14 ms·
Aerial photography ban proposed for all but government
- urza 14y agoThis is wrong on so many levels. 1. Prohibition does not work. It has been tested many times over many decades. If people of New Hampshire are afraid of aerial photography how about this: When anyone (incl. government) wants to take pictures from drones over some area in N.H., they need to tell in advance and concerned property owners can permit or prohibit the action. 2. Sponsoring bills is a very strange practice to me (I am from Europe). I dont understand how this is democracy. 3. Government should be more restricted in what it can to than its citizens. Not the other way around. The world needs new law-making system(s). More democratic and rational.
- scarmig 14y agoIf I'm reading this right... it actually bans Google Maps while explicitly acknowledging the feds' right to use whatever drones they want? We need better small government advocates.
- sbhere 14y agoHow about just smaller government?
- greenrice 14y agoHow about just more efficient government with better representation of the populance?
- oleganza 14y agoHow about before talking about the size of the government, proving when and how using threat of murder is moral? Because government has "legal" and real power to kill you if you don't do what you are told. If you cannot prove it as good as some math theorem, then why don't you find some other ways to solve problems before killing people? Why not being able to find a peaceful solution justifies murderous solutions? Do you threaten others with death to believe you when you cannot prove your point peacefully and reasonably?
- baddox 14y agoDon't hold your breath for a "proof" involving morality.
- oleganza 14y agoI don't argue for use of violence and therefore I don't need to provide any justification for it. It's people who suggest laws and regulations as solutions need to prove why they can do that. Without a proof, it's just bullying and mob rule. Why is burden of proof is not on me? Because I don't stop the discussion by taking out a gun. If you don't agree with me you are always able to go away, or tell everybody to not talk to me because I'm not nice to others. No one kills anyone, everybody is free to agree to disagree. But whenever somebody gets angry that I disagree and takes out weapons, then it's up to him to explain why he is doing that.
- colanderman 14y agoWhy is burden of proof is not on me? Because you're arguing that representatives of the government's executive branch should not be able to use force to defend themselves when threatened with force. That violates the golden rule, which, being core to many moralities, places the burden of proof on you.
- oleganza 14y agoDon't you think, the representatives and their supporters need to justify their use of violence first? If not, then I can also end this discussion by killing you without justification. Example 1. Everyone thinks the Earth is flat, but I don't think so. Since everyone's senses indicate that it is flat and my idea is not self-evident, it is me who must provide sensual evidence. E.g. by showing that the horizon is limited and ships go under. Example 2. Many people think the god exists, but senses do not provide any common (objective) perception. More than that, if you show them that by behaving badly you don't get mysteriously evaporated, it's now their job to prove how and why the god exists. In other words, me and other people see a lot of evidence that some people kill other people, but we do not see a solid reason why some have a right to do so, while others do not. Then someone comes and says "it is democracy". Very well, but it is very far from being satisfactory answer and it has even more moral questions. E.g. how sudden increase of 50% audience by 1 person reverts their morality? Or what happens if older voters died and new were born? What are the "borders" within which you can use democracy, but outside - it's another jurisdiction? All of this stuff is 100% imaginary and outside of realm of sensual evidence. So it's your job to prove that these imaginary concepts have any ground. Quarks are imaginary, we cannot feel them directly or indirectly. So it's up to physicists to prove to anyone else that this imaginary model is useful at organizing all their real sensual knowledge in a coherent manner. And if they derive from quark theory that they can kill people - they have to prove it first.
- n3rdy 14y agoHow about embracing adulthood and using our own judgement to make our own decisions, rather than delegating our common sense to a group of people who clearly have little themselves.
- nhaehnle 14y agoThe problem is that most small government advocates are not actually working towards small government, but just towards a government that does what they want it to do. Or they use it as a general catchphrase to abuse the slightly schizophrenic attitude of most voters, who want less government spending in the abstract, but will actually favor more (or equal to current) government spending when asked about individual programs or departments of government.
- oleganza 14y agoThe smallest government in the history of the world, created 300 years ago turned out to be the largest and most destructive one in the history of the world. Suggestion: try to prove that the people who are identified with "the government" have different moral rights than you. Why they can have nukes and guns, while you cannot. And before you have a perfect conclusive proof, abstain from using any physical violence upon anybody around you. If you find a person, who will be convinced that the policeman can shoot at him when he runs away, while the person cannot shoot back, then you can shoot that person. But do not shoot those who are not so much convinced yet.
- CamperBob2 14y agoThe smallest government in the history of the world, created 300 years ago turned out to be the largest and most destructive one in the history of the world. Which government was that, and how'd they outdo the Soviets?
- oleganza 14y agoIt is US. And they outdid everyone precisely because they had the most of freedom. Free market created enormous amount of wealth and the government got its portion. Less free contries just were not that wealthy to afford massive military and other spendings. I'm not saying it was even possible to have anarchy back in 1796: the slavery and wife ownership was okay. But today we can learn from history and understand that it is possible to employ non-violent methods of conflict resolution using existing total connectivity. With internet, cheap and strong crypto, Bitcoin and social networks you can securely notify anyone you want about misbehavior of someone and use ostracism instead of prisons.
- ctdonath 14y agoNo. Government should never get a pass on a prohibition just because it's the government. Au contraire: save for very narrow instances (ex.: nuclear weapons) handled with intense care and oversight, government agents should be subject to any and all restrictions inflicted upon the populace at large. People have rights and delegate them to government as granted powers, not the other way around.
- baddox 14y agoOn the other hand, the only organizations in history to have developed, stockpiled, and used nuclear weapons are governments.
- mikeash 14y agoHow is that "the other hand", exactly?
- knowaveragejoe 14y agoEr, because in contrast to nuclear weapons anyone can build their own drone?
- sliverstorm 14y agoIs that due to technical obstacles, or the regulation around nuclear material? Nobody could build a drone either, if the government regulated access to microcontrollers like it regulates nuclear material.
- baddox 14y agoBecause ctdonath proposed nuclear weapons as an exception to the rule that governments shouldn't be exempt from laws and regulations.
- ctdonath 14y agoI used it as a catch-all phrase for whatever most people would consider a reasonable exemption from prohibition, and used it to avoid a prolonged derailment of the post's point. Most people would agree that possession of nuclear weapons should be prohibited. Insofar as other sovereign governments do have them and threaten to use them, and insofar as on rare occasion their use may arguably save more lives than non-use, most people would also agree their government may be exempted from an otherwise universal prohibition on possession of nuclear weapons. Hence the purpose of using the subject as a "code phrase" to make a point without getting derailed. Seemed an obvious, simple, and understandable literary tool at the time. Yes, the issue is somewhat moot as, until recently, nuclear weapons were something only governments had the resources to construct, maintain, and deliver. That civilian ownership is night unto impossible should have been obviously irrelevant to the point being made. That private manufacture IS becoming viable for the ultra rich (legal and societal prohibitions aside) makes the "but only governments are capable" point moot in turn. If I presented my personal views on individual civilian possession of nuclear weapons, a flame war would ensue with a great many impassioned respondents failing to hold any interest in understanding my view.
- webwanderings 14y agoThe most depressing documentary of all time I recently watched on public television: Rise of the Drones. And to top it off, the end credit suggested that the major funding of this program was provided by Lockheed Martin! You'd be better off not watching. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/military/rise-of-the-drones.html http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/military/rise-of-the-drones.htm...
- n3rdy 14y ago> You'd be better off not watching. Ignoring a problem usually doesn't make it less of a problem.
- webwanderings 14y agoWell you're right, but we can only watch. The world is slipping out of the hand with this technology and we can already tell where it is heading. So this isn't really a "problem" anymore, as much as it is a reality.
- ckvamme 14y agoSlipping out of hand?? Only watch?? No. Get involved, this tech isn't proprietary, it's all been opensourced, power to the people.
- j_s 14y agoWorth pointing out the video is available to stream directly from PBS at that link.
- j_s 14y agoClearly it's time for hobbyists to switch from making drones to making anti-drone rockets!
- n3rdy 14y agoSpark gap radios and Ku-Band jammers are handy too.
- protomyth 14y agouhm.... making drone - probable talk with FAA making anti-drone rocket - probable vigorous discussion with FAA, SWAT, ATF, DoD, and FBI with vacation in Caribbean
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoDefine the difference between an anti-drone rocket and a drone that oh whoops, sorry lost control there, is that your drone I crashed into ?
- protomyth 14y agointended versus unintended consequences and which Federal agency has authority
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoSorry, I meant intentionally crashing drone into drone - let's call it hunter killer drones. My ardu-pilot drone swarm can take out your million buck drone over the parts of the city I dont want you looking at. Probably. Saving that I will just laser your optics. I think disrupting technologies are orders of magnitude cheaper and more mobile than any government spec surveillance technology.
- protomyth 14y agoWell, you start with the FAA and NTSB then quickly get some serious involvement by the FBI (if it was and DoD or Border Patrol you are hosed). If it was the local cops drone, expect a visit from SWAT. Arming any type of aircraft is going to get you sent away for a very long time and lasers are a particular no-no with the FAA. We'll skip the basic "willful destruction of government property" and move right up into all the laws based on military grade weapons and terrorism.
- blhack 14y agoThere is absolutely no chance that this bill will pass. Crazy bills championed by people that either don't understand them, or are just posturing are semi-common. Just because it has been proposed, doesn't mean anything.
- ctdonath 14y agoAlas, enough of them pass with serious enough consequences that we do have to watch for and actively oppose them. Prime example is NY's recent passage of the "SAFE Act".
- jrockway 14y agoWhat's the problem with the SAFE Act? The provision where mental health providers have to become informants?
- ctdonath 14y agoThe provision making hundreds of thousands of cooperative upstanding law-abiding citizens into enemies of the state for owning common devices less dangerous than stairs.
- Millennium 14y agoThis century has already seen far too many crazy bills pass to just dismiss something like this as having no chance.
- nitrogen 14y agoThere is absolutely no chance that this bill will pass. There've been too many cases where it seemed this way, then the bill passed (or was only narrowly defeated), for us to ignore anything that appears to have no chance of passing.
- blhack 14y agoA bill like this would royally screw over the mapping, GIS, agricultural, real estate, and film industries, and those are only the ones I can think of off hand. I think we'll be okay.
- btbuildem 14y agoSo, let me get this straight: they're proposing to prohibit anyone who may actually contribute something valuable to society from using the technology, but give full license to those pretty much guaranteed to do evil with it?
- squozzer 14y agoThis sort of legal logic-twisting is more common than we like to admit. 1) Take a topic that has some legal buzz. 2) Draft a law that, on the surface, seems to do something about it while actually doing nothing or the opposite of what it seemed to intend. 3) Sit back and collect the cheers of the ignorant proles. e.g. Gun Owner's Protection Act of 1986, PATRIOT Act, ad nauseum.
- nekojima 14y agoWhen we fly over New Hampshire in a commercial plane, does this mean the captain or flight attendants will be obligated to tell us not to take photos of the state from the air, if any buildings are visible or identifiable as buildings based on other landmarks? Unbelievably this has been possible for well over a century (including use of air ships), only now has it become an issue for excessive regulation.
- jevinskie 14y agoAre roads not man made objects? Those are visible from very high altitudes!
- dmckeon 14y agoThis prohibition shall not apply where the image does not reveal forms identifiable as human beings or man-made objects. Seems like a poor distinction to me - "identifiable" by what? A human eyeball, infra-red, multi-spectral analysis? This would allow imaging of forests, fields, and streams, but not man-made objects like roads, bridges, dams, or the more navigable waters (might contain humans). Perhaps the sponsor expects image-creators to blur out anything that might be a human or man-made object? How would this affect the usage of self-driving cars? You could image a deer crossing the road, but not a human? (Note the prohibition is on image creation, not publication.)
- n3rdy 14y ago> This would allow imaging of forests, fields, and streams, but not man-made objects like roads, bridges, dams, or the more navigable waters (might contain humans). I wonder how much of a stretch it would be to imagine some court ruling that trees could be considered man-made objects if they were planted by humans.
- glesica 14y agoOr, more sinister, crops and other agricultural lands. Which would prevent monitoring by environmental groups for run-off control and such.
- protomyth 14y agowell if you want to think the worst in people... I would say this law would be a pain for farmers and ranchers that are taking the next steps in technology. Plus architects would get caught eventually.
- roc 14y ago> "How would this affect the usage of self-driving cars? " It wouldn't. Puzzlingly, this law seeks to ban aerial drone surveillance while explicitly allowing any surveillance, by person or drone, conducted by a device or person supported by the ground. So an aerial paparazzi drone would be illegal. But a veritable army of paparazzi ground drones, even ringing a property and photographing every inch of the same people and/or structures, would be legal.
- JVIDEL 14y agoI would agree if it wasn't for the recent report that FBI agents have illegally accessed the bureau's DB to look for dirt on famous/important people, either to sell that info to others or to blackmail them. Yet another case of "who watches the watchmen?"
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoAgain, we need laws that stipulate three new Techno-age rights * right to awareness of surveillance Surveillance is just sooo pervasive that trying to ban it is useless. Just require that any time anyone is able to identify or track an individual through video, data mining, or any other process, they are required to publish this within $time period - publish the date time location means and data used, along with the identifying data. * ? * ?
- PotatoEngineer 14y agoThat first one reduces your privacy even further: not only does Group A track you, but now everyone knows that Group A is tracking you, allowing Group B to ask Group A for data on you.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoBut now I know group b is tracking me too. Basically we have lost our privacy and we need some way of knowing who has what on us. Total transparency is the only answer - otherwise people can track me and it will never come to light - so punitive data protection measures will not work cos there is no obligation to report.
- tantalor 14y agoWouldn't this make more sense as a civil matter than than a criminal misdemeanor? Then you don't have to worry about breaking the law photographing your own property.
- crististm 14y agoHow do these bills pop-up anyway?
- protomyth 14y agoSome state lawmaker who doesn't think out the consequences of a bill or gets caught in one of those "think of the children" moments writes up a crappy law. I do believe in the 90's some extremely green (in many ways) congress-critter wrote a law that would basically make farming illegal in the USA and require quite a lot of buildings to be torn down (like the whole states of SD,ND, and WY). Bill did get some co-sponsors (tells you a little about the world there). One house rep pointed out due to the wording that all building within a mile of Central Park would have to be torn down. So ended the bill.
- CamperBob2 14y agoWatch "House of Cards" on Netflix if you have the opportunity. It seems pretty realistic.
- sbhere 14y agoSo the government wants everyone but the government to be restricted from something? Go figure!
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- j2d3 14y agoIf we make aerial cameras illegal, only criminals will have aerial cameras!
- DennisP 14y agoDavid Brin's Transparent Society gets more relevant every day. http://www.amazon.com/The-Transparent-Society-Technology-Between/dp/0738201448/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1361909242&sr=8-1&keywords=transparent+society http://www.amazon.com/The-Transparent-Society-Technology-Bet...
- martinced 14y agoYeah. And thankfully there's lots of hope in that (semi-old) David Brin essay. Technology is a multi-faceted dice and although the government is very powerful and lobbyist manage to get ever more restrictive laws passed each day, they simply cannot stop technological progress. "Police and thieves in the streets, scaring the nation with their guns and ammunitions" are getting filmed, photographed and arrested thanks to technology (even if the government desperately tries to ban that). There's hope and David Brin saw it a long time ago.
- tokenadult 14y agoFrom the article, "Neal Kurk (R), member of the New Hampshire House of Representatives since 1986 has recently sponsored HB 619-FN to make aerial photography illegal in their state, which many are considering a look into the future." This is a state-level proposal in one of the smallest states in the United States. All of the comments about the "federal" or "United States" government in this thread apparently aren't based on reading the fine article. Moreover, the text of the proposed bill, "A person is guilty of a class A misdemeanor if such person knowingly creates or assists in creating an image of the exterior of any residential dwelling in this state where such image is created by or with the assistance of a satellite, drone, or any device that is not supported by the ground. This prohibition shall not apply where the image does not reveal forms identifiable as human beings or man-made objects. In this paragraph, 'dwelling' means any building, structure, or portion thereof which is occupied as, or designed or intended for occupancy as, a residence by one or more individuals," could reasonably be construed as a privacy protection. (That's the context I would expect from New Hampshire, where the state motto is "Live free or die.") The first person quoted as a specific opponent of the bill in this article (which is more balanced than the comments in this thread) is a real estate photographer. Well, yeah, maybe I as an individual don't want multiple real estate agencies flying planes over my house to take photos, possibly when I am in my yard in view of airplanes and helicopters. Reasonable minds could take either side of this bill, but don't react to the link-bait headline, but to the actual text of the bill and its context among current business practice and other legislation. From the website's description of itself: "About us & our story "AGBeat is Business news, insights, tools, and inspiration for small business owners and professionals. AGBeat condenses news information on technology, business, small and medium business, NPO’s, social media, startups, real estate, economics and more, so you don’t have to. "In 2007, AGBeat began as Agent/Genius (AG) . Fed up and disgusted with the pay to play real estate space, we decided to radically change the face of news publishing by giving industry professionals a legitimate voice. "Successful to date in its fundamental mission, AG is a multi-award winning publication and its columnists and editors are named as some of the most influential in real estate, business, and in technology. AG is known for ripping the lid off of hot new technologies, startups, and mashups- everyone knows that if it’s on AG, it’s relevant. "In late 2009, AG took on News and Business News, seeking to disrupt a drab and boring, and mostly pay to play business publishing space and continues to bring honest coverage and insight to an eager audience. Because of AG’s footprint within the tech startup space and in the business category, we needed a way to expand our publication, and in 2011, we changed our masthead to AGBeat, launching a brand around Agent/Genius." http://agbeat.com/about/ http://agbeat.com/about/ Oh, so the link-bait headline comes from a group of real estate agents who want to spread alarm at their business actually being subjected to the rule of law. What a surprise.
- HeyLaughingBoy 14y agoWell there goes another business if this passes. I live on a small farm in (obviously) a rural area. There are people whose business model consists of coming to the front door to show you a small aerial photo of your house and asking if you want to buy the framed 18"x30" version. Not my cup of tea, but has it even begun to cross the minds of legislators in the mostly rural state of New Hampshire that there are many legitimate businesses that need to do aerial photography? Just when you thought you'd finally seen the bottom of the stupidity cup, you find there's still more to go!
- quink 14y agoMy high school, when I went there a decade ago, had an giant aerial photograph right at the reception. Crazy to think that it would be banned, but the map right next to that - which has an outline of every building and labels - wouldn't be. Which in turn makes me wonder whether this will give reason to ban maps of school campuses too. After all, school shootings happen so the solution could be to ban maps of schools :|
- gojomo 14y agoSociologist Max Weber in 1919 advanced the idea that the state is an entity which claims for itself a monopoly on the legitimatized use of violence. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly_on_violence http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly_on_violence A 21st-century Weber might instead identify the state as the entity claiming a monopoly on surveillance.
- oleganza 14y agoThe problem is not in surveillance. The problem is: "we will kill you if you decline to go to jail for doing aerial photography". That's what the law says. The surveillance is secondary.
- mimiflynn 14y agoKill? I read that it would be a Class A Misdemeanor.
- kevingadd 14y agoIf you reject their attempts to assert control over the path and processing of photons, eventually they will attempt to incarcerate you. They will do this with increasing degrees of force if you continue to resist. Eventually this resistance is classified as enough of a 'threat' to justify a police officer accidentally discharging half a clip into your back while you're on the ground. In self defense, of course. At least if you live in Oakland...
- n3rdy 14y agoI am loving the high concentration of anarchists in this thread, HN needs more anarchists. An uncaged mind thinks bigger than a caged one.
- colanderman 14y ago"we will kill you if you decline to go to jail for doing aerial photography" Where? What law? They're giving out the death penalty for misdemeanors now?
- fredBuddemeyer 14y agothe best part will be enforcement; each state can create an air force to protect us from such potential threats.
- neurotech1 14y agoTechnically they do. It's the Air National Guard, some who fly F-16s or even F-22 fighters. Of course, the Rules of Engagement are pretty restrictive, but they are available to protect a state from aerial threats. I doubt they'll use F-22s to take out little drones taking photos of someones backyard.
- run4yourlives 14y agoThis is one of those cases were google could wield it's near monopoly in mapping services for good. They should just simply decide to follow this law preemptively and eliminate all aerial imagery of New Hampshire tomorrow. Let the uproar from the public sort the law makers out.
- brk 14y agoDoes Google actually own the satellites taking the images, or are they licensing them (as was my understanding) from Federally-funded satellites?
- run4yourlives 14y agoI think most of the images are actually private aerial photographs.
- tamersalama 14y agoThe bill should be correctly labelled as giving exclusive rights to government for aerial photography. This is wrong.
- ipetepete 14y agoThis is ridiculous. People need to be educated on what they don't understand so the will stop being afraid and try to pass these unfounded, near-sited, knee-jerk legislations. If this goes more widespread, the government will be severely crippling my hobby, and some of my supplemental income.
- noonespecial 14y ago>some of my supplemental income. What you are doing now is likely already quite illegal. http://fstoppers.com/using-drones-faa-approval-photos-or-video-is-illegal http://fstoppers.com/using-drones-faa-approval-photos-or-vid...
- Anechoic 14y agoIs Kurk actively trying to stop all real estate and building development activity in his state? One of the first things that often happens when someone is planing a public or private development is that developer/architect/engineer commissions an aerial photo of the project area. It allows for more up-to-date photography of that specific (and surrounding) area than may be available from USGS or the state's GIS office and can help to identify and address any number of environmental concerns that come up in the permitting process. Yeah, government users are unaffected, but I have a box and multiple DVD's full of aerial photography commissioned by private clients. Development would have been constrained on those projects without those photos.
- wallawe 14y agoOh, but you can purchase an expensive license... from the government
- redthrowaway 14y agoA person is guilty of a class A misdemeanor if such person knowingly creates or assists in creating an image of the exterior of any residential dwelling in this state where such image is created by or with the assistance of a satellite, drone, or any device that is not supported by the ground. This prohibition shall not apply where the image does not reveal forms identifiable as human beings or man-made objects. In this paragraph, “dwelling” means any building, structure, or portion thereof which is occupied as, or designed or intended for occupancy as, a residence by one or more individuals. This would seem to criminalize GoPros on RC airplanes, strapping a camera to a balloon and recording its journey to the edge of space, and a bevy of other harmless applications. At best, this bill is ill thought-out.
- base698 14y agoOr skydiving with a camera if you look down. Oh dear don't look down it's a misdemeanor!
- mrb 14y agoThis law would make so many things illegal: news helicopters filming road traffic, taking pictures from your plane seat's window, from a valentine's day hot-air balloon ride, filming your skydive, etc.
- maxk42 14y agoLet's do it the other way around.
- leot 14y agoOne potential solution: require all drones (gov't included, unless there's a warrant) to publicly identify their location and operator if operated higher than, say, 20 feet.
- kdazzle 14y agolive free or die
- chris_mahan 14y agoI would prefer the opposite.
- stcredzero 14y agoNew Hampshire: Live Free or Spy Drone use should actually be a bigger citizen's rights issue than guns.
- matterhorn 14y agoThis is ridiculously broad. It serves as a great example of H.L. Mencken's famous quote, "For every complex problem, there is a solution that is simple, neat, and wrong."
- jacobmarble 14y agoI propose a law to ban unlicensed aerial photography by the government. Government entities shall announce, in public record, any flight intended to collect aerial photographs, before such flight is undertaken. The reason for the flight shall be declared in simple English, and all photographs shall become part of the public record. I trust (and know) the people in my neighborhood more than I trust the Ministry of Truth.
- logn 14y agoThis is an interesting issue. Normally I'm all for privacy but I think we need some way to allow for innovation yet still ensure privacy. Actually I think banning the government and allowing others is a starting point. I think maybe a petition or license-based system would be good. I'd hate for a software startup to be disallowed from taking pictures for some new innovative idea. I think Google Maps is really just the start of a whole wave of technology we'll see.
- jrockway 14y agoPrior restraint. Also, good luck enforcing New Hampshire law in space.
- eksith 14y agoIf they intend to ban arial photography from "any device that is not supported by the ground", they might as well ban all general aviation in New Hampshire. Or will there be fines and confiscations if you take a camera on your next flight? This is yet another unenforcable law. Why can't they make more sensible ones in NH like this nugget of gold? http://www.dumblaws.com/law/630 http://www.dumblaws.com/law/630
- vacri 14y agoHey, it's only illegal at night! I wonder what the thinking was behind that law. Edit: On second viewing, that's a highly suspect site. For example, for the UK it has 'Divorces are Outlawed'. For a start, they're actually not - that's the whole thing about the creation of the CofE, but more to the point, the 'Source' for the law is listed in its totality as "BBC 17 Nov. 1999", as if that would help us verify it.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]