3 ms·
One main difference is that public companies are required by law to have independent auditors. Government departments are not. In Australia independent audits
by jacques_chester 14y ago
One main difference is that public companies are required by law to have independent auditors.
Government departments are not.
In Australia independent audits rely on the Australian National Audit Office, which is profoundly and deliberately underfunded because of its annoying habit of discovering embarrassing incompetence and wastefulness.
- cynwoody 14y ago>One main difference is that public companies are required by law to have independent auditors. Also, companies can go broke. Compared to that sanction, independent auditors are a band-aid.
- Spooky23 14y agoBig companies can persist for decades with endemic corruption. In public sector, the audit process is incredibly painful, and you're going to end up losing a career and pension over malfeasance. I've seen it happen a few times. Once you start operating outside the lines, you're likely to escalate and will get caught. More offensive to me are the folks who understand the system intimately and waste time & treasure legally. I've seen cases where a government used a big govt contractor to install PCs -- at cost of $120/hr for two guys and a truck. Offensive? Yes. Illegal? No.
- arethuza 14y ago"companies can go broke" Apart from the "too big to fail" banks...
- gaius 14y agoTell that to Lehman Bros. Oh wait, you can't, they went broke.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThat's not actually as important as the key main difference. Governments spend YOUR money, companies spend their own money. On top of that, companies are subject to competition and, as cynwoody pointed out, they can go out of business. This means that the incentives for reducing fraud are greater in private business and companies that have high levels of fraud that are easily reigned in by obvious solutions will be at a huge competitive disadvantage and more likely to simply go away.
- Mvandenbergh 14y agoCompanies are not natural persons any more than governments are, they don't have their own money. The difference is that shareholders are better at demanding independent audits than voters are.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThe government takes money from people involuntarily, corporations receive money due to voluntary transactions. If I never buy a product from Apple or Exxon, there's no problem with that. If I don't pay taxes I go to jail.
- Mvandenbergh 14y agoThat's true, but it doesn't change the fact that a corporation is not spending its own money either. That money belongs to the shareholders in the same way that tax receipts belong to citizens. Actually you would expect taxpayers to be even more vociferous in pushing audit requirements on government departments than shareholders are in ensuring their portfolio companies are correctly audited.
- jeltz 14y agoYour comparison is incorrect. The citizens of a company are its shareholders, not its customers. And if you are a shareholder the company is indeed spending YOUR money.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoBecoming a shareholder is voluntary. And if you discover that a company is not doing enough to prevent fraud then you can divest yourself of that company. This in itself is another form of negative feedback which exists much more strongly for corporations than for government. Because individuals divesting themselves of a public stock company will result in the stock price dropping which will have a negative impact on the company, encouraging it to do something about the problem.
- wisty 14y agoAustralia isn't that badly off - at least the governments have to do accrual accounting. Most countries don't, because it's too much work. As a consequence, when most countries release their budgets, expenses can be hidden for the next guy to reveal. And lazy assets don't burn a whole in spending. Imagine if the US government had to admit how much it was "spending" on rent (taking up land which could otherwise be used by the private sector). A $20,000 router isn't an "investment", it's a burn of $4,000 a year over the 5 years it's in use. The reason accrual accounting is used in large companies is, when ownership and management is separated, you need to ensure the managers give an accurate picture of what they have spent.