a job if things don't workout). He is graduating from Stanford (already higher chance of success, considering the reputation and connections that exist). I watch a presentation with the father and son and I just could not understand how this person felt they were taking a huge risk by doing their start-up versus "getting a job". He mentioned the risk and it really emphasized the vacuum some of these founders live in. I will gladly give more respect to people such as Mark Cuban and many others like him who have built their companies from the start with real risk and real failure. I wish the best of success for these people that do have these really good circumstances. Being able to leverage their good fortune to do a start-up is adding value to society but I tend to find it a bit too much sometimes when I read about the struggles of these people that have the good circumstances. I also feel it perhaps leads some people astray who should not do a start-up as the consequences of failure are extremely bad as they don't have the good circumstances to cushion the failures.
- wooster 14y agoOriginal title: "After a year of reading HN, this is how I view the successful entrepreneur" New title: "Citizenship in a Republic"
- tomrod 14y agoHuh. It really makes no sense why I posted this after the title change. What gives?