7 ms·
If you think ostensibly "flat" social structures can't be gamed in stunningly unpleasant ways, then I have a bridge to every 1970s anarcho-syndicalist commune i
by jacques_chester 14y ago
If you think ostensibly "flat" social structures can't be gamed in stunningly unpleasant ways, then I have a bridge to every 1970s anarcho-syndicalist commune in Brooklyn for sale.
- ionforce 14y agoThe difference here is that there is a high barrier of entry. The people accepted to work at Valve are allegedly elite and compatible with this flat structure. I don't think communes are as rigorous about admission.
- jacques_chester 14y agoI think high barriers lower, but cannot prevent, the incidence of shenanigans. But good point.
- columbo 14y ago>The people accepted to work at Valve are allegedly elite and compatible with this flat structure. That or the people that have niched themselves into positions of unwritten-but-assumed authority have decided to hire quiet followers. Just because someone calls an environment a 'flat system' doesn't make it true. There exists just as likely, a very defined system controlled by seniority.
- rmah 14y agoHeh, to me that makes it sounds like the politics it would be worse at Valve, not better.
- ionforce 14y agoWhy would the politics be worse? You are supposedly hiring people who are culturally compatible, possibly apolitical.
- networked 14y ago>The difference here is that there is a high barrier of entry. An even bigger difference might be that the financial goals Valve has as a community are more clear than the goal of "build a good anarcho-syndicalist commune". In my experience communities that have a goal to pursue that's external to the existence of the community are the ones that last while those that don't tend to descend into high school-like popularity contests and fail because of that. BTW, is there anything HN would recommend reading on 1960s-1970s communes and, especially, ways in which they failed?