5 ms·
But what can we do? Kids will be kids, eh? End age based classes would be a good start.
by barry-cotter 14y ago
But what can we do? Kids will be kids, eh?
End age based classes would be a good start.
- moron4hire 14y agoAnd mandatory attendance. You can't force someone to learn when they don't want to. Stop treating schools like prisons and the attendees will stop acting like inmates.
- Nursie 14y agoSchool is a combination of daycare and training. We make it mandatory because otherwise the kids of the disadvantaged, the uneducated or the just-plain-disorganised wouldn't get a decent start in life. It also allows more people to work - someone else is looking after the kids. There's some argument to be had about what age it should be mandatory until, sure, but mandatory schooling is most definitely a good thing for society.
- moron4hire 14y agoMandatory schooling is more about keeping people OUT of the job market than it is putting people INTO it. If schools were about training, they'd look more like universities (and if universities were about advanced training, they'd look more like business environments). How many kids study to pass the test? How many teachers teach to get the kids to pass the test? And thereafter they forget everything. I see grown-ass adults who can't calculate a simple 20% tip on paper, and more who can't do it in their heads, and that's an EASY one. People, working in industry, who don't know that the US has 50 states. I've seen programmers with computer science degrees counting on their fingers to add numbers. Again, you can't teach something to someone who doesn't want to learn, and you can't prevent someone from learning who does want to. Schools get the credit for education, but they're just present. The mandatory aspect did nothing.
- Nursie 14y ago"you can't teach something to someone who doesn't want to learn" Pretty sure you can, when they're kids. Repeated exposure at the very least. I'm not going to address the rest of your comment, I disagree utterly with pretty much everything you've said there.
- stared 14y ago> mandatory schooling is most definitely a good thing for society. [citation needed] ...and on the other hand putting smart kids _willing_ to learn in an uninspiring and oppressive environment. (Bad for their learning and devastating for their still developing personality.) IMHO it's hard to find a worse crime against natural curiosity and willingness than _forcing_ people to do something.
- Nursie 14y agoSmart kids willing to learn - how do they know? How do we pick out these smart kids and make sure they get education? Even if they're not from good backgrounds? How do we get these smart kids out of their crappy homes and make sure somebody teaches them something, anything, unless it's mandatory? YOU may have been perfect, motivated, willing to learn, and may have been given the opportunity to learn even if it wasn't mandatory. Many others would not, many parents wouldn't bother.
- mnicole 14y agoIt was very noticeable to me, by second grade, who was there to learn and who was just there because they were forced to wake up and walk to a bus stop in the morning. While I was lucky enough to be put into some specialty classes based on previous testing I'd done, the majority of my day was still spent sitting next to kids who were literally drying glue in their desks, pouring ink into it to color it and eating it once it dried. There's nothing fundamentally wrong with those kids, they just need a different direction and a little more support.
- Nursie 14y agoCan't disagree with that. But at that age some of the 'forced to wake up and walk to the bus-stop' kids still have a long way to grow and change. I don't know the system in the US very well. Kids can go to different sorts of colleges post-16 here in the UK, or could (until recently, this may have changed) opt out at that age and enter the workforce.
- stared 14y ago
- king_jester 14y ago> We make it mandatory because otherwise the kids of the disadvantaged, the uneducated or the just-plain-disorganised wouldn't get a decent start in life. For most of the "disadvantaged, the uneducated or the just-plain-disorganised", as you put it, mandatory school attendance does nothing to solve their problems anyway, as the people you are thinking of have many systemic things running against them in addition any personal issues in their lives. > There's some argument to be had about what age it should be mandatory until, sure, but mandatory schooling is most definitely a good thing for society. Mandatory school isn't the same thing as doing something positive for communities. Some communities will find the policy beneficial, others will find it destructive (esp. when some kids are forced into school systems are that literal prisons, complete with metal detectors, cell phone lockers you pay out of pocket for, and frequent searches of all student belongings).
- Nursie 14y ago"mandatory school attendance does nothing to solve their problems anyway" I disagree that it does nothing. Some people still get the opportunity to better themselves through education, even if it doesn't help everyone. Schools becoming prisons is a weird US phenomenon, I think you have societal issues to tackle that are much bigger than schooling. And it's still better to have kids given access to education under those circumstances than not at all (and without it being mandatory they would not have access. No, they wouldn't)
- moron4hire 14y agoso "we" have to provide mandatory schooling and a value judgement on what constitutes the "correct" schooling, but "you" have to deal with societal issues.
- Nursie 14y ago"we" in most western countries do tend to provide schooling to our children and make it mandatory "you" in America seem to have some extra problems in this area, which I still don't think overshadows the benefits Yes, problem?
- babarock 14y agoI completely agree that age-based classes is stupid. But what's the alternative? The idea of classifying 5 year old kids based on any kind of factor scares the hell out of me.
- polymatter 14y agoErm, what scares you about ability-based classes? The single strongest motivator for me to do well at school was to get into the top set which was free from bullies.
- thejteam 14y agoThe problem with ability based groupings across age groups is that doesn't take into account learning velocity, ie the speed at which people learn new things. For example, a second grader that is at a fourth grade math level is likely to learn much faster than a fifth grader at a fourth grade math level. And you don't want to put advanced 8 year olds in a class with slow 11 year olds. That in itself is an invitation to bullying. Ability based learning within age groups makes perfect sense, but assumes a sample size large enough to make meaningful groupings at the high and low ends.
- moron4hire 14y agoThe problem is the classroom environment itself. The lecture format is an antiquated relic. We don't ever do the lecture format again once we leave school, which I think is pretty good evidence that it's garbage. You might submit conferences as a counterexample, but I would submit them in favor of my argument.
- thejteam 14y agoI firmly agree with you that classroom lectures are garbage. We homeschool our children. I'm simply making the point that, at least among younger children, age based classes are preferable to skill-based classes. A preferable alternative in my mind would be a classroom where ALL work is done independently. The teacher then calls each student to their desk individually to see what they have learned and what they need help with. They can then spend 10-15 minutes individually with each student per day. Fast students can get pushed ahead and slow students can get the help they need instead of being forced along with the rest of the class.
- coldtea 14y agoBecause getting bullied from kids 2-3 years old would be so much better?