2 ms·
"Notice however, that on these devices, it's the general-purpose CPU dominating, leaving the FPGA as a configurable peripheral, subordinate to the dense, pre-de
by VLM 14y ago
"Notice however, that on these devices, it's the general-purpose CPU dominating, leaving the FPGA as a configurable peripheral, subordinate to the dense, pre-designed silicon."
Ah yes exactly. I would not translate machine language or C into raw asynchronous VHDL I'd stick a real or virtual core in the FPGA and create the worlds most amazing accelerator peripheral to make the CPU little more than a UI and a DMA controller to keep the accelerator fed.
You don't implement your video game's title page in discrete (emulated) FPGA logic. You put your 3-d graphics engine in the FPGA and leave the author credits in plain old CPU memory.
"For example, one student implemented a large number of PWM oscillators on an FPGA where it would have been much simpler to use the debugged, verified, PWM peripherals on microcontrollers"
Totally missing the point. You want 768 PWMs to run 768 servos you instantiate 768 VHDL and an onboard proc to set them up and/or UI, all done. Not all that much harder than running 1. You are not going to find 768 PWM outputs on any single chip microcontroller that I'm aware of. Actually you aren't going to find a 768+ pin microcontroller out there anywhere, although thats kinda fat its not unheard of for a FPGA. You want one PWM output, yeah you use an off the shelf PIC, but that doesn't scale. Also don't make a plain old generic PWM when you need a servo controller. Make the worlds best hardware dedicated servo controller (which is, at its core, basically a PWM, but add extensive offset and calibration registers, and maybe limit registers, and sensible hardware default on boot positions and all that, and maybe integrated hardware backlash correction, thats how you make a servo controller, not just "make a PWM" that later gets turned into a servo controller)
"often a separate clock crystal. They are high-maintenance"
This is a bit WTF the guy isn't too far off until he gets to this kind of stuff.