3 ms·
I'll take the other point of view, as a) I haven't noticed this become problematic and b) engage in it myself, on occasion. My reasons, which I will write here
by patio11 18y ago
I'll take the other point of view, as a) I haven't noticed this become problematic and b) engage in it myself, on occasion.
My reasons, which I will write here to avoid having the world caught in a loop:
1) HN community norms require comments to be short and minimally formatted to avoid causing consternation on the thread. (People get upset if you do anything which causes line formatting to change. Big blocks of text which requiring scrolling past are right out.) Not all worthwhile thoughts are pithy and minimalist.
2) Keeping content on HN is perhaps a passable solution for the HN community, but the nature of the evolving discussion plus the fact that Google can't tell which comments are the 1% gem-like insights and which comments are the bottom 20% means that, from the perspective of the 99.999..% of humanity which isn't here, nothing on this site ever happened.
3) Troll might be the wrong D&D monster: lets try a dragon, with a horde of about 100,000 misc. coins, gems, art items, and magical items, and no filing system to speak of. (Oh, except you can call items back if you remembered to make note of their True Name.) Seriously -- permanence of comments leaves something very much to be desired. I know my favorite comment ever is http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=469940 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=469940 . You know how I found that? I Googled for the place offsite where I quoted him, and then followed the link back to the original.
4) A disinterested rational observer would note that over the course of a day the #1 story generally generates about 4,000 pageviews, almost 100% from highly technical ad-blind people, many of whom have noscript installed. Previous experience with that sort of audience leads me to believe that the economic value of an HNlanche is about $1 if that. As a get rich quick scheme it is inferior to Amazon Turk. (Posting articles is only a tool for SEO to the extent that a cynical, picky audience believes you are producing linkworthy content. I think anyone who gets a link here clearly put in enough work to deserve it.)
5) Linking out (and linking in) has salutary effects on preventing intellectual incest, groupthink, and ivory tower-ism. Or, to be blunt: when people talk about HN on their blogs its an opportunity to be exposed to a new community of readers as something other than a group of Erlang advocates with immense superiority complexes.
6) People have often requested a "super-upvote" or some similar method of signaling that a particular comment is significantly more important than the background noise. Posting offsite is a zero-programming-required implementation of a self super-upvote: it says "I thought what I was about to say was so important I went to the trouble of taking this offsite." Given that people do it very freaking seldom, that is a decent first approximation for "Wow, he sure feels strongly that this post adds value".
- swombat 18y agoMaybe one of us should write a blog post about this. Seriously, though, I agree with all the points above. I was going to type (some of) them myself, but since you've done such a great job of it, well done. It's also worth pointing out that writing a blog post that is loosely based on a comment that you made on HN is a chance to shape the conversation in a different direction, to explore a different facet of the argument. That's not always possible once a popular story has been drowned in a hundred comments, other than by posting your own blog post about it.
- mechanical_fish 18y agoThanks for the high praise for my old comment. Moreover, thanks for bringing it up, because if I had brought it up the following thoughts would be even less modest. ;) Now that we're on this subject, though, I have to confess that I have mixed feelings about that comment. On the one hand, I'm really proud of it. On the other hand, every time I think about it I have a vision of Seth Godin, dressed as the drill sergeant from Full Metal Jacket, shouting at me. ("WHY ISN'T THIS ON YOUR BLOG? YOU'VE WRITTEN SOMETHING PEOPLE LIKE. 37SIGNALS HAS LINKED IT. AND YOU HAVEN'T EVEN TOLD THEM YOUR REAL NAME! YOU'RE A DISGRACE TO MARKETERS EVERYWHERE!") It's kind of painful. [1] There's a lot more to say about this. [2] I think the fact that I can't quite figure out where I should put my own writing is a symptom of a problem with online conversation that has yet to be solved. (Though many have tried, and are still trying.) But rather than go on at great length in a comment I'll save it for that hopeless blog of mine. ;) I will say one thing now: I agree with the original submitter that the user experience of reading a link to a comment, rather than the comment itself, is horrible and frustrating and irritating. But I also agree with you: The alternative is bad as well. Because it's not as if you can adhere to a rule like "I will put my best work, the stuff I really want to preserve, on my blog; I'll reserve HN comments for random scribblings". Because your best work will probably be a random scribbling, at least when you first draft it. --- [1] www.michaelfbooth.com. There. Perhaps that will silence the voices in my head. [2] About the subject of blogs vs comments, that is. Not about me.