7 ms·
Has the ideas machine broken down?
- spikels 14y agoThis seems to contradict the feeling of great progress in technology over the last few years. Perhaps it is just an illusion that when "software is eating the world" it is actually making the world better. Perhaps it is being negated by lower productivity in the rest of the economy or government. Just seems at odds with my recent experience.
- magicarp 14y agoNo
- redschell 14y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline...
- nazgulnarsil 14y agoWe're just spoiled. We want something as disruptive as the internet every year.
- eksith 14y agoThis. And we want it as an app.
- crgt 14y agoFor free.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoAvailable now.
- ipedrazas 14y agoand that works offline
- dkulchenko 14y agoI assure you, it has not. Sometimes it's hard to look past TechCrunch and the endless SaaS/CRUD apps, but we're in the middle of a technological revolution right now. Platforms like Kickstarter are driving innovation like never before, pushing forward ideas that would have never seen the light of day otherwise. The new tech coming out of the machine is awe-inspiring. Even as a tiny, tiny sample of what's happening out there: Google's making self-driving cars, healthcare is advancing by leaps and bounds, and portable electronics have changed the way we live our lives over the course of but 5 years. Google Glass? Oculus Rift? Leap Motion? MYO? All tech that would simply blow your mind just 10 years ago, but we're practically taking it for granted today. I'm typing this on a thin glass slab, for Christ's sake, this is something out of Star Trek. If you're struggling to see innovation, you aren't looking hard enough.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoNot just innovation, things like kickstarter are a part of a fundamental sea change in our economy. Away from the model of the "worker" manning an assembly line in a factory for life and towards a model of individual artists, craftsmen, makers, developers, etc. working independently as freelancers and in very small "indie" outfits. I think that the model of mega-corporations serving as the backbone of the economy is going to transition increasingly toward smaller, more autonomous organizations and individuals which typically work in a cooperative / collaborative fashion on major projects. We're already seeing that pattern play out in the arts, with more and more musicians, comedians, graphic artists, game makers, etc. working on their own.
- tomjen3 14y agoThere is no inovation in health care. We can't grow organs, we are still dying of hearth diease and diabetes. Doctors know how important exercise is but keep turning out study after study on the subject instead of figuring out how to get the same effects in a pill. They don't even want to cure cancer, prefering ever more expensive treatments. You talk Star Trek, at this point I would be impressed with a goddamm hypospray. Tech companies have made it possible to get live video from the other side of the planet, it is about time the rest of the sectors step up.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThis is actually the reverse effect, I think, disruption blindness. Disruption has become so commonplace that we've started to call it complete even when it's in its early stages (such as the current PC revolution). And we've become used to a rapid pace of massive disruption. So even while we're in the midst of several big transformative changes to the world wrought by technology, we get impatient. Why isn't the entire world being revolutionized EVERY year? Has the pace of development slowed down? Just calm down and readjust your perspective. Consider even just the tablet revolution, which has only just started. The low parts count of tablets makes them ideal low cost computers. The long battery life makes them perfect for use in areas without ubiquitous electrical power. And the intuitive touch based interfaces make them perfect for use even by people who aren't literate. Over the next 20-30 years we're going to see a massive acceleration in the diffusion of computing technology into the developing world. Which will have a huge impact on education, communication, economics, and industry. This will be one of the most profound things to happen in the history of humanity, but nobody's paying enough attention because everyone in tech journalism has the IQ and attention span of a gnat. Meanwhile, over the same time frame increases in computing power are going to be a key element in the rise of fully configurable and fully automated manufacturing, as well as automated long-distance transportation (not just driverless cars), and a strong transition away from mass production as we've known it. All of which will transform the economy and society in ways we can scarcely imagine today. That's not even to mention the rise in space exploration, exploitation, and colonization that is in the midst even as we speak. The world of 2050 will be more futuristic and unfamiliar to the people of 2013 than the fictional futures of Star Trek or Blade Runner.
- graycat 14y ago"everyone in tech journalism has the IQ and attention span of a gnat" I take great offense and strongly object to your unwarranted, unjustified, uninformed, misinformed, just plain wrong insult of good and innocent gnats!!!!
- spiritplumber 14y agoPut the patent trolls to work the fields and the situation will surely improve.
- edderly 14y agoIt's worth being careful with the provocative title. You should consider that innovation can involve in recycling existing businesses, and the point here is whether they are either generating growth or productivity. So what this means is that there can be a whole load of innovation occurring, but when it comes down to it, it may not be generating a lot of new growth.
- graycat 14y agoI read it a little differently: 1920-1940, just 20 years, including 12 years of The Great Depression, saw just explosive growth in telephones, electric power, electric motors, electric lighting, radio, autos, oil, steamships, chemical engineering, and airplanes with continued growth in railroads and, thus, steel, Great Lakes shipping, and more. Then could go to college and study 'industrial arts' with chemistry, strength of materials, metal working, wood working, printing, etc. with excitement much like studying computer science in college today. My explanation: Small gumment, meager regulation, big bucks left over from the Gay 90s available for investment. Then 1940-1970 the US DoD kept giving high technology many really big kicks in the back side to move much faster each year. That's what built Silicon Valley, much of Boston, several labs around the country, and many labs around DC. But, the war in Viet Nam and the subsequent mess of the inflated economy, e.g., the 22% prime rate and the S&L crisis, and the oil shock of 1973-4 slowed things down through at least 1980. But in 1980, IBM retreated from their grand 'future systems' direction and did another turn on the 370 architecture and started selling 370s again. They were shipping from their plant in Kingston, NY. The 18 wheel trucks that came to pick up the boxes got in a queue starting a the plant and continued out of Kingston and onto the NY State Thruway and formed a queue there. There was a blip in the GDP. So, things were starting to grow again. By 1990, IBM was starting to hurt; microprocessors were taking a big toll on IBM's revenue. In three years near 1994, IBM lost $16 billion and went from 407,000 employees down to 209,000 and cleared out rush hour traffic jams in several counties north of NYC. Since then we've had the dot-com bubble, 9/11, two wars of 10 years each, the housing bubble and The Great Recession, the end of the Cold War, the end of much of the Space Race, and, thus, no longer big Federal bucks for 'aerospace'. So, some things slowed down. This should be a time of explosive growth, especially exploiting the price/performance of current computing and optical fiber along with the infrastructure software. To do what? Sure, to automate as much as possible of everything there is to do -- computers managed by computers ... managed by computers several levels deep managed by humans. But there is a big financing problem: The big, old companies don't like to innovate, are not being pushed by DoD and NASA, and don't see the big profits that IBM long did. So, innovation is up to small companies. Alas, the way the financing works, really there is essentially no funding for the research and early development anything like what gave us everything from the electric light bulb through the electric typewriter, the nuclear power reactors, the Xerox machine, System 360, the SR-71, Multics, DEC VAX, AT&T Unix, and more. So, now the IT R&D is from 1-3 guys funded by personal checkbooks. The 'professional' money doesn't want to get involved until all the R&D is done, the product has launched, and there is significant 'traction' growing rapidly. That's a long way from, as I recall, Rockefeller writing checks to get Edison and/or GE going so that we could have electric lighting instead of gas lighting. And if Rockefeller asked Edison how the bulb was going, Edison could only say that he knew 1000 things that wouldn't work. And the ability to raise money on the stock market is much less good: 100 years or so ago, could form a company on Monday, print stock on Tuesday, sell it to the public on Wednesday, and then by Friday be building the new steamship, railroad, hotel, coal mine, or whatever. Currently Apple, Google, Cisco, Microsoft and more are sitting big piles of cash and should be able to fund a next big thing like Rockefeller funded electric lighting.
- influx 14y agoEverything's Amazing and Nobody's Happy: http://vimeo.com/50652818 http://vimeo.com/50652818
- diminish 14y agoThe Economist, is the maintainer of the current world order, reassures us again and again then all is fine, or getting better.
- yesbabyyes 14y agoAs others are saying, there is a lot of innovation going on. However, I propose that the "digital economy" is quite different from anything we are used to. The productivity gains are not necessarily such that they contribute to growth -- at least, not they way we are used to measure it. It seems that two of the big effects of the Internet is removing rentiers and middlemen, and lowering costs across the board, the first because, well, connecting people, the second because of multiplicative efficiency increases. This enables smaller organizations to capture a bigger part of a smaller pie. This is most visible in strictly informational sectors, such as free software, music and publishing, but I don't think it's constrained to that but rather the effect of adding "intelligence". The end game of a company like AirBnB for instance, is to replace (all) hotels, for a fraction of the turnover (but higher profit margin). The same could be true of self driving cars -- we believe it will let us make do with fewer cars, because they are easier to share. Indeed, Google is perhaps the foremost example, incessantly cutting away at the advertising sector (along with related industries), filling the same purpose but better and an order of magnitude cheaper. This is not growth, but degrowth. The thing is, it is still good and valuable -- it's just that it's not reflected in GDP. I would say that this has been going on for a few decades, which is why we've seen the rise of the financial sector, which seems, to me, to be a kind of "manufactured growth" -- all of our politics and policies expect, indeed, demands growth in order to work. So when it slows, or rather changes it's nature if you will, we invent fake growth. In summary, I agree with some of the "pessimists" in the article, but I'm optimistic and hopeful about it. I think we can really live abundant.
- brianchu 14y agoNo, what you have just described is the epitome of increased productivity and therefore increased GDP. In fact, productivity gains are the primary contributor to rising standards of living (higher GDP per capita). Take self-driving cars. Sure, one might fixate on the fact that car manufacturers will lay off workers and that cab/truck drivers will lose their jobs. But that's a very narrow way of viewing things. If self-driving cars save 20 minutes in each American's day (commute, going out, filling up the tank), we're looking at more than 11,900 human years saved each day, just in the US. This figure doesn't even include the fact that when you are in the car you can do work or read while the car is driving itself. And we haven't even looked at: 1) health benefits from lower air pollution, 2) cheaper and more efficient transport of goods everywhere (lower costs for every type of good), 3) more efficient allocation of real-estate (no parking garages in the middle of the city), and 4) numerous other effects I am probably leaving out.
- qxf2 14y agoInnovation is, and rightly should be, followed by a phase of enjoying its benefits. We are enjoying the fruits of the Internet. Its opened up more options and improved quality of life. My own life has changed drastically since I was introduced to computers twelve years ago. Today I work across continents - not a choice I had in the 90s. My mother can video chat with my nephew and niece everyday. My grandmother can see places across the world in vivid detail without leaving her chair. I can get away by being less knowledgeable. The much reviled 140 characters is a symptom of us enjoying the benefits. What's the fascination with flying cars? Why is it a poster child of 'innovation'? Innovation is bursty, uncontrolled and usually cross disciplinary. Innovation just happens. For true innovation, pay attention to the Nobel prizes in science, to cutting edge research in science and not just industry. Its also weird to put up known checkpoints like 'flying-cars' to measure innovation. Does anyone else find it strange that the title is 'idea machine' but content is tangible innovation that reaches the masses? From the article: >>"Mr Jones says that, from 1985 to 1997 alone, the typical “age at first innovation” rose by about one year." Hmmm .... we are in 2013. Why curate and quote a period from 1985 to 1997??