8 ms·
Tesla says it lost “hundreds” of orders after New York Times controversy
- tokenadult 14y agoI thought the reporting on the Q4 results that Tesla released last week [checks story] showed that some of those order cancellations preceded the publication of the New York Times story. Yep, "Tesla expects to deliver 20,000 Model S cars this year. Right now, with its production line just getting into gear, it takes time for Tesla to fulfill its orders. As a result, there is a backlog of reservations. "Tesla said 15,000 cars were reserved at the end of last year, below its expectation that it will deliver 20,000 cars this year. The company added 6,000 new reservations in the fourth quarter, which makes the 20,000 target look achievable. "However, Tesla’s numbers suggest that a few thousand reservations were canceled in the fourth quarter. (Update: The Tesla spokeswoman Shanna Hendriks later said the company had 1,500 cancellations in the fourth quarter). Many customers were in line but pulled out when it became time to make a substantial down payment in cash." http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2013/02/20/teslas-earnings-indicate-some-customer-cancellations/ http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2013/02/20/teslas-earnings-indic... Investors looking at basic customer appeal issues like that seem to think that Tesla Motors stock may not have as much upside as it appeared to have before the fourth quarter financial results were announced. https://www.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ:TSLA https://www.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ:TSLA
- stephengillie 14y agoIt's not immediately clear how much of the stock drop was caused by the Q4 numbers, and how much was caused by uncertainty from the NYT story. But while the NYT story can affect the stock price drop, it can not have any effect on the Q4 numbers. I'm not sure from the article, but it sounds as though Tesla had 15,000 2013 orders by Q3 2012. Then, during Q4 2012, they added 6,000 orders for 2013, and had 1500 people unable to pay their 2013 down payment, which would leave their 2013 orders at 19,500. This is 500 cars short of Tesla's projected 20,000. If these 500 were all Roadsters, wouldn't the projected 2013 sales shortfall be around $5 million? It's odd that they report so many people placing orders, then balking at the down payment. It's an odd item to be reporting, I don't know if other auto manufacturers report this. Maybe they should require the down payment at an earlier point in their checkout process, to remove these superfluous tire-kickers from the corporate statistics? It's got to be embarrassing to announce that ~8% of your customers decided to cancel at the last moment.
- lawnchair_larry 14y ago> It's got to be embarrassing to announce that ~8% of your customers decided to cancel at the last moment. Isn't this normal in that business? People back out of car purchases all the time. Cold feet, financing falls through, better deal elsewhere, etc. I don't know what percentage is business as usual, but 8% doesn't seem high. I do agree that it's an odd thing to report.
- slantyyz 14y ago>> It's an odd item to be reporting, I don't know if other auto manufacturers report this. That's because it's the dealers who handle down payments for most auto manufacturers (in North America, at least). There's an arm's length relationship between the dealers and manufacturers. Tesla sells its own cars and would therefore have direct access to this data.
- tlrobinson 14y ago"It's got to be embarrassing to announce that ~8% of your customers decided to cancel at the last moment." I could be wrong, but if those include people who just put down $5k to hold their spot in line years before the car was released, then 8% isn't surprising at all. I know at least one person who decided not to go through with the purchase for reasons that have nothing to do with Tesla or the ability to pay the down payment.
- mistercow 14y ago>I thought the reporting on the Q4 results that Tesla released last week [checks story] showed that some of those order cancellations preceded the publication of the New York Times story. But in that article, they mention 1500 cancellations, while Musk is only attributing "a few hundred" to the NYT article. That makes it sound like he's compensating for the baseline cancellations they were having at the time.
- revelation 14y agoBefore the NYT story, Tesla slightly increased prices and made those with reservations either commit now or bite the increased prices afterwards. That certainly drove a lot of the cancellations.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoInteresting strategy. Like tokenadult comments, some cancellations occurred before the NYT article. In any sort of 'high dollar' purchase like this there is a certain percentage of buyers who, after time, get cold feet. There are also people who clearly speculated that having a spot in line with a reservation could be arbitraged for a quick gain. People who run businesses are quite careful to distinguish between the 'sales funnel' and 'sale commitments' and 'booked sales.' As more and more cars get out there, there will be a more likely chance of 'knowing' someone who has one (within a degree or two of separation) and so a more durable 'consensus' of whether or not they are worth the expense will surface. I wouldn't panic as long as their book to bill ratio is > 1.0 but once they catch up, things will get interesting.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- OGinparadise 14y agoIf had to base a decision on Musk's behavior I, too, would have cancelled. This also backfired on Musk, IMO, as more potential buyers learned about Tesla's weak points.
- gutnor 14y agoThat is what I was thinking during this whole affair - if I buy a Tesla I sure hope I will not make the front page of a website like Reddit with a negative opinion of my car. ( I have posted in the past a humoristic picture of my broken down car on my way to an interview ) Tesla goes straight for the jugular, and considering I'm a nobody I don't know what they would do to my reputation online, because of my 5 min of unwanted fame.
- gte910h 14y agoHonestly, living in a warmer climate, all the retests, etc, made me completely unconcerned with Tesla range now. Still too expensive for me for a depreciating asset, but I now think the S far less toy and far more reasonable car that's not so great for road trips, but CAN do it.
- crazygringo 14y ago> "And lots of people said that it does not matter if you're right or wrong, you do not battle the New York Times. To hell with that. I would rather tell the truth and suffer the consequences even if they are negative." Well, only if it's good PR. Because if a CEO would rather tell the truth and suffer negative consequences because of it... they're not really qualified to be CEO then. When you're running a company with investors' money, you'd better be more mature and intelligent about things than worrying about who's "right" and "suffer the consequences". Because you don't come across as professional, you risk coming across as unhinged.
- hvs 14y agoAnd, as you intimated, a CEO has a fiduciary responsibility to the board and stockholders. Doing something that you know is going to have negative consequences for your company could be seen as failing to do honor that responsibility.
- _delirium 14y agoThe fiduciary duty is taken pretty broadly and with a long-term perspective, however; courts don't generally second-guess strategic decisions. For example, Musk could plausibly argue that the company's long-term reputation with its target audience depends on being seen as brusquely honest. A court is typically not going to get into trying to determine if that's true or not.
- brousky 14y ago> Well, only if it's good PR. Because if a CEO would rather tell the truth and suffer negative consequences because of it... they're not really qualified to be CEO then. and herein lies the problem with Corporate America
- sukuriant 14y agoFor telling the truth? You can paint the truth in a positive light; or say "yes, this is where we were weak, and this is how we're going to fix it. These are problems in the past, and this is how we fixed them, so you see we have a track record of improvement." I'd buy that stock.
- blhack 14y agoPeople must be pretty on the fence about the car if all it took was one article to sway their opinion into not buying a car. The NYT article did highlight a major problem with electric vehicles: when you get the batteries really cold, their reported charge can be non-reflective of their actual range. I never leave my Jeep overnight and wake up to seeing the gas gauge report only half of what is actually in the tank. If this was a thing that was possible, Jeep would be back to their drawing boards figuring out how to fix it, not chiding a reporter for pointing it out. I hope everybody following this read the NYT reporter's response: http://wheels.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/02/14/that-tesla-data-what-it-says-and-what-it-doesnt/ http://wheels.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/02/14/that-tesla-data-w...
- niggler 14y agoMusk has a convenient scapegoat here. The reality is that we haven't seen really cold weather in a long while here in the NYC metro area, and the NYT article revealed a major issue. Many people believed we wouldn't see such weather in the future, so that risk wasn't on their minds (and as mentioned ad nauseum elsewhere, tesla didn't mention this in any marketing material except for saying that you can leave the car unplugged at the airport). Now having seen cold weather, people are asking what happens, and Musk's response installs little confidence in the Layman's view
- jpollock 14y agoThe amount in the tank is entirely different from the range it represents, which is also modified by environmental conditions such as altitude and temperature. The difference between the two situations is the number of places that you can refill the tank. Diesel drivers (in the US), have similar concerns to the electric car driver.
- Someone 14y agoThe number of places you can, the speed at which you can, the relative frequency at which you have to refill all work against electric cars at the moment. Diesel, AFAIK, is better of in the sense that you can drive farther without refilling. Also, for both petrol and diesel, customers can somewhat reliably estimate how far a tank will carry them. Part of that is experience, but for now, I have the impression that Tesla, with all its electronics, cannot even break even with 'normal' cars at that single measure. They are working hard on refill speed and refill locations and I expect they are working hard on their battery control systems to improve remaining range estimates. I think they need all three to create a viable mass market product.
- cafard 14y agoIs a long drive in cold weather really the general use case for Tesla? It seems to me to be a commuting car for the well-off early adopter.
- TylerE 14y agoThat's kind of the point. Tesla is pushing this as the "ready for general use" version. The Roadster was the early adopter special.
- base698 14y agoGiven how many people in California go to Tahoe and Mammoth for a weekend, I think cold weather driving is a must. That would stop me from buying one.
- DanBC 14y agoWouldn't you want a bigger car for Tahoe, to fit the skis, snowboards, etc? (Also, Californian roads, snow chains, etc) But, as for cold, Tesla apparently have lots of Scandinavian customers who live in very cold places and they seem to do okay. I have no idea how to say "My car died in the cold" in any of the Scandinavian languages, so I can't search for reviews.
- taligent 14y agoScandinavian countries are also quiet small in size so you aren't likely to be too far from a charger in the event something does go wrong.
- Shivetya 14y agoWell regardless of the facts of the NYT article the facts Tesla revealed don't make me want one. I read nearly every article I can on this car and similar. I want to know where the industry is going and what is working and what is not. I think like motorcycles of yesterday electric vehicles need a reserve, something that does not register in range calculations. Something that lets you heat or cool the cabin, something that gets you by that oops moment, detour, or just bad luck. That and better software for representing range and to top that off, forcing the car's dynamics to always favor range and make people choose otherwise. The current breed of cars favors the enthusiast, the problem is that they aren't the only ones with money to buy.
- DanBC 14y ago> electric vehicles need a reserve, something that does not register in range calculations. Something that lets you heat or cool the cabin, something that gets you by that oops moment, detour, or just bad luck. They do have a reserve. The reserve doesn't figure into range calculations. You can heat or cool the cabin. You can have an oops moment, you can have a detour. What you can't do is allow the car to discharge, then give it much less charge than is needed for your journey, and then ignore the obvious warnings ("You want to drive over 60 miles. You only have enough charge for 30 miles. A good idea to keep charging.") and drive away knowing that you don't have enough energy to get to your destination.
- cube13 14y agoHow does the loss of a few "hundred" orders translate to a net loss of $100 million? Assuming that all of the orders are the top-end Model S or Roadsters, a few hundred loss sales would translate to lost revenue in the low tens of millions of dollars.
- martythemaniak 14y agoA lot of people are of the opinion that Musk should not have called out the NYT and taken a much more laid-back line. But consider for a minute the Iraq war - years after the start many people still believe that Saddam was directly involved in 9/11. Once people form an impression, even if that impression is completely, utterly and factually wrong, it will persist for a long time. Right now is a very crucial time for EVs and Tesla in particular when this popular impression is being formed. If nonsense like "Electric cars don't work in the cold" gains traction, it will be very bad for the industry. And if you think that quote sounds ridiculous, it is exactly the take-away a casual reader would have gotten from that NYT review. Remember, to this day a sizeable chunk of the population still believes Saddam was directly involved in 9/11. So I say, Musk did the right thing - if you don't defend yourself, you might end up with nothing to defend.
- lotso 14y ago>If nonsense like "Electric cars don't work in the cold" gains traction Well, isn't that kind of true? Obviously, EVs work, but the cold weather has a large impact on batteries.
- PotatoEngineer 14y agoThat's the point - it's "kind of" true. But the takeaway from that NYT article is "you'll get stranded," which is much more painful than the truth: "be careful in the cold."
- lotso 14y agoI read the NYT article. The takeaway for me was that there are serious problems with the car in cold weather. Regardless of it is "kinda of" true, cold weather concerns aren't "nonsense."
- adestefan 14y agoEspecially since being stranded in 0F weather without working heat is a really big deal.
- jmpeax 14y agoHow embarrassing for NYT. My goofy cousin ran out of gas on the highway, maybe NYT can publish his story too.
- drucken 14y agoHead of Edmunds car review site reports that the Model S's on-board touchscreen failed: https://twitter.com/edmunds_test/status/306067589589774336 https://twitter.com/edmunds_test/status/306067589589774336 The Twitter conversation is ... interesting! BSOD in an electric car, what will Musk say this time?
- kamaal 14y agoWhoa!!! The thread says that pressing both the steering buttons reboots the software(Read: The whole car). This is purely WTF!
- danso 14y agoFor someone who used the "we have the data and the data proves we're right" approach, something just feels off in what Musk is quoted as saying: > "We did actually get a lot of cancellations as a result of The New York Times article. It probably affected us to the tune of tens of millions, to the order of $100 million, so it's not trivial,” Elon Musk, the chief executive, said on Monday. “I would say that refers more to the valuation of the company. It wasn't as though there were 1,000 cancellations just due to The New York Times article. There were probably a few hundred." "Probably" a few hundred? Can't he be certain how many car orders have been canceled? And in what time period, and how long of time period, did these cancellations take place? And how does this rate compare to other periods in time? And if he's going to claim that the impact was non-trivial, then why leave so much fuzziness in the interpretation of how much was lost in direct car sales and how much through a loss of valuation? The use of data, as it did in his rebuttal to the NYT, would help his case here. But in this interview he sounds like someone just throwing out rumors he heard from someone in the finance department.
- mistercow 14y agoHe knows how many were canceled. He doesn't know exactly how many were canceled because of the NYT article.
- ZeroMinx 14y agoNot all cancellations will have been because of the NYT piece, so no, he can't be certain how many car orders were cancelled because of it. Also, there is probably a feeling that some would-be orders were not placed because of the article. Quite hard to quantify that.
- stephengillie 14y agoTesla currently only makes 2 cars: the Roadster, which sells for about $100,000, and the Model S, which sells for around $50,000. To reach $100 million in canceled sales, 1000 Roadster orders or 2000 Model S orders would have to be cancelled. If a few hundred meant 300 cancelled orders, then their losses would be limited to between $15-30 million. So the 2 sentences reflect a disparity of at least 700 cars. I wonder if someone is trying to confuse the 1500 cancellations in Q4 with the cancellations caused by the NYT article. 1500 cancellations would represent around $100 million in cancelled sales, and this was announced at about the same time as the NYT article.
- jrochkind1 14y ago“I would say that refers more to the valuation of the company. It wasn't as though there were 1,000 cancellations just due to The New York Times article. There were probably a few hundred." Huh, he's talking about HIS OWN QUOTE about "hundreds of millions lost", he has to GUESS what he himself meant? He doesn't know _exactly_ what he meant when he said they were "affected" "to the tune of tens of millions, to the order of $100 million." He has to hazard a guess "I would say that refers mostly" about his own quote? I guess he did say "probably" in the first place. Yes, he's just making shit up. The more he goes, the less trustworthy he seems.
- greggman 14y agoHe just needs to invest in this and outfit the next Tesla with Super Supercapacitors. http://vimeo.com/51873011# http://vimeo.com/51873011# Charge your car faster than you can fill it with gas? Yes please ;-)
- migrantgeek 14y agoInstead of attacking the NYT, why not just let another paper do the same test with the same car? There may be an issue with that particular car, the journalist could be bias or the battery may just not perform well in cold weather. It’s hard to tell without additional testing. I don’t see why all the focus is on who said what. Just re-run the test a few times to try to repro. That’s what I’d do if someone had an issue with a piece of code I’d written.
- confluence 14y agoI'm a TSLA stockholder and the article and this entire brohaha don't particularly bother me. The Model S is the best luxury sedan on the market, orders are backed up for most of this year's capacity, and 100s of orders are coming in every month. Furthermore, the factory they run to build the entire thing is just incredible (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qvPosSzUGVI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qvPosSzUGVI). I used the recent 10% drop to significantly add to my TSLA position. Please - continue doubting TSLA, shorting it and selling the stock - you're doing me, and other TSLA investors a great favour. I always hate it when prices on stocks I want go up - it means I can't buy anymore :(
- robomartin 14y agoI am not taking sides in terms of the Tesla vs. NYT issue. I will say that anyone who cancels an order for a bleeding-edge car based on an article like this is a moron. You, more than likely, don't want such a person as a customer. They'll bitch and complain about anything and everything and be nothing but collective pains in the ass. I've been in complex hardware manufacturing before and I can say that, almost without fail, the customers who would flip on you based on forum posts, hearsay or such articles/reviews are a total waste of your time. They were just looking for a reason not to buy and found it. Good riddance. How can an article that is NOT the result of a rigorous scientific evaluation process be used for anything other than entertainment is beyond me. At best one could call it a potentially interesting "unverified data point" and move on.