3 ms·
Couple of things: 1) Does this actually exist? The video looks SWEET, but feels like it's way to computer generated and too flawless (in the video) to be true.
by mbesto 14y ago
Couple of things:
1) Does this actually exist? The video looks SWEET, but feels like it's way to computer generated and too flawless (in the video) to be true.
2) I believe gesture control will never full take over our computing needs. Reason being, the feedback response from our skin's nerve endings are quicker than the feedback from our eyes. In other words - 'gorilla arm' - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Touchscreen#.22Gorilla_arm.22 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Touchscreen#.22Gorilla_arm.22 Furthermore, we'll continue to assume that touch-based and gesture-based systems will replace all machines and computers, when I believe this is simply not true. Our muscles were not built to work efficiently by "waving into the air". For some applications this is true, but not all.
- grinich 14y agoYeah, it exists. And for your second question: "gorilla arm" depends on where you have your hands-- if you keep them below your heart, you can gesture almost indefinitely without fatigue. This is obvious for people who use a lot of hand gestures when talking, or those who speak with sign language.
- knowaveragejoe 14y agoI think the better question is: is it really as seamless/flawless as the video portrays? Some of the clips imply integration with systems that largely don't exist in the way they're showing them(ski HUDs are real, but not like that). Another notable omission is in the video game sequence - we never see them turn the camera in any direction. I don't think that would be possible with this system alone.
- Smirnoff 14y agoYou can always use a second one on your left arm to turn the camera around. That's how joystick solved that problem :)
- andrewflnr 14y agoI think it has less to do with "below your heart" than with "shoulders not required to hold up your arms".
- TrevorJ 14y agoThe main issue I see with gesture controls is that compared to traditional inputs, you are doing more work and making bigger movements. For certain situations, like gaming, where 1:1 movement can be immersive this makes sense. For others it does not. I do think a system that allowed you to use small hand and finger movements to control your devices make sense. The large gestures don't seem to be optimal in most cases.
- tobyjsullivan 14y agoYeah, I too hope it is more than just vaporware. That hesitation doesn't actually come from their presentation specifically, aside from maybe looking too polished, just general experience with similarly styled launches. The faster they get this in the hands of real people/reviewers, the better. It looks great. Nintendo would love it, hehe.
- dchichkov 14y agoThey must have shown some demo of some prototype. At least I don't see how else they could have passed YC interview. Either way I really like the approach. Start with some sensor that has good ergonomics (wrist band), do some awesome machine learning trick and get a gadget from the future as a result.