4 ms·
Everyone involved in this should be ashamed of themselves. The machine pictured is a Stratasys Fortus 900MC, which costs $379,900. An annual lease on a machine
by jdietrich 14y ago
Everyone involved in this should be ashamed of themselves.
The machine pictured is a Stratasys Fortus 900MC, which costs $379,900. An annual lease on a machine of this type is usually about a fifth of its purchase cost, so let's be generous and call it $70,000 per year. Each body therefore costs about $20,000 in machine time alone, before you factor in the cost of materials and the not-inconsiderable amount of finishing that an FDM part requires once it comes off the machine.
There's nothing magical about 3d printing, so we could just as easily injection-mold these parts in exactly the same ABS plastic at a tiny fraction of the cost. There'd be no point, because ABS is a terrible material for car bodies.
Car bodies are largely stiffness-critical structures. In most practical materials, they're much stronger than they need to be once you've made them sufficiently stiff. That's why carbon composite is such an excellent material for performance cars - it's immensely stiff. You don't need to be an engineer to know that ABS plastic isn't very stiff.
The whole thing is hokum, absolute hokum.
- TylerE 14y agoI agree with most of what you said, but 3d printing DOES allow shapes that you couldn't easily injection mold, such as undercuts and ridges, and you also wouldn't have the requirement for some degree of draft angle for mold/part seperation.
- jonhohle 14y agoWith the exception of SLS type machines (lasers which melt powder) or Z-corp machine (powder with applied binder) many under cuts will require additional support structures to help bear the weight of the part during construction which require manual removal after the fact. Cleverly orienting the structure can help in some cases, but not all. For example, you could create a hollow sphere because you always have a counterweight, but an upright arch would require some scaffold. The scaffolds are usually easily removed (made of a different material then the main structure), but still require manual removal.
- erikpukinskis 14y agoI'm not an Engineer, but aren't there limitations on what kinds of shapes you can injection mould? Different limitations than those on 3d printing? For example you could 3d print a closed cell ABS foam-like structure, or honeycomb, which would be lighter than a solid plastic part of equivalent strength.
- sbierwagen 14y agoYou could, and can, but the problem becomes the feedstock. ABS, PLA, PC et al just aren't as strong as any of the FRP composites, and are weakened still further by the (lack of) bond strength between print layers. FDM is great, I love it, but it's not a process for producing structural parts, and won't be for quite a while.
- crististm 14y agoEvery time I see these futuristic cars with continuous forms and seamless integration of body and glass I wonder: how much a collision repair is going to cost? Sometimes, smart shapes are too smart for their own good. They are at the border of bad engineering.
- wmeredith 14y agoWIRED continues to be rubbish. Every time they report on anything I have any domain knowledge about, I've found that it's full of lies, exaggerations and half-truths. It's best just to assume the stuff they publish that I have no domain knowledge about, such as this story, is the same. It's like they're a tech tabloid.
- ars 14y agoYour outrage is misplaced. It's not WIRED, it's ALL journalists. EVERY single time I have personally known information about something reported in the news, the news has been wrong.
- sliverstorm 14y agoThere's nothing magical about 3d printing Thank you. You are like a sweet, sweet breath of fresh air, in this 3d printing hysteria.
- Tarrosion 14y agoI disagree, but not because I think you're wrong about the feasibility. I've no way to judge, but let's assume you're right: this car doesn't make sense either mechanically or economically. And the cost to produce it? A few hundred thousand dollars of printer, a few hundred thousand dollars of designers and engineers, a bit of plastic...call if 5 million to be generous. On the scale of a wealthy nation like the United States, 5M is not much money. But the (perhaps tiny) chance that this project leads to discovery or innovation in manufacturing, fuel efficiency, 3d printing, etc. is worth far more.
- jdietrich 14y agoIn the replies to my comment, there are a few of "what ifs" about the usefulness of 3d printed parts. All such questions can be answered with the following: If 3d printing produced useful parts, it would be absolutely ubiquitous in motorsport. In reality, it's of no real interest. Formula 1 teams add new parts to their car at almost every race, iterating as fast as their wind tunnel and computer models will produce data. It's commonplace for an engineer to arrive at a racetrack hours before a race starts, carrying a brand new part. They almost exactly match the ideal use-case for 3d printing - they produce lots of one-off parts, where speed of iteration is vital and money is no object. In reality, most F1 teams use entirely conventional manufacturing processes, even for non-structural components like wind tunnel models. 3d printing is extremely useful in a small number of applications (mainly mold-making) but it's not new and it's not revolutionary. Most manufacturing processes are dipshit-simple, even if you're producing something very complex. Just as in programming, we combine lots of simple processes into a sophisticated whole.
- Bjartr 14y agoSome teams (Williams F1) are using 3D printing, specifically Selective Laser Sintering of titanium alloys.
- nickpinkston 14y agoThis man knows what he's talking about. This article is BS and so is the car idea. There's sooo much koolaid in 3D printing right now - even though there's a ton of great stuff in manufacturing in general. It's not the panecea the media are reporting. (Source: I used to own a 3D printing company doing every type of 3DP process)